Conference Agenda

Overview and details of the sessions of this conference. Please select a date or location to show only sessions at that day or location. Please select a single session for detailed view (with abstracts and downloads if available).

Please note that all times are shown in the time zone of the conference. The current conference time is: 10th May 2025, 09:51:14 EEST

 
 
Session Overview
Session
27 SES 11 B: Promoting Reading Competence
Time:
Thursday, 29/Aug/2024:
13:45 - 15:15

Session Chair: Anke Wegner
Location: Room B105 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [-1 Floor]

Cap: 60

Paper Session

Show help for 'Increase or decrease the abstract text size'
Presentations
27. Didactics - Learning and Teaching
Paper

The Impact of Some Critical Reading Strategies on Upper-intermediate Students' Comprehension of Expository Texts

Khuriya Paviz, Zhannur Mauytova, Altyn Kelimberdiyeva, Nurzada Yermaganbetova, Yryskul Imambayeva

Nazarbayev Intellectual School of Chemistry and Biology in Aktau

Presenting Author: Paviz, Khuriya; Mauytova, Zhannur

Reading is an essential skill for foreign and native speakers that enables their professional development (Wallace, 2006). This is in line with the submission of Habermas and Nielsen (1990), that reading ability is requisite to participate in and interpret the complex discussion of texts. Subsequently, developing students’ reading skills is essential for their future career success, as the modern job market and employers are looking for professionals who can read, understand, and interpret texts. Critical reading (CR) is the way students and teachers interact in the classroom to practice a higher form of comprehension. Combs (1992) emphasized that CR is an interactive process that uses multiple levels of thought simultaneously. In discussing and interpreting data, students practice critical thinking. This is also reinforced by Salisbury College (2008), which states that in reading comprehension, students not only absorb the knowledge of the passages they read, but also assess and evaluate the author’s arguments, tone, and bias.

According to some experts (Sweet, 1993; Wallace, 2003;) CR means the ability to read between the lines, i.e. to find the hidden meaning of texts and to read beyond the lines by using their analytical and evaluative skills that require higher order thinking. Arici (2012) refers to CR as “ideal reading” and states that it is the only way to help retain knowledge in the long term. Sweet (1993) and Wallace (2003) agree to some extent, referring to critical readers as "living readers" who can evaluate, question, interpret, recognize, and analyze evidence. As it helps students retain knowledge in the long term, it could even be useful in tests and exams. Although this is one of the skills that students need to acquire in this study, the compulsory and assessed internal and external examination tasks do not reflect the tasks that require critical thinking skills. However, the observational exams, i.e. the ungraded exams held to determine students' strengths and weaknesses, have tasks that require the use of critical thinking. The two aforementioned exams are common in High School Educational programs in Kazakhstan. Nonetheless, the structural difference in tasks puts additional pressure on teachers’ shoulders who struggle to juggle the preparations for two exams.

Nevertheless, Özdemir(2007) emphasizes that CR can be conducted by “intellectual students”, which could indicate that this could only be beneficial to students whose level of English proficiency is high.

Although it is not required in assessed examinations, the aim of this research is to develop student’s reading skills on expository texts through critical reading strategies so as to prepare them for further studies in higher institutions. According to Lwai (2007), expository texts are written to convey, describe, or explain non-fictional information. Ozensoy (2021) had previously studied the effect of cultivating critical reading skills on students' academic progress in social studies courses. He reported that there was a noticeable difference in learners’ academic achievement who trained CRS compared with another class who did not. The current study therefore aims to investigate the impact of some critical reading strategies on upper- intermediate students’ comprehension of expository texts. For quantitative analysis, pre and post-tests (derived from Critical reading test in English classes and from National exam tests in Kazakh) four science/industry and four nature related texts (ESL Brain, Critical Reading club) were covered during the study. Researchers conducted a survey and semi-structured interviews for qualitative analysis to study the learners’ perception according to the practiced strategies.

This study was carried out in one of the intellectual schools of Kazakhstan. The participants were tenth grade students of class A, experimental and F, control groups. The study lasted 10 weeks. After taking pretest, teachers presented


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
CR strategies such as annotating/questioning/charting/inferencing/summarizing and evaluating of texts as it is used at Salisbury University (SU, 2009) in experimental group. Both groups are familiar with previewing and predicting. In every lesson, teachers provided a more explicit guidance for a specific strategy or a combination of two or more, showed demonstration, and extended whole class discussion using the chosen texts. Students use the previously practiced strategies in the ongoing texts with a new strategy together. In pre- and reading stages, students annotate the text by circling the title and identifying the author, the source, and other basic details. In subsequent lessons, learners practice marking the text, underlining the thesis, highlighting if it has  parallel structure, rhetorical question(s), or repetition(s). It is advised to underline cue words such as cause/effect’, ‘comparison/contrast’ and ‘issue/decision’ as the given texts have one or combination of these elements. For context, when students previewed their first reaction to the author’s opinion that a nuclear power plant will be built in their country, they confidently expressed their responses by giving a two-way point of view. Some students expressed through emotions indicated the reason for their fear of a previous catastrophic historical fact in the country, and the students who supported the construction of the power plant attributed the reason for job opportunities, development of safety technology. When they read the experts’ viewpoints on the possible nuclear power plant construction in local area, compared previous tragic accidents, stated cadre deficiency as a reason and counterargument not to build nuclear plants. A few supported the author’s idea of a nuclear station construction to save natural resources connecting it with their real lives. Learners visualized ideas, drew images of those thoughts to clarify unfair concepts asking what the writer wants the readers to understand. Some scholars (Collins, Brown, & Larkin, (1980), Hilton (1990), suggest that generating questions is crucial in mental process that operates at profound theoretical levels like reading for comprehension.  Moreover, Salisbury University posited that learners would comprehend the material quicker and restore it longer if they write a question for every paragraph. Learners practice how to clarify ideas by rereading; analyzing statements and asking questions about the meaning of words and why this idea is vital in this case. Then learners responded to the writer’s claims with provocative and emotional arguments. While reading ‘Clean air or Clean hair?’,  student questioned why writer starts the text with ‘shower’.
Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
Arguments about ‘palm oil producers burning the forests instead of cutting’ was also made, which further helps students to understand the texts explicitly.
Anderson-Medius (1990) and Biano McCormick (1989) argue that being able to outline a text is a high degree of ability to notice the connection relate to real life. While charting the text, readers distinguished what the author says and does in each paragraph. Learners tried to relate texts to their own lives and other texts.
Findings
For English class, students did a pre and post-test from 501 Critical Reading Questions for the same test.  Chapter Seven contains material on science and nature, which is appropriate for unit’s theme. It contains three short and six longer reading passages. In pre-test, only 3 students could cover 65 percent of the task, 11 students managed only 35-40% of the task responding to 20-22 questions. The remaining part (3) could answer only 13-15 questions out of 56, though excepting 2 students usually cover FCE tasks for B and A levels. After 10 weeks, high-level readers achieved between 87 and 92 %, and more students were able to almost double their scores by mastering deducing hidden meaning, summarizing, relating texts to real life, identifying the authors’ tone, purpose well. However, they wrote in their learning log that sometimes it was harder to recognize words related to science than nature and figuring out the main idea. For Kazakh class, as it was their native language, after all training for CRS, teacher takes the national test for reasoning which consists of 30 questions. 78 % of students outperformed the task getting A level. interview and learning log revealed, the urgency of using annotation in their long expository texts. They emphasized divergent questions that ask students to preview, interpret, redesign, solve an issue, or create a product.

References
. In English class interviews, students accentuated the value of summary/paragraph writing, it assisted in determining needed thoughts and consolidating vital elements. They added that summary enables to focus on main ideas that are worth remembering and present a more straightforward explanation. They distinguished the role of convergent questions that ask to describe, express differently, state connections, compare/contrast, resolve a challenge.
 Analysis of results showed that there is a significant difference in the performance of students’ post-intervention, suggesting that the strategies employed in this study were effective, particularly for English class. Quantitatively, the difference between pre- and post-intervention in Kazakh class is small. However, documented reflections from students showed that there was an increase in their level of critical thinking and ability to annotate and summarize long texts. The disparity between the two group could be explained by the fact that students in Kazakh class were being exposed to such reading strategies for the first time, even though they might have used them for their native texts.. Following the statistical analysis, it was discovered that there was no significant difference between pre-test control group and pre-test experiment group of English class. Similarly, no significant difference was observed between post-test control group and post-test experimental group. However, a significant difference was observed post-intervention in the experimental group, validating that CR strategies were effective.
Significant improvement of 21%  was observed in results of English class experimental group’s pre-test and post-test, while Kazakh class demonstrated average improvement of about 7 % data from pre and post tests comparison.
Habermas J, Nielsen T, Habermas (1990) Society and Ethics – an Interview with Nielsen, Torben, HVIID, pp. 93-114.

Wallace C Critical reading in language education, 1st edn. (Palgrave Macmillan, New York, 2006), 217 p.

. Collins, A., Brown,J.S. & Larkin, K.M. (1980). Inference in text understanding. In R. J. Spiro, B. C. Bruce, & W. F. Brewer (Eds.), Theoretical issues in reading comprehension (pp. 385-407). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum
Handayani, Fitriyanti Agil, et al. “The Effect of Critical Reading Strategy on Students’ Reading Ability in Comprehending Expository Text.” Jadila: Journal of Development and Innovation in Language and Literature Education, vol. 2, no. 2, 15 Nov. 2021, pp. 170–179, https://doi.org/10.52690/jadila.v2i2.194.
Anderson-Medius, L. (1990). Cognitive mapping as a ―bridge‖ activity. Paper at the Annual Meeting of the
International Reading Association (35th, Atlanta, GA, May 6-11, 1990) (ERIC Document Reproduction
11.Salisbury University (2009). 7 Critical Reading Strategies.
Retrieved from: http://www.salisbury.edu/counseling/new/7_critical_reading_strategies.html


27. Didactics - Learning and Teaching
Paper

Effects of a Subject-Integrated Reading Training on the Reading Performance of Third Graders in Austria

Elisabeth Stabler, Fabian Feyertag

PPH Augustinum, Austria

Presenting Author: Feyertag, Fabian

There is no doubt that the ability to read is a fundamental skill without which participation in today's society seems almost impossible. This is precisely why numerous studies point to the key role of reading skills acquired in primary school (Maitz et al., 2018) for later educational and career opportunities (Bachinger et al., 2021).Additionally, the results of the latest Progress in International Reading Literacy Study (PIRLS) show that the acquisition of the readingskill is often not crowned with success: In Austria, 20% of the primary school pupils read at literacy level 1 or below and are therefore at risk (Schmich et al., 2023). However, in order to show a long-term improvement in reading, preventative measures and consistent reading promotion based on evidence are required. This refers in empirical educational research to the proof and legitimization of the effectiveness of a specific measure. Moreover, according to the National Reading Panel (2000), reading fluency is one of the key factors in effective reading promotion. The development of this skill is generally regarded as a central task of German lessons. However, the results of more recent research (Michalak & Feigenspan, 2022) indicate that fluency and subject-related learning are closely linked. Accordingly, reading promotion and reading comprehension must be seen, conceived and implemented as a task for all subjects. It should not be the isolated focus of German lessons at primary school as a subject-specific vocabulary requires basic interpersonal communication skills. Thus, reading promotion measures are needed that focus on and support subject-specific reading in addition to general reading comprehension. For this reason, the FLEDI Project (Subject-integrated Reading Promotion in Mathematics, German and Subject teaching) focuses on promoting reading skills at primary school level.

The term subject-integrated reading promotion focuses on reading measures that are not detached from their problem contexts, but rather imply a mental networking of what has been read in subject lessons. In this context, non-fiction texts play a central role in subject lessons, as pupils use them to deal with certain topics and facts on the one hand and to learn new content on the other. Ultimately, it is always about a lesson design that is not primarily constituted by the subject areas, but is based on the promotion of reading, in which subject matter plays an essential role. In addition, non-fiction texts meet children's need to understand the world and, according to the Erfurt-study, are among the most popular types of text for primary school children of both genders (Richter, 2003).

Despite these studies, however, Križan (2014) criticizes the lack of reliable findings, particularly in German-speaking countries, as to which support approaches are fruitful under which conditions. The FLEDI-Project attempts to address this criticism from the third grade onwards by using a longitudinal design to investigate the development of reading fluency in reading comprehension, taking particular account of pupil-related background characteristics (special educational needs, family migration background, ethnicity). The aim is to find out whether the FLEDI-Reading intervention is particularly beneficial for a specific level group of children. The developments of four different level groups are considered separately. These levels result from the initial reading fluency skills. Based on the children's performance in the Salzburger Reading Screening 2-9 (SLS) at the first test time, they were divided into four level groups one based on the quartiles of the overall sample. Accordingly, the research question is: How do the basic reading skills and reading comprehension of pupils with different reading performance levels develop in the context of subject-integrated reading promotion?


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
The present quantitative study is based on a quasi-experimental design, i.e., a non-randomized two-group plan with pre-test, treatment and post-test. Rost (2006) also refers to this procedure as a non-equivalent comparison group design. The first group represents the intervention group who trained with FLEDI for six weeks, the second group forms the comparison group, who received conventional reading lessons during the same period.
In order to measure the effects of subject-integrated reading training on reading skills, the children's reading skills were assessed in a longitudinal design before the start (April 2023) and after the end of the intervention (June 2023) in a test window of two weeks each. The Salzburg Reading Screening (2-9) (Mayringer & Wimmer, 2014) was used to measure basal reading skills, while the Progressive Diagnostic of Sense Comprehension Reading (VSL) (Walter, 2013) intended to measure reading comprehension. Personal data on the children (e.g., gender, L1, L2, etc.), in this case special educational needs, were filled in by the teachers using class lists. As the socio-economic status of the parental home is a predictor of educational success, this was also assessed by asking the children to rate their parents' more income holdings (Bos, Lankes, Prenzel, Schwippert, Walther et al, 2003; OECD, 2017).
The sample of this study consists (N=821) 659 pupils from the Upper Styria West educational region (intervention group) and 161 children from the educational region of Eastern Styria (comparison group), who received conventional reading lessons served.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
Initial results of a repeated measures ANCOVA on basal reading skills showed a significant main effect for time (F(1,688)=19.69, p<.01, ƞ2=.030). Accordingly, significant changes in basal reading skills in favour of the intervention group can be determined. An ANCOVA with repeated measures for reading comprehension also revealed a significant main effect over time (F(1,670)=16.18, p<.01, ƞ2=.024), which can be interpreted as a significant change in reading comprehension between the intervention group and the comparison group.
Calculations are still pending to check whether the FLEDI-Reading Training particularly promotes or supports a specific level group of children. The developments of four different level groups are considered separately. These levels result from the initial abilities in reading fluency. According to the performance that the children showed in the SLS at the first test time, they are divided into level groups 1 (lowest quartile) to 4 (highest quartile) based on the quartiles of the overall sample aiming to find out for which group of children the training is most effective.
By introducing the recommended subject-integrated reading promotion, there is, on the one hand, the opportunity to offer reading promotion measures in the classroom in accordance with the current state of German didactics and on the other hand to create specific world access to different subjects. In addition, the great potential of non-fiction texts as a starting point for reading promotion should be clarified. This results added value for all subjects, so that pupils recognize that reading forms a basis for all subject areas. This gives rise to the well-founded hope that reading can be experienced as a key competence in the classroom and in society, thus creating the basis for learning in all subjects.

References
Bachinger, A., Bruneforth, M., & Schmich, J. (2021). Lesekompetenz und Leseunterricht in Österreich – Ergebnisse, Entwicklungen und Forschungsinteressen aus fachdidaktischer und aus bildungspolitischer Perspektive. In Nationaler Bildungsbericht Österreich 2021 (S. 532). Bundesministerium für Bildung, Wissenschaft und Forschung. http://doi.org/10.17888/nbb2021
Bos, W., Lankes, E.-M., Prenzel, M., Schwippert, K., Walther, G. & Valtin, R. (2003). Erste Ergebnisse aus IGLU. Schülerleistung am Ende der vierten Jahrgangsstufe im internationalen Vergleich. Waxmann.
Križan, A. (2014). Evidenzbasierte Leseförderung in der Grundschule. Vergleich der Wirksamkeit eines Phonics- und eines Leseflüssigkeitstrainings in der zweiten und vierten Grundschulklasse. Verfügbar unter http://geb.uni-giessen.de/geb/volltexte/2014/10863/pdf/KrizanAna_2014_04_28.pdf [15.01.2024].
Maitz, K., Paleczek, L., Seifert, S., & Gasteiger-Klicpera, B. (2018). Zusammenhang der Leseverständnisleistungen mit sozialen Herkunftsfaktoren bei SchülerInnen der dritten Schulstufe. Zeitschrift für Grundschulforschung, 11(1), 147–160. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42278-018-0012-6
Mayringer, H., & Wimmer, H. (2014). Das Salzburger Lesescreening 2-9 (SLS 2-9). Hogrefe.
National Reading Panel (2000). Teaching children to read: An evidence-based assessment of the scientific research literature on reading and its implications for reading instruction: Reports of the subgroups (NIH Publication No. 00-4754). DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

Michalak, M., Feigenspan, K. (2022). Zum Zusammenspiel von fachbezogenem und sprachlichem Lernen. Zeitschrift für Grundschulforschung 16, 95–111 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s42278-022-00163-w.

OECD (2000). Literacy in the information age: Final report of the international adult literacy survey. Paris: OECD Richter, K. (2003). Die Entwicklung von Lesemotivation und der Literaturunterricht in der Grundschule. In: B. Hurrelmann & S. Becker (Hrsg.), Kindermedien nutzen (S. 115-132). Juventa Verlag.

Rost, D.H. (2006). Handwörterbuch Pädagogische Psychologie (3. überarbeitete und erweiterte Aufl.). Beltz PVU.

Schmich, J., Illetschko, M., & Wallner-Paschon, C. (2023). PIRLS 2021—Die Lesekompetenz am Ende der Volksschule—Erste Ergebnisse (S. 154). Institut des Bundes für Qualitätssicherung im österreichischen Schulwesen. http://doi.org/10.17888/pirls2021-eb.2

Tippelt, R. & Reich-Claassen, J. (2010). Stichwort: Evidenzbasierung. DIE Zeitschrift für Erwachsenenbildung. Abgerufen 17.01.2014, von www.diezeitschrift.de/42010/tippelt1001.pdf

Walter, J. (2013). VSL. Verlaufsdiagnostik sinnerfassenden Lesens (1. Aufl.). Hogrefe.


 
Contact and Legal Notice · Contact Address:
Privacy Statement · Conference: ECER 2024
Conference Software: ConfTool Pro 2.6.153+TC
© 2001–2025 by Dr. H. Weinreich, Hamburg, Germany