20. Research in Innovative Intercultural Learning Environments
Paper
School Communities that Better Support Refugees and Migrants' and Respond to Their Needs for a Sense of Belonging
Maria Papathanasiou1, Dimitrios Georgiadis2
1University of Thessaly, Greece; 2Ministry of Migration and Asylum
Presenting Author: Papathanasiou, Maria;
Georgiadis, Dimitrios
Sense of belonging, particularly for immigrants, is a complex tapestry woven from threads of cultural continuity, adaptation, community ties and social recognition. It is a dynamic process shaped by personal narratives, cultural interactions and the wider socio-political context, highlighting the resilience and adaptability of individuals in their search for a place to call home (Nikolaides, et al, 2022). Greeks have been eternal migrants/refugees, whereas the last decades the country has been hosting migrants and refugees itself. It has been their turn to welcome, communicate and bequeath such a sense and make everyone “feel like home”.
While first-generation refugees and migrants may grapple with adapting to a new culture, subsequent generations often develop a hybrid identity that seamlessly integrates aspects of both their heritage and the host culture (Georgiadis, 2023a, 2023b). However, their journey is fraught with challenges, and among those are the acquisition of a new language that stands out as a transformative and empowering endeavor. Language learning goes beyond mere communication; it becomes a key tool for integration, understanding, and unlocking opportunities. Resilience, courage, and persistent search for stability in the face of displacement are the lifeline to navigate the complexities of a new life. Peer support for both children and their parents can create a space for emotional connection, where shared experiences would foster a profound understanding of the challenges faced by refugee families. Parents and children may find solace in knowing that their struggles and fears are validated by others who walked a similar path.This validation is a crucial aspect of building resilience. Therefore, the question that arises is how a community and particularly, a school community that includes students, teachers and the parents/guardians can better provide a sense of trust, care and belonging to migrant/refugee and asylum seekers families (Papathanasiou, 2022b).
Peer support can aid refugee children in their academic journey, especially in language learning. Fellow students who have already navigated language barriers can provide guidance, tutoring, and encouragement. Understanding the nuances of a new educational system and culture is facilitated through peer interactions, creating a smoother transition for refugee children. In addition to peer support, a linguistic and culturally responsive pedagogy would serve as the bridge to immediate needs such as accessing services, seeking employment, and communicating with the local community. It is a fundamental skill that empowers individuals to navigate their new environment, gain a deeper understanding of the customs, traditions, and societal norms of their host country, and facilitate a smoother integration process.
Certain factors, such as parents' socioeconomic situation, educational level, and race but also their different perceptions of their involvement in their children’s education, can directly or indirectly influence learning literacy skills for their children (Brooks-Gunn & Markman, 2005). Nonetheless, the same and other researchers state that the key to the emergence of language learning is neither the profession and education, nor the financial situation and race of the parents, but the way in which the parents organize the appropriate activities and engage their children in them, that ultimately facilitates the emergence of writing and reading (Bornstein & Cheah, 2006, Rowe et al, 2016). In latest research, it has been also stated that one of the main responsibilities of parents is to build a positive family environment that will encourage the development and learning of children (Van Voorhis et al, 2013). Why then not invite parents to an activity in which everyone participates, regardless of age, language, and socio-economic level, as it is a tool that enhances primarily dialogue that incorporates critical thinking and reflection which begins with an inquiry that is triggered with a story, art, or a song.
Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources UsedAs a tool to test our research questions, we choose qualitative research. As we all know, qualitative research is very important in educational research as it addresses the "how" and "why" research questions and allows for a deeper understanding of experiences, phenomena and context. Qualitative research allows you to ask questions that cannot easily be put into numbers to understand the human experience. Understanding the everyday reality of a social phenomenon and studying important questions as they are actually practiced contributes to the expansion of knowledge and understanding. To do this, you need to understand the philosophical position of qualitative research and work from it to develop your research question, study design, data collection methods, and data analysis.
The researchers have built and used an interview guide with open-ended questions that allow participants to express their thoughts freely. Leading questions that might bias responses are avoided. They also developed probing techniques to elicit deeper and more detailed responses. This may involve asking follow-up questions or seeking clarification. There has been a pilot test with a small sample to refine the interview guide, identify potential issues, and ensure that questions are clear and effective. They begin the interview by building rapport with the participant. Clearly restate the purpose of the study and reassure them about confidentiality.
It has been decided to employ a suitable sampling strategy, such as purposive sampling or snowball sampling, based on the research aims and participant characteristics. In particular, our sample consists of 10 subjects from the Turkish and Afghan communities who live in Athens and know Greek well.
Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or FindingsSharing personal stories and coping strategies can be therapeutic, addressing the mental health challenges that often accompany displacement. Therefore, peer support could possibly serve as an informal counseling platform. Community building could assemble a network that creates a sense of belonging, reduces the isolation capable to contribute to mental health issues.
Language acquisition on the other hand is integral to cultural integration. Through language, refugees and migrants gain a deeper understanding of the customs, traditions, and societal norms of their host country, facilitating a smoother integration process.
In essence, peer support for refugee children and their parents is a testament to the strength of human connections. Beyond offering practical assistance, it serves as a source of emotional sustenance, cultural enrichment, and empowerment, embodying the resilience that defines the refugee experience. Similarly, a linguistically and culturally responsive pedagogy (Cummins, 2021), can unlock the immense potential within these individuals, fostering a more compassionate and integrated future where language becomes the bridge that unites rather than divides. Considering community-based strategies that respond to migrants and refugees’ language learning needs as well as their sense of belonging to a new society cannot be a panacea but it could possibly support, empower and respect those people’s identity, linguistic and cultural background, new language, and provide new opportunities.
ReferencesBornstein, M.H., & Cheah, C. S. L. (2006). The place of “culture and parenting” in the ecological contextual perspective on developmental science. In K. H. Rubin, & O. B. Chung (Eds.), Parenting beliefs, behaviors, and parent–child relations. New York: Psychology Press.
Brooks-Gunn, J. & Markman, L.B. (2005). The contribution of parenting to ethnic and racial gaps in school readiness. The Future of children, 15(1), 139–168. https://doi.org/10.1353/foc.2005.0001
Cummins, J. (2021). Rethinking the education of multilingual students: A critical analysis of theoretical claims. Bristol, UK: Multilingual Matters.
Georgiadis, D. (2021). Unaccompanied Minors in Greece: An Empirical Research, The
Migration Conference, London, UK.
Georgiadis, D. (2023a). Human Rights, Racism and Migration: A philosophical approach
Interdisciplinary Research in Counseling, Ethics and Philosophy, vol. 3, issue 7, 2023: pages. 1-
12. ISSN: 2783-9435 © IRCEP.
Georgiadis, D. (2023b). The European Management of Immigrants in the mediterranean: The
Case of Italy, Athens: Jean Monnet European Centre of Excellence, National and Kapodistrian
University of Athens. http://dx.doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.22077.03041
Pantazis, V. Georgiadis, D. (2023). Social Pedagogy [Undergraduate textbook]. Kallipos, Open Academic Editions. http://dx.doi.org/10.57713/kallipos-333
Hertel, S. & Jude, N. (2016). Parental Support and Involvement in School. In S. Kuger, E. Klieme, N. Jude, D. Kaplan (Eds.), Assessing Contexts of Learning. Int. Springer Cham: Switzerland.
Nicolaides, A., Eschenbacher, S., Buergelt, P. T., Gilpin-Jackson, Y., Welch, M., & Misawa, M. (Eds.). (2022). The Palgrave handbook of learning for transformation.
Papathanasiou, M. (2019). Parents’ philosophical community: When parents go to school! Childhood and Philosophy, 15:1-28, 10.12957/childphilo.2019.38746
Papathanasiou, M. (2022a). Parents-Teachers Transformational Community of Philosophical Inquiry: An Innovative Model. University of Naples, Federico II, Italy. Papathanasiou, M. (2022b). Enhancing Parents’ Engagement to Enhance Children’s Learning (270322-091656) in Handbook of Research on Family Literacy Practices and Home School Connections (Eds) ISBN13:9781668445693
Rosenblum, M. Tichenor, D. (2018). The Politics of International Migration, Oxford University Press.
Rowe, M. Denmark, N., Harden, B. & Stapleton, L. (2016). The Role of Parent Education and Parenting Knowledge in Children's Language and Literacy Skills among White, Black, and Latino Families. Infant and Child Development. 25. 10.1002/icd.1924.
20. Research in Innovative Intercultural Learning Environments
Paper
Informal Encounters Strengthen the Connection between the School and African Immigrant Families
Michal Ganz-Meishar
Levinsky-Wingate Academic College, Israel
Presenting Author: Ganz-Meishar, Michal
International immigration brought about a change in the human public sphere in Israel and created tensions against the background of differences related to religion, culture, tradition, and language. The education system tries to provide solutions to strengthen non-Jewish immigrant families and community resilience. Additionally, established social initiatives innovative of humanitarian organizations and associations: "Soul Group," which operates according to Waldorf's educational concept, and "Elifelet," citizens for refugee children (https://www.elifelet.org/?lang=en). These organizations support schools, and their goal is to promote a shared life of tolerance, inclusion, and mutual respect while providing equal opportunities for children and their families for social integration, creating social cohesion, health, and security now and in the future days (McAuliffe & Khadria, 2020; Wittenberg, 2017; Magner, 2016).
Social integration helps families to be more protected in the foreign environment in terms of language, behavior, tradition, and appearance of skin color. Immigrants live in a reality of economic and social uncertainty, loneliness, and a sense of foreignness. To create protection and community as a substitute for the nuclear family, the immigrants create communion and live in a neighborhood with residents from the same country of origin and socioeconomic status. This social cohesion contributes to maintaining identity, assistance in raising children, administrative procedures, and finding a job. In terms of the education systems in Israel and the world, there is a trend towards segregation, and immigrant families' children study in culturally homogenous schools that were established as a response to this communalism (International Organization for Migration (IOM), 2022; Kugler & Price, 2009; Schleicher, 2017).
Interactions between different social groups and informal encounters may lead to a discourse involving obedience, acceptance of the authority of a majority group, and absorption of expressions of violence and racism. Therefore, educators and parents from the majority group need to build relationships on trust, inclusion, and respect. The dialogues with the parents are not based only on the transfer of knowledge but also on understanding the trauma experienced by the immigrant parents from difficulties in The conversations with the parents are not based only on the transfer of knowledge but also on understanding the trauma experienced by the immigrant parents from the problems in their new life. Positive feelings towards the "other" dissolve the concepts of "us and them," which causes considerable tension and separation. It was found that forming an image of peace education, which operates according to the principles of "Restorative justice pedagogy," promotes self-awareness of others and the ability to deal effectively with stereotypes and prejudices (Lee & Walsh, 2017; Ratnam, 2020; Ogilvie & Fuller, 2017).
Educators from the majority group, who hold cultural encounters between the parents, must create a safe environment of trust and mutual appreciation with the understanding that there are differences between people and groups, which create the uniqueness of the individual. This will allow partnerships to be built that help the parents and the school define goals and accept joint responsibility for promoting the students' learning and cultural integration processes in the new cultural and linguistic environment (Lerner, 2012; Pharaoh & Li, 2022).
The study examines the contribution of the shared experience in informal encounters between Israeli families whose children attend Waldorf education and immigrant families from Africa and its implications on building the relationships and partnerships between African parents and the school in south Tel Aviv.
The study questions are: (1) In what way do these informal encounters promote the partnership between the school and African immigrant parents? (2) What are the challenges and consequences of informal activities in developing pedagogical, social, and personal responses for immigrant families in the receiving society?
Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources UsedThe research approach is a qualitative-interpretive case study, which allows for in-depth observation of the phenomenon within a specific context of real life to understand the case: informal encounters between parents from Israel who believe in Waldorf education and parents from immigrant families. This allows local to global generalizations and examines the studied case's processes, actions, and behaviors. The encounters took place in parks for playing, creative crafts, listening to music, authentic refreshments, and intimate conversations. The participants are 72 families, teachers, and organizers: 34 African immigrant parents from a minority group with a different cultural background, 27 parents from Israel whose children attend Waldorf education schools, 3 program managers, 5 educators, the school principal, and two assistants from a school for children from African families' Immigrants from Tel-Aviv.
The data were collected by three research tools: (1) 3 open observations by a researcher acting as an observer as a participant who does not have a role in the groups being studied, (2) semi-structured in-depth interviews lasting about an hour, which took place after participating in the encounters (3) documents such as invitations and verbal and voice correspondence in the WhatsApp groups.
To create a complete understanding of the activities, the researcher participated as an active observer and held spontaneous conversations with the participants, writing shortlists, observing, and participating in the activities while maintaining a distance from the participants to create objectivity (Merriam, 2009; Adler & Adler, 1994; Kawulich, 2005). Interviews were conducted with 20 participants in a focus group of up to 10 participants from all groups of parents, as well as with 5 teachers, the program coordinators from the association, the school principal, and the management team. The interviews took place face-to-face, on Zoom, and in a phone call for about forty minutes (Griffin & Care, 2015).
The data was analyzed using content analysis, focusing on what the participants said, reflecting their actions, feelings, beliefs, and knowledge. Moreover, the content analysis allows a description of the data and drawing valid conclusions for a broad context (Krippendorff, 2004).
According to the analysis of the findings, a general categorical thematic was conducted to help consolidate and clarify the meanings and create generalizations (Englander, 2020). The ethical rules were observed. The chief scientist at the Ministry of Education approved the study. The ethical practices were observed. The chief scientist at the Ministry of Education approved the study.
Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or FindingsThis study offers unique and innovative informal encounters and highlights the social aspect of school education for immigrant children's future to strengthen personal and community resilience for integration into society. The informal encounters helped the African immigrant parents get closer to the school and understand its critical role in their children's education. These encounters allowed parents from immigrant families to participate in an open space with families of the dominant majority group. The immigrant families usually meet publicly with the Israeli community, where hierarchical order is very prominent. As opposed, the informal encounters between the two groups of families create an atmosphere of equality: all are parents of children seeking to bring about humane and social values.
The cooperative atmosphere contributed to the understanding that closeness outweighs distance, and everyone is troubled by similar issues of parenting, enjoyment for children, and a shared desire to be good citizens while demonstrating tolerance, reciprocity, and respect. At the same time, the minority of participants in the third encounter may reveal doubts and uncertainty about parents' abilities. Other social organizations that believe in the full integration of immigrants may want to benefit more from these activities. Therefore, they have interfered with the decisions of the families of the immigrants and prevented them from joining.
Meetings between different communities may develop an intercultural competence not satisfied with empathy, listening, and inclusion but work actively to create belonging. The study enriches academic knowledge about the importance of expanding the circles of support for immigrant families. A school must open the door to additional collaborations to provide diverse answers to the children's needs. It can help determine a holistic policy for educating in multicultural schools and promote principles to emphasize the immigrant's identity and our identity as a global society that receives immigration.
ReferencesAdler, P. A. & Adler, P. (1994). Observation techniques. In Norman K. Denzin & Yvonna S. Lincoln (Eds.), Handbook of qualitative research (pp.377–392). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Creswell, J. W., Poth, C. N., & Hall, M. (2018). Qualitative inquiry & research design: Choosing among five approaches (Fourth edition). Thousand Oaks, California: SAGE.
Englander, M. (2020). Phenomenological psychological interviewing. The Humanistic Psychologist, 48(1),54–73.
Griffin, P., & Care, E. (Eds.). (2015). Assessment and teaching of 21st-century skills: Methods and approach. Dordrecht: Springer.
International Organization for Migration (IOM) (2022). Protection and Assistance for Migrants Vulnerable to Violence, Exploitation and Abuse: Household/Family Assistance.
Kawulich, B. B. (2005). Participant Observation as a Data Collection Method [81 paragraphs]. Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung / Forum: Qualitative Social Research, 6(2), Art. 43, http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:0114-fqs0502430.
Krippendorff, K. (2004). Content Analysis: An Introduction to Its Methodology. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Kugler, E. G., & Price, O. A. (2009). Go beyond the classroom to help immigrant and refugee students succeed. Phi Delta Kappan, 91(3), 48–52. https://doi.org/10.1177/003172170909100310.
Lee, S. J., & Walsh, D. (2017). Socially just, culturally sustaining pedagogy for diverse immigrant youth: Possibilities, challenges, and directions. In D., Paris & H. S., Alim (Eds.), Culturally sustaining pedagogies: Teaching and learning for justice in a changing world (pp. 83–98). Teachers College Press.
Lerner, A. B. (2012). The educational resettlement of refugee children: Examining several theoretical approaches. Multicultural Education, 20(1), 9–14.
Magner, T. (2016). Refugee, Asylum, and Related Legislation in the US Congress: 2013–2016. Journal on Migration and Human Security, 4, 166–189.
McAuliffe, M., & Khadria, B. (2020). World Migration Report. IOM UN MIGRATION, International Organization for Migration.
Merriam, S. B. (2009). Qualitative research: A guide to design and implementation. Jossey-Bass.
Ogilvie, G., & Fuller, D. (2016). In the classroom: Restorative justice pedagogy in the ESL classroom: Creating a caring environment to support refugee students. TESL Canada Journal, 33(10), 86–96.
Pharaoh, L., & Li, J. (2022). Strategies to Develop Intercultural Competence of Students in a Multicultural Set Up. Journal of Learning and Development Studies, 2(3), 14–22. https://doi.org/10.32996/jlds.2022.2.3.3
Ratnam, T. (2020). Provocation to Dialog in a Third Space: Helping Teachers Walk Toward Equity Pedagogy. Frontiers in Education 5.
https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2020.569018
Schleicher, A. (2017). Seeing Education through the Prism of PISA. European Journal of Education, 52(2).124–130. DOI: 10.1111/ejed.12209
Wittenberg, L. (2017). Managing Mixed Migration: The Central Mediterranean Route to Europe. International Peace Institute, (pp. 2-9).
20. Research in Innovative Intercultural Learning Environments
Paper
Conflicting Historical Narratives as a Starting Point for Educational Processes
Daniel Wutti1, Nadja Danglmaier2
1University of Teacher Education Carinthia, Austria; 2Alps Adriatic University, Austria
Presenting Author: Wutti, Daniel;
Danglmaier, Nadja
Remembering and storytelling are among the most fundamental human dispositions. Narratives about experienced, inherited and communicated pasts not only have a formative character in the lives of individuals. They are also essential for smaller and larger communities, as the re-presentation of central experiences serves to reaffirm identity and belonging. However, memories need certain media and forms of articulation so that they can fulfil their function of creating identity and meaning. In addition to literature and art, it is above all monuments that play an indispensable role as visible signs in public spaces in the transmission and communication of memory narratives.
By examining the design, history and social reception of commemorative symbols, we can observe the development of public attention for historical events. Meanwhile, gaps in the landscape of remembrance tell us something about marginalised cultures of remembrance. What is remembered in public spaces makes it clear who has the power to occupy it and thus to underpin a specific view of the past as the official one. In this presentation, we would like to show the extent to which the examination of historical narratives and conflicts of remembrance can be used for historical-political educational work and global citizenship education.
Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources UsedThe public space in Kärnten/Koroška - Carinthia, a historically bilingual region with a recognised autochthonous ethnic group - the Carinthian Slovenes - has been described in the literature as a "battlefield of memory", where various "communities of remembrance" struggle to make their versions of history visible and assert themselves. These ongoing memory conflicts can be illustrated by several specific monuments in the region. In our research from 2023 and 2024, historical monuments that address various themes of the Second World War and National Socialism in the region were systematically examined for their suitability in terms of "dialogical remembering" (Assmann 2020; Brousek/Grafenauer/Wintersteiner/Wutti 2020). In a second step, monuments that represent one-sided historical narratives and thus contradict inclusive memory were identified. In considering these "problematic monuments", the focus was placed on possible options for a new contextualisation of these monuments, associated debates and actionist alliances. This content was in turn prepared for school project lessons in order to make topics such as inclusive, dialogical remembrance, the necessary problematisation of existing, outdated symbols of remembrance and current social aspects of the past accessible to pupils.
Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or FindingsWhile publicly visible monuments mainly reflect national and nationalistic perspectives, their critical contextualisation opens their potential for contemporary discourse. Aspects of dialogical remembering can help identify problematic memorials. By using materials which consider (according to national and local circumstances) dialogical remembering, a mutual view of history and ultimately a greater understanding of the community in a transnational region can emerge. These, in turn, can be used in school lessons to spark a contemporary, democratic discourse with young people and at the same time make them accessible to critical topics of contemporary history. The presentation shows the extent to which the examination of historical narratives and conflicts of remembrance can be used for historical-political educational work and global citizenship education. It will show ways in which pupils can be encouraged to actively shape remembrance discourses as part of school projects.
ReferencesBrousek, Jan/Grafenauer, Danijel/Wintersteiner, Werner & Wutti, Daniel (Eds.) (2020): SLOVENIJA | ÖSTERREICH: Befreiendes Erinnern – Osvobajajoče spominjanje. Dialogische Aufarbeitung der Vergangenheit – Dialoško obravnavanje zgodovine. Drava.
Danglmaier, Nadja (2020): The changing landscape of memorials and its pedagogical possibilities. Jahresbericht 2019 erinnern.at – 20 Jahre erinnern.at. 26–27.
Danglmaier, Nadja/Hartmann, Eva & Wutti, Daniel (2021): Minority topics, ethnic questions and their potentials for memory work at schools. Treatises and documents – Journal of Ethnic Studies. Institute for Ethnic Studies. 33–48.
Danglmaier Nadja/Holfelder Ute/Klatzer Elisabeth & Entner Brigitte (Eds.) (2022). Koroška/Kärnten. Wege zu einer befreienden Erinnerungskultur. Mandelbaum.
Wutti, Daniel/Danglmaier, Nadja & Hartmann, Eva (Eds.) (2020). Erinnerungskulturen im Grenzraum – Spominske kulture na obmejnem območju. Mohorjeva/Hermagoras.
Wutti, Daniel (2023): Traumen und Gesellschaft. Transgenerationale Traumatisierung & Erinnerungskultur in Kärnten/Koroška. Psychologie in Österreich, (3), 214–221.
20. Research in Innovative Intercultural Learning Environments
Paper
Between Despair and Hope - Arab Teachers in a Personal, Educational, and National Trap
Dolly Eliyahu-Levi1, Avi Gvura2
1Levinsky-Wingate Academic, Israel; 2Beit Berl College
Presenting Author: Eliyahu-Levi, Dolly;
Gvura, Avi
Israeli society is deeply divided, and the mutual relations between Jews and Arabs are characterized by inequality, alienation, lack of dialogue, mutual negation, and increasing polarization between the groups (Epstein, 2016; Jackson & Doerschler, 2016; Paul-Binyamin and Haj-Yehia, 2019). Between Jews and Arabs, there are religious, cultural, national, and linguistic differences, all of which create one of the centers of political-social tension in everything related to the political-social power relations, including the inequality between them. (Shdema & Martin, 2022)
The events of Shiva in October threw Jewish society into the heart of darkness, into a state of trauma and uncertainty, as the dimensions of the massacre are unlike any terrorist events or murders of Jews since the Holocaust. Faced with this reality, the Arabs find themselves in a trap. On the one hand, suspicious voices towards the Arabs are getting stronger, as if they are all terrorists while strengthening the sense of national unity and Jewish identity. On the one hand, moderate voices are heard calling to protect the Arabs of Israel and to leave behind the riots and harassment.
The relations of mutual negation and cultural separation intensified following the "Iron Swords" war, and the Arabs are seen as an illegitimate element in the public systems, including the education system, which plays an essential role in shaping Israeli collective identity (Levy, 2023). According to Samuha (2010), power relations and the lack of equality are particularly prominent in the relationship between the Jewish majority group and the Arab-Palestinian minority in the long-standing national and historical conflict.
In the Israeli education system, Arab students' study in separate schools from the Jews. Thus, the system is characterized by discrimination, injustice, segregation, and inequality and does not allow the creation of a common basis for an authentic multicultural education that enables mutual interaction and recognition of others (Abu-Saad, 2020; Lustick, 2019). According to Allport's contact theory (Allport, 1954), direct and unmediated meetings between groups reduce conflicts and tensions and improve their relations. The lack of contact in formative years may harm intergroup relations (Cehajic et al., 2008). The discrimination between Jews and Arabs is also reflected in the legislation of the "Nationality Law" (2018), which highlights the Jewish nature of the country. It blatantly ignores the democratic nature of the country and the Arab minority (Amara, 2020).
Examining the issue of hiring teachers in Israel reveals that, over the years, there has been a shortage of Jewish teachers. At the same time, hundreds of quality Arab teachers are qualified to teach and are looking for employment. The solution proposed by the state is the integration of Arab teachers in Jewish schools (Shaked, 2016).
Researchers (Fa'or, 2021; Pinuras, 2019; Rajput & Talan, 2017; Halabi &) found that, in general, Arab teachers who teach in Jewish schools report a positive feeling alongside difficulties arising from cultural gaps and mistrust arising from national identity related to the Jewish-Arab conflict. Almelek (2020) claims that Arab teachers are often forced to suppress their political positions and beliefs from their students and colleagues to blur the national-political tension and increase the sense of trust.
The study directs the focus to the issue of the integration of Arab teachers in Jewish schools as it is perceived in the eyes of Arab teachers. This is to act consciously and intelligently to change the existing situation and promote the implementation of democratic values in society. The interviewees' descriptions constitute an authentic human document that reveals new aspects of their experiences in the current social reality. These stories can illuminate how Arab staff deal with complex situations in their professional practice.
Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources UsedThis study is based on the qualitative-phenomenological approach that seeks to learn about the issue under investigation by observing a particular phenomenon while focusing on the subjective experience of teachers from Arab society who teach in Jewish schools (Creswell & Poth, 2017). According to this concept, the human experience has meaning for those who experience it and is seen as a significant source of knowledge. Any objective understanding rests on a subjective perception (Eatough & Smith, 2008; Creswell & Creswell, 2018).
Nine Arab teachers, aged 25-32, with two to ten years of teaching experience in a Jewish school, participated in the study. All the teachers are graduates of Jewish colleges, and they teach mathematics, English, science, and Hebrew in Jewish elementary schools, middle schools, and high schools. They are selected by the snowball method.
The research tool was a semi-structured interview about the teaching experience of the participants and the diverse contexts of their personal, educational, social, cultural, national, and religious world through which it is possible to understand their teaching experience and the meanings they attribute to teaching in a Jewish school.
The question addressed to the research participants is, "Describe the teaching experience in the school. Address the challenges in teaching and the main ways to deal with these challenges so that the teaching experience is based on the values of democracy and the promotion of a shared life in Israeli society. Please explain and give examples." During the interview, the Arab teachers shared their feelings, beliefs, educational concepts, and the challenges of socio-cultural integration. The processing of the research data is based on an interpretive content analysis, which allows a look into the inner experience of the Arab teachers while referring to the descriptions of the characteristics of the teaching experience in Jewish schools, the diverse challenges, and ways of coping (Creswell, 2012).
The processing was based on content analysis focusing on what the teachers said in words, descriptions, and the way they presented their words. The cases selected for analysis from the large data set were those with explicit mention of the teaching experience, challenges, and coping methods (Braun & Clarke, 2006).
The accepted rules of ethics were kept. The goals of the interview were explained, full confidentiality and anonymity were guaranteed, and participants signed a consent letter.
Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or FindingsThere are cultural gaps in educational settings where teachers from diverse cultures, nationalities, and religions teach. The Israeli case is complex because it involves a meeting between teachers from two nations who live in parallel worlds and hardly ever meet in everyday life. In such a reality, Arab teachers often report dealing with personal, emotional, social, and cultural challenges in the face of difficult situations they encounter almost daily in a multicultural space saturated with expressions of racism, alienation, injustice, and disparities.
Moreover, they report the fear of expressing themselves freely, of expressing an opinion, of revealing a perception or belief that is not compatible with the perception of the dominant Jewish majority, probably because the school environment is not characterized by the emotional closeness between the Arab teachers and their students or colleagues.
These findings establish and add a new layer to the claims of researchers who examined the integration process of Arab teachers teaching in Jewish schools (Alhaj, 1996; Rodnitsky, 2014; Halabi & Fa'or, 2021).
Moreover, from a critical point of view, the question arises as to why, despite all the descriptions of racism, alienation, and exclusion, none of the teachers reported a desire to return to teaching in a school in the Arab sector. It seems that the Arab teachers understand that social integration is a continuous process that requires a unilateral concession. They know that they must remain open and exposed, because, above all, they are ambassadors of an entire population suffering from alienation, exclusion, inequality, and discrimination. The Arab teachers can deal with the Jewish students and make them understand that Arabs are people just like Jews. Only in this way of educational-social integration is there a chance to shatter stereotypes, reduce cultural gaps, and change perceptions about Arabs and other minority groups.
ReferencesAbu-Saad, I., Khalil, M., Haj-Ali, I., Awad, Y., & Dallasheh, W. (2020). Re-Examination of Hofstede's Cultural Value Orientations Among Beginner Palestinian Arab Teachers in Israel. Sumerianz Journal of Education, Linguistics, and Literature, 3(8), 169-177.
Allport, G. W. (1954). The effect of contact. Addison-Wesley.
Almelek, A. (2020). Emotional closeness and emotional distance in professional and personal relationships between schoolteachers: the case of Arab teachers teaching in Jewish schools. Mofet.
Amara, M. (2020). Teaching the Arabic language in Jewish society in Israel - characteristics and challenges. In: Y. Mendel, M. Aro, T. Abu Ras and G. Kramersky (editors). Arabs, Jews, Arabic: the teaching of Arabic in Israel and its challenges (pp. 28-12). Research report. Van Leer.
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa
Cehajic, S., Brown, R., & Castano, E. (2008). Forgive and forget? Antecedents and consequences of intergroup forgiveness in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Political Psychology, 29(3), 351–367.
Creswell, J. W. & Creswell, J.D. (2018). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approach (5th ed). Sage.
Eatough, V., & Smith, J. A. (2007). Interpretative phenomenological analysis. In E. Lyons & A. Coyle (Eds.), Analysing qualitative data in psychology (pp. 35–50). Sage.
Finuras, P. (2019). Culture Differences and Trust. Journal of Intercultural Management and Ethics, 2(4), 5-12.
Halabi, R. and Fa'or, H. (2021). Arab teachers in Jewish schools: suffering and remaining silent. Multifaceted: Research and Discourse, 21, 180-202.
Jackson, P. I., & Doerschler, P. (2016). How safe do majority group members, ethnic minorities, and Muslims feel in multicultural European societies? Democracy and Security, 12(4), 247-277.
Levy, N. (2023). Arabs in segregated vs. mixed Jewish–Arab schools in Israel: Their identities and attitudes towards Jews. Ethnic & Racial Studies, 46(12), 2720-2746.
Lustick, I. (2019). Paradigm lost - from two-state solution to one-state reality. Pennsylvania Press.
Paul-Binyamin, I. & Haj-Yehia, K. (2019). Multicultural education in teacher education: Shared experience and awareness of power relations as a prerequisite for conflictual identities dialogue in Israel. Teaching and Teacher Education, 85, 249–259.
Samuha, S. (2013). Do not break the dishes. Index of Arab-Jewish relations in Israel 2012. Israel Democracy Institute.
Shaked, K. (2016). Action to expand the circle of teaching: integration of Arab teachers in Jewish schools. Eye Contact, 260, 34–38.
Shdema, I., & D. Martin. (2022). Place identity among native minorities: Lessons from Arabs in Israel. Geographical Review, 112(2), 286–305.
|