Conference Agenda
| Session | ||
TUE1-06: Banco de México Special Session: Access and Use of Credit
| ||
| Presentations | ||
Monetary Policy Tightening and SME Bank-Credit Demand Substitution 1Trinity College Dublin, Ireland; 2Central Bank of Ireland; 3Central Bank of Ireland Since July 2022, European Central Bank (ECB) increased its interest rates for the first time in eleven years to bring inflation back to target. This has huge implication on the credit decision for firms, especially the small and medium enterprises (SME), instrumental in supporting employment, innovation and income. Using ECB's `Survey on Access to Finance of Enterprises' (SAFE) from 2015 to 2023, this paper assesses if the ECB's monetary policy tightening bears any relationship with SME's substituting away from bank credit towards alternative sources of finance. Our results show that contractionary monetary policy shocks were positively associated with the likelihood of SME's substituting away from bank credit. We find this behaviour across SMEs with larger turnover, employee size, age, as well as credit-quality; indicating a much stronger reliance and stickiness to bank credit for relatively smaller, younger, and riskier firms despite increases in the cost of credit following contractionary monetary policy shocks. When the Dam Almost Breaks: Disasters and Credit Risk 1Deutsche Bundesbank; 2Vienna University of Economics and Business; 3Goethe University How does risk perception in credit markets change after observing a nearby catastrophic event? We combine detailed geospatial data on ex-ante flood risk of German firms with credit register data and show that after a major flood in 2021, loan rates \emph{decrease} for high-flood risk firms that were not directly affected. This negative indirect effect is strongest for banks with a large loan portfolio exposure to the flood. Firms that were affected by earlier, but similar floods do not experience rate reductions. The decrease is also strongest in areas with low climate change belief, while high climate change belief areas experience rate increases. Overall, our evidence points to a novel near-miss effect in lending markets after natural disasters, where a close disaster ``miss'' may be misinterpreted as a reduction in fundamental risk. Government-guaranteed credit and populism European Central Bank, Germany The phenomenon of political populism and its financial determinants have proved elusive. We utilise the sudden and uneven change in credit conditions during the COVID-19 pandemic and the unprecedented government credit guarantee programme in France to investigate whether liquidity support to firms affects political preferences. Drawing on credit registry data – which provides the universe of loans and credit lines to firms – we build a postcode-municipality-level dataset and show that government-guaranteed credit reduced the support for the far right but increased it for the incumbent. The underlying economic channel shows that credit guarantees preserved employment, which in turn influenced political preferences. Effects are driven by microenterprises, predominantly self-employed businesses in which the employee-owner-voter is fully aware of the government financial support, i.e., where government support is more salient. This study does not aim to evaluate policies to address the popularity of populist politics. Credit Use, Credit Delinquency Rates and Remittances 1Banco de México, Central Bank of Mexico, Mexico; 2Universidad Iberoamericana; 3University of British Columbia This paper examines the impact of remittances on credit and provides the first evidence of their effect on delinquency rates. Using a dataset of more than 34 million consumer loans in Mexico and instrumenting for remittances with U.S. unemployment exposure at the municipality level, we uncover two effects overlooked in the literature. First, a “substitution” effect where low-income borrowers, especially women, use remittances to avoid delinquency. Second, a “complementary” effect where remittances increase credit but solely for securing loans with favorable terms. These findings highlight remittances’ role in reducing credit risk and supporting financial development in low- and middle-income economies. | ||