Conference Agenda
| Session | ||
29 SES 14 A: Visual arts in education
Paper Session | ||
| Presentations | ||
29. Research on Arts Education
Paper About reenacting of Visual Games 1: Ministério da Educação, Portugal; 2: Universidade do Porto, I2ADS Presenting Author:This work is part of a research project that intersects the fields of design and arts education. ‘Reenactment of Materials of Arts Education’ draws on an archive of past pedagogical materials and seeks to update them. It aims to critically reinscribe such body of practices in the field of arts education, starting from the Portuguese territory of the second half of the 20th century and looking at it from the present. Design methodology is used to study the materials and propose revisions. Educational issues and the revision of materials are intersected, in terms of the critical intentions of this proposal, by a feminist perspective. The work we now present contextualizes and initiates one of these studies of materials. Emerging in a secondary context in a peripheral European country, at the hands of two female educators, Elvira Leite and Manuela Malpique, little known at the time, Jogos Visuais (Visual Games) constitutes a unique case in the panorama of Portuguese arts education, receiving increasing media interest in recent years. The visual grammars and discourses contained in these materials will be problematized in our paper, as we believe they continue to inform conceptions of arts education in the present. How should we consider the modern expression of visual purity, solid colors, and formal minimalism in Visual Games? How can we review these and other aspects conveyed by the sociopolitical inscription of design practices and how can we use design as a critical tool to reformulate the premises that in 1974 translated into these devices? Which school of thought should we stick to? The usability-driven modernists and their “form follows function”; the attention to detail and craftmaking, of arts and crafts, por example, aiming to slow time; “the art of looking sideways” Alan Fletcher brought to us or the “fuck logic, bravo to instinct” both Björk and David Carson live by? The paper considers the notion of archive, firstly, as an effort to record and catalog proposals, solutions, and objects and, secondly, as a possibility for questioning their subjectivation effects, while reinterpreting and updating these same proposals, solutions, and objects. This implied subjectivity production that occurs in the configuration of the archive is also at stake in its re-activation. The re-activation gesture will be supported by Andrea Fraser’s reflection on reenactment and performativity, as she states that every enactment is directed towards a body that is invested and at stake, and such enactment “(...) performs itself and in so doing structures a recognition of and reflection on the relations produced and reproduced in the activity and, above all, on the investments that orient them” (p. 127). The feminist gaze operating in the reactivation of past pedagogical materials will call on a large spectrum of gender issues. The authors start with the work of two female educators, Leite and Malpique, and intend to appropriate their work and use it nowadays in educational contexts to develop themes like female labour, sorority, rummage and attentiveness in everyday flow into reviewed versions. The conviction is that anti-dicriminatory themes largely surpass personal interest and are a social and political duty towards a more equal and fair society. As teachers, the authors of this investigation are also interested in revisiting and recontextualizing these archives from a perspective of resource ecology and dilution of authorship: do we need to always be closed in our classrooms, presenting proposals that have not been tested, discussed, or thought out together? Or can we make use of the experience of those who came before us and those who accompany us, look back at their proposals in a critical way, use them, and update them? Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used This research relies on the configuration of an archive of practices, collected through literature review and interviews with educators and cultural mediators. The authors support their archival impetus in the notions shared by Giannachi (2016) and think the archive as “an apparatus [that] consists of a set of practices, bodies of knowledge, measures, and institutions that aim to manage, govern, control, and guide—in a way that is intended to be useful—the behaviors, gestures, and thoughts of human beings.” (Giannachi, 2016, p. xv). This proposition locates the work to be done: when we recover archives to think about them and activate them, we must also reflect on the practices and histories they carry and what it means to revisit them. Based on this reflection, and given that everything can constitute an archive (Giannachi, 2026), we accept the suggestion to “design the archive as the apparatus by which we want to be produced” (Giannachi, 2026). In particular, this paper will focus on developing further insights in the case of Elvira Leite and Manuela Malpique’s set of Visual Games, read through a critical lens which intends to question their modern heritage and subjectivation intentionality, while, at the same time, recognizes and seeks to experiment on the very potentiality they offer. This potentiality will be, nonetheless ‘hacked’ by a feminist perspective of the authors that might have been less prominent on the original conception of Leite and Malpique. Visual Games, which are a set of books and games produced by Asa Publisher in the 1970s, will be primarily analyzed by the authors of this investigation, and framed within the proposed lens. Interviews and informal conversations with cultural and education agents are expected to enlighten on how these materials have been used and appropriated, bringing additional insights on the flexibility they also promote. Afterwards, these educational objects will be tested and discussed with invited guests—teachers, students, and other researchers—in scheduled sessions. These sessions result in jointly produced knowledge, accounting for advances, setbacks, challenges, mistakes, and inflections. This collective practice adds to its initial reflective purpose also the pursuit of a set of updated versions of Visual Games, reframed from a feminist perspective that will likely align with derivations related to attentiveness, analogue techniques and social activism. At a later stage, and held by design expertise and material experimentation, updates to these objects are tested in a laboratory setting and then taken into the classroom. Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings The project ‘Reenactment of Materials of Arts Education’ and this paper lead us to a tensional state previously experimented in another research project named CREAT_ED - the historicization of the creative child in arts education (in which one of the authors participated). We share conflicting feelings regarding these pedagogical objects: their materiality plays a seductive role, while we admittedly recognize an ongoing reproduction of modern patterns with direct impact on the subjectivation of the creative individual. In the face of this tension we purposely want to stay with the trouble, and thus to look back at CREAT_ED: “We struggle not to subject ourselves to the naturalisations operated by the archive of the creative child/the archive of arts education, while we regard them as acts of governance, as fields of force of violent effect (Stoler, 2008) with and against which we want to strive. Whether reenacting certain materials as an interpolation is reinforcing or interrupting such fields of force of violent effect, is a disquiet that remains with us so far.” (Almeida; Midori; Guimarães & Boavista, p.131) As teachers we have strong views on the school culture of individualism and seek to promote modes of collaboration within school contexts, also as part of the sorority we often find among feminist peers. With a stronger community teachers are more likely to share and discuss classroom practices and debate their positioning. Besides reviewing the modern influence playing through arts education past objects brought into the present, our update also aims to interrupt hegemonic trajectories, by resorting to less visible issues through them. The actualized pedagogical materials are intended to circulate and lend a critical trigger that unsettles current aspects of school culture, and offer the possibility to instigate a more attentive relationship with the world mediated by arts education. References Almeida, C.; Midori, A.; Guimarães, S. & Boavista, R. (2023). Games in hands, questions in mind: in the flesh of the impossibility of ‘about what’s there’. In Martins, C. (Ed.). (2023). The historicization of the creative child in education (ISBN 978-989-9049-53-6). i2ADS – Instituto de Investigação em Arte, Design e Sociedade. https://doi.org/10.34626/2023/978-989-9049-53-6 Buckley, C. (2025). Made in patriarchy. Bikini Books & Clube do Livro do Design. Fraser, A. (2015). Performance or Enactment. Performing the Sentence, 13, 123-127. Garcés, M. (2022). A honestidade com o real [La honestidad con lo real] (L. Rabello, Trad.). In L. Rabello & M. C. Fenati (Eds.), Caderno de Leituras (155). Edições Chão da Feira. Giannachi, G. (2016). Archive Everything: Mapping the Everyday. The MIT Press. hooks, b. (2021). Ensinando comunidade: Uma pedagogia da esperança (K. Cardoso, Trad.). Editora Elefante. Jansson, T. (2022). The Summer Book. Sort Of Books. Lutters, J. (Ed.). (2018). The trade of the teacher: Visual thinking with Mieke Bal. Valiz. Le Guin, U. (2019). The Carrier Bag Theory of Fiction. Ignota Levit, B. (2025). Sobre design, feminismo e amizade. Bikini Books / Clube do Livro do Design. Martins, C. (Ed.). (2023). The historicization of the creative child in education (ISBN 978-989-9049-53-6). i2ADS – Instituto de Investigação em Arte, Design e Sociedade. https://doi.org/10.34626/2023/978-989-9049-53-6 Thompson, T. S., & Harney, S. (2018). Ground provisions. Afterall: A Journal of Art, Context and Enquiry, 45(1), 120–125. 29. Research on Arts Education
Paper From Drawing School to Art School: the First Hungarian State Art Education Institution in Student Photographs Doctoral School of Education, ELTE Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary Presenting Author:The presentation focuses on Hungary's first state art education institution. The school is the nearly 250-year-old Secondary School of Visual Arts. In the 19th century, the institution operated as a drawing school providing training for craftsmen, and at the beginning of the 20th century, workshop teaching was introduced. From then on, drawing training and design were complemented by execution, and the school offered increasingly complex art education. The lecture examines the work of the very first art classes at the school through the Schola Graphidis Art Collection, a collection of artworks used and created during the course of education that has been preserved at the school. The museum-quality art collection, preserved in the school environment and still used in teaching today, includes a collection of photographs of historical value. These student works, created in the photography department founded in 1914, continuously documented school life, the work going on in the workshops, and student exhibitions. With the help of photographs supplementing written sources, we sought answers to the following questions: 1. What international influences shaped the development of the first secondary art education in Hungary? 2. Are guild traditions and the tradition of the drawing school function still valid, and if so, to what extent? 3. How did the institution's art collection, which was constantly expanding with student works, determine the work going on at the school and how did it define the institution itself? Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used Following a deductive, qualitative paradigm, this idiographic study examines the beginnings of secondary art education in Hungary by processing primary written and visual sources. Due to the subject matter and sources of the research, our study is a synchronic examination that also includes diachronic elements, in which we approach the characteristics of art education with the help of primary sources and through student work. In processing the written primary sources (archival sources, school periodicals), we examined phenomena related to the institution's operation, specific character, and pedagogical practice through historical source analysis and approached them through discursive analysis of the texts. The primary written documents were supplemented by the analysis of visual sources, in which the historical context was determined by exploring cultural codes and identifying the social and artistic environment through the interpretation of visual sources. Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings In examining the above questions, our main analytical perspectives are: the examination of reception effects, the analysis of the continuing traditions of guild-based drawing instruction, and the characteristics of current art education as it has developed from workshop-based instruction. The expected outcome and benefit of the analysis is to paint a more accurate picture of the characteristics and roots of secondary art education in Hungary in the 19th and 20th centuries. Our results indicate that art education, which developed within the framework of traditional training and applied modern 20th-century educational principles, retains many traditional elements. The art collection, which is still used in educational work today, contributes to the institution's self-representation. References Bodóczky, I. (2020). A rajztanítás speciális jellege és módszertana a Budapest Székesfővárosi Iparrajziskola elődintézményeiben (1778–1886). Ars Hungarica, 46(1), 7–18. Elfland, A. D. (1990). A History of Art Education: Intellectual and Social Currents in Teaching the Visual Arts. Theachers College Press. Fliedl, G. (1986). Kunst und Lehre am Beginn der Moderne. Die Wiener Kunstgewerbeschule 1867–1918. Residenz Verlag. Katona, J. (2020). Minták után szabadon? Rajzoktatás a Budapest Székesfővárosi Iparrajziskolában. Ars Hungarica. 46(1), 19–30. Székely, M. (2023). Schools and Museums of Modern Design in Transylvania around 1900. Bölcsészettudományi Kutatóközpont. Művészettörténeti Intézet. 29. Research on Arts Education
Paper Sharing the visualisations of the Arctic Art-based Learning of the Arctic in upper-secondary Students’ online collaboration University of Lapland, Finland Presenting Author:The paper presents a study analysing students' different visualisations of the North and the The participants were upper-secondary students from the compulsory visual Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used art-based action research, visual polarisation method analysis Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings The expressions of the Arctic by the students' artworks show the idealistic, commercial and touristic on the other hand, the desolated wilderness and personal everyday side of the Northern landscape. The research also demonstrates the potential of the visual polarisation method in art education context as an art-based analysis method. The results show that by approaching the topic of the Arctic through contemporary art examples, one's own visual expressions, collaboration with other secondary schools and especially by sharing and seeing others' artworks, the dialogical learning of the concept and multiple realities and perspectives became possible. This points out the possibilities of art-based learning and analysing artworks by youth and peers on multifaceted topics. Gaining knowledge through others' subjective visions expressed in visual tasks offers a forum to develop empathy and openness for others' experiences and perspectives. All valuable skills in the current world view and the future. References Aspelin, G. (1973). Bildanalys. Stockholm, Sweden: Gidlunds förlag. Jokela, T., Hiltunen, M., & Härkönen, E. (2015). Contemporary art education meets the international north. In M. Kallio-Tavin & J. Pullinen (Eds.), Finnish art education (p. 260–279).Helsinki, Finland: Aalto ARTS Books. Räsänen, M. (2008). Kuvakulttuurit ja integroiva taideopetus [Visual cultures and integrative art teaching]. Helsinki, Finland: University of Art and Design. Manninen, A. (2021). Yhteyksiä luomassa: Nykytaideperustainen ilmiöpohjainen oppiminen Euroopan kansalaisuuden tarkastelussa . [Väitöskirja, Taiteiden tiedekunta]. Lapin yliopisto. http://urn.fi/URN:ISBN:978-952-337-279-5 Manninen, A., Parpala, M., & Härkönen, E. (2022). "Miten eri tavoilla voi tulkita pohjoisen": Tiedostava kuvataidekasvatus ilmiöoppimisena taideperustaisessa verkkoyhteistyössä. Kasvatus : Suomen kasvatustieteellinen aikakauskirja, 53(2), 145-159. Artikkeli 3. https://doi.org/10.33348/kvt.115921 Räsänen, M., Romilson, C., Nordström, G. Z., & Aspelin, G. (1990). Polarisoiva menetelmä: Referaatit kirjoista nordström-romilson: Bilden, skolan och samhället (1970), aspelin m.fl.: Bildanalys (1973). Helsinki, Suomi: Taideteollinen korkeakoulu. 29. Research on Arts Education
Paper ***WITHDRAWN*** To Make Film, To Make School: The Bolex in the Classroom 1: KULeuven, Belgium; 2: LUCA School of Arts, Belgium Presenting Author:What does it mean to make a film with a school rather than about it? To Make Film, To Make School: The Bolex in the Classroom approaches this question by treating the camera as a material object whose presence, mechanics, and demands allow the conditions of school to appear. Working with the Paillard-Bolex H16 and the grammar of filmmaking itself, the project investigates how the act of filming itself can enact the conditions of school as scholè: a temporally and spatially organized situation in which things are withdrawn from immediate instrumental purpose and made available for study. The Paillard-Bolex H16, a mechanical camera from the 1930s, requires a series of precise gestures: calculating exposure, setting focus, winding the spring, and consioucly starting and stopping the take. Each shot lasts no more than twenty-five seconds, after which the mechanism must be rewound. The ratcheting motor, clicking gears, and moving film produce a sound that can be heard throughout the classroom. Each take carries weight: the film stock is finite, mistakes cannot be erased, and the result remains unknown until development. This material presence affects how everyone in the room acts, waits, and observes, and makes the act of filming something tangible and collective. The project unfolds as a concrete film production in which the filmmaker, supported by a small crew, opens a film atelier within a primary school. Children participate as actors, not playing a role, but themselves. Yet not in the sense of self-representation, but as pupils of the school whose actions form the material and temporal fabric of the film. Drawing on historical links between cinema and educational practices, the work resists contemporary instrumental approaches in which film is primarily used to communicate, instruct, or enable self-expression. In this context, the Bolex mediates between classroom and filmic space: it is both an object to be studied and a device that generates a filmic environment emerging from the gestures, materials, and routines of the school. To Make Film, To Make School does not document the classroom or produce self-representation. Instead, it enacts the school as a space of scholè, where filming itself makes the school tangible and perceptible, and where meaning arises in the process of filming rather than in the final images. Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used - Artistic Research / Filmmaking (experimental, practice-based methodology): self-produced audiovisual images and experiences with cameras in the classroom - Literature study Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings Expected findings include insights into how filmic procedures can reveal the conditions and relationships that constitute school as a space of collective study and attention.The project suggests that filmmaking in this mode can function as both a method and an outcome of research: the film itself, and the process of making it, become a means to understand and activate school as scholè. References - Masschelein, J., & Simons, M. (2013). In defence of the school. A public issue. - Bresson, R. (2016). Notes on the cinematograph (J. Griffin, Trans.). New York Review Books. - Deligny, F., Béghin, C., De Séguin, A., Masson, A., Comolli, J.-L., Miguel, M., Joubert-Laurencin, H., & Alvarez de Toledo, S. (2021). Camérer: A propos d’images : Fernand Deligny. (Marina. Vidal-Naquet, Marlon. Miguel, Anaïs. Masson, & Sandra. Alvarez de Toledo, Éds.). L’Arachnéen. | ||