Conference Agenda

Overview and details of the sessions of this conference. Please select a date or location to show only sessions at that day or location. Please select a single session for detailed view (with abstracts and downloads if available).

Please note that all times are shown in the time zone of the conference. The current conference time is: 10th May 2025, 09:59:18 EEST

 
Filter by Track or Type of Session 
Only Sessions at Location/Venue 
 
 
Session Overview
Location: Room 117 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [Floor 1]
Cap: 48
Date: Tuesday, 27/Aug/2024
15:15 - 16:4507 SES 02 B: Multilingual Children‘s Language Identity, Decolonising Pedagogical Approaches and Teachers’ Response-Ability
Location: Room 117 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [Floor 1]
Session Chair: Sofia Santos
Paper Session
 
07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Trauma-Affected Refugee Children and Teachers’ Response-Ability: An Explorative Study from Norwegian Classrooms

Inga Storen, Wills Kalisha

NLA University College, Norway

Presenting Author: Storen, Inga; Kalisha, Wills

During war and forced displacement, children are exposed to cruelty, threats, and suffering, the like of which most people in peaceful nations will never know. Upon arrival in host countries in Europe, most refugee children are immediately placed in local schools, since it is generally believed that schools— by offering routine and structure— can provide a ‘safe space’ for trauma-affected children (Eide & Hjern, 2013). Teachers, thus, end up at the “frontline of dealing with the global refugee crisis” (Capstick, 2018, p. 72).

Following increased forced migration in Europe since 2015, several studies have shown high prevalence of trauma exposure among refugee children and youth, as well as high rates of mental health problems like anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (Jensen et al., 2019; Nilsen et al., 2022). However, teachers in European host nations are often ill-equipped at dealing with— and caring for— trauma-affected refugee children (Costa, 2018; Djampour, 2018; Kalisha, 2023). Despite cautions against relying on teachers as mental health professionals, teachers are nonetheless perceived as advocates for trauma-affected children (UNICEF, 2019). In fact, Pastoor (2016) argues that it is crucial teachers have adequate knowledge on how trauma exposure during war, flight, and exile impact refugee children’s learning and behavior in the classroom.

If schools and schooling is indeed relied upon to address vulnerability, trauma, and other migratory-related difficulties, where does this leave teachers? How do teachers understand their role and responsibility in classrooms with refugee children?

This study explores teachers’ encounters with trauma-affected refugee children in Norway. Through semi-structured interviews, teachers are invited to share experiences of their ability and capacity to support refugee learners in their classrooms. The study draws on the concept of response-ability, defined as the ‘ability or capacity to respond’ (Bozalek & Zembylas, 2021). We integrate, too, theories on trauma-informed pedagogy (e.g., Brunzell et al., 2019; Palanac, 2019; UNHCR, 2017).


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
Interview data is scheduled to be collected from teachers (n= ca. 7) working in government schools in Norway, between February and April 2024, following ethical approval. Data will be thematically analyzed using a mixture of emic and etic coding approaches.
Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
The study aims to provide new knowledge and insights into teachers experiences in classrooms with trauma-affected refugee children. As such, the study will contribute to ongoing efforts to meet the psychosocial and learning needs of refugee children in schools across Europe. It also highlights the integral role of teachers in this endeavor.
References
Bozalek, V., & Zembylas, M. (2021). Towards a ‘Response-able’ Pedagogy across Higher Education Institutions in Post-apartheid South Africa: An Ethico-political Analysis. In V. Bozalek, M. Zembylas, and J. C. Tronto (eds.) Posthuman and Political Care Ethics for Reconfiguring Higher Education Pedagogies (pp. 27–37). London and New York: Routledge

Brunzell, T., Stokes, H. & Waters, L. (2019). Shifting Teacher Practice in Trauma-Affected Classrooms:  Practice Pedagogy Strategies Within a Trauma-Informed Positive Education Model. School Mental Health 11, 600–614. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12310-018-09308-8

Capstick, T. (2018). Language for Resilience: Cross-Disciplinary Perspectives. British Council.  www.britishcouncil.org/sites/default/files/language_for_resilience_-_cross-disciplinary_perspectives_0.pdf

Costa, B. (2018). Supporting the supporters – how to be helpful without being a hindrance, in T. Capstick (ed.) Language for Resilience: Cross-Disciplinary Perspectives (pp. 62-63). British Council. www.britishcouncil.org/sites/default/files/language_for_resilience_-_cross-disciplinary_perspectives_0.pdf

Djampour, P. (2018). Border crossing bodies: The stories of eight youth with experiences of migrating [PhD thesis]. Malmö University, Faculty of Health and Society https://doi.org/10.24834/2043/24776

Eide, K. & Hjern, A. (2013). Unaccompanied refugee children – vulnerability and agency. Acta Paediatrica 102(7), 666-668. https://doi.org/10.111/apa.12258

Jensen, T.K., Skar, A.-M.S., Andersson, E.S., et al. (2019) Long-term mental health in unaccompanied refugee minors: Pre-and post-flight predictors. European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 28, 1671–82

Kalisha, W. (2023). Vulnerable enough for inclusion? Unaccompanied minors’ experiences of vulnerability and trauma on their way to Norway. In I. Bostad, M. Papastephanou & T. Strand (eds.) Justice, Education, and the World of Today: Philosophical Investigations (pp. 131-154). Routledge.

Nilsen, S. N., Kvestad, I.  Randal, S. B., Hysing, M., Sayyad, N., & Bøe, T. (2022). Mental health among unaccompanied refugee minors after settling in Norway: A matched cross-sectional study, Scandinavian Journal of Public Health 51(3), 430-441. DOI: 10.1177/14034948221100103

Palanac, A. (2019). Towards a trauma-informed ELT pedagogy for refugees. Language Issues, 30(2), 3-14.

Pastoor, L. d. W. (2016). Enslige unge flyktningers psykososiale utfordringer: behovet for en flyktningkompetent skole. I C. Øverlien, M. I. Hauge & J. H. Schultz (Red.), Barn, vold og traumer. Møter med unge i utsatte livssituasjoner (s. 200-219). Oslo: Universitetsforlaget.

UNHCR (United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, 2017). Teaching about Refugees: Guidance on Working with Refugee Children Struggling with Stress and Trauma. www.unhcr.org/uk/59d346de4.pdf


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Storytelling and Poetry as Decolonising Pedagogical Approaches to Educating for Peace in Algeria's Tuareg Community

Fella Lahmar

The Open University, UK, United Kingdom

Presenting Author: Lahmar, Fella

This paper discusses the use of storytelling and poetry as pedagogical tools in peace education within the Tuareg Muslim community in Southern Algeria. The central key question that the paper examines is how storytelling and poetry, as traditional oral educational practices, are utilised as pedagogical tools for promoting peace within the Tuareg Muslim community in Algeria and what challenges and opportunities arise from integrating these cultural narratives into formal educational settings to impact peace education within and beyond Tuareg communities.

The indigenous inhabitants of North Africa are known as Berbers, or as some defined themselves as Imazighen, which literally means "free men." The Berber linguistic landscape in Algeria includes several dialects (Hagan & Myers, 2006; Shoup, 2012). Within this broader Berber context, the Tuareg in Algeria cultivated a distinct cultural identity. Tuareg, a nomadic group residing in Southern Algeria, is known for their use of the Tamesheq language dialect, with their adeptness in navigating the Saharan landscape. Tuareg's cultural practices, including the veiling of men's faces, are rich in symbolism. French colonisation in the 19th century marked a significant shift, forcing a transition from nomadic to more sedentary lifestyles, yet the Tuareg maintained many traditional customs (Shoup, 2012). Moreover, the imposition of Western educational models disrupted traditional practices, including the oral transmission of knowledge and values.

Historically organised tribally with a class-based system, their society comprises nobles, religious scholars, artisans, and various strata of vassals and labourers. Tuareg's oral literature tradition, primarily in the Tifinagh or Libyan script, consists of monumental inscriptions and a vibrant storytelling and poetry culture. These oral narratives serve as a medium for imparting religious and cultural values, including pre-Islamic myths and legends.

Storytelling and poetry play a pivotal role in transmitting cultural values and shaping the worldview of the Tuareg people in Algeria. These oral traditions are integral to the informal education system within the Tuareg community, serving not only as a means of entertainment but also as vital pedagogical tools. Through narratives imbued with teachings on social values, storytelling and poetry convey profound moral and ethical lessons, ensuring the passage of the community's rich heritage from one generation to the next.

Theoretically, the concept of Assabiyah, as discussed by Ibn-Khaldun (2005), refers to the social cohesion and collective solidarity that bind a community together, enabling it to act as a unified entity. This concept is particularly relevant to understanding subjects' cultural context when considering the role of storytelling and poetry in the Tuareg community of Algeria as a means of educating peace and transmitting cultural values.

This study presents how the stories and poems of the Tuareg are more than mere words; they are carriers of values and a reflection of the community's underpinning philosophies. They foster critical thinking and problem-solving skills, as exemplified by the story of Amamalandilyas, which is used to instil foundational values and develop peace resolution and reconciliation skills. These narratives guide young members in understanding their cultural identities and social responsibilities, thereby shaping their worldview and moral compass.

Despite their importance, storytelling and poetry face numerous challenges in the modern era. The advent of technology, the transition towards formal education systems, and the shift from a nomadic to a sedentary lifestyle have all threatened the continuity of these oral traditions. This paper advocates for acknowledging these approaches' artistic and educational potential effectiveness in peacebuilding. This further underscores the need to shift from Western-centric methodologies to embrace traditional heritage, contextually relevant, and culturally attuned educational practices, which can significantly impact peace education in Algeria and potentially in other similar contexts.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
The data for this study are part of the 'Decolonising Education for Peace in Africa (DEPA)' research project in Algeria, focusing on the values of reconciliation and peace within traditional Algerian art heritage. With ethical approval from the Open University (HREC/4669/Raghuram/Lahmar), the research was conducted in four Algerian provinces: Aïn Beïda (Oum El-Bouaghi province), Beni Maouche (Béjaïa province), Ghardaïa city, and Tamanrasset city and its outskirts, with additional insights from Guelma Province. The analysis in this paper is derived from three Jama'a focus group discussions and eight semi-structured individual interviews in Tamanrasset province. All recordings were transcribed and translated into standard Arabic and English. Subjects preferring the Tamesheq dialect, due to limited fluency in Algerian Arabic, were provided instant translations for approval during their interviews. I employed NVivo for thematic data exploration and ChatGPT-4 for Arabic to English translations and critical review. As a native Arabic speaker fluent in the Algerian dialect (Darija), I ensured the accuracy of all translations. Data were anonymized before any translation or NVivo coding. However, it's crucial to recognize the limitations of these tools. The analysis and writing are my original work.
Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
Storytelling and poetry have long been integral to the cultural fabric of the Tuareg Muslim community in Algeria, serving as vital pedagogical tools that impart moral lessons, ethical teachings, and cultural values. These oral traditions are key to shaping the worldview of the Tuareg people, influencing their perceptions, beliefs, and behaviours. The narratives and poems passed down through generations encapsulate the essence of Tuareg's rich heritage, playing a significant role in peace education by fostering understanding, empathy, and social cohesion within the community.
Also, the Tuareg's oral traditions are more than just a means of preserving their cultural identity; they are also a vehicle for peacebuilding. Through the stories and poems that emphasize themes of justice, compassion, and community, individuals learn to navigate social relationships and conflicts in ways that prioritize harmony and mutual respect.
These narratives often contain lessons on how to resolve disputes, encourage dialogue, and foster a culture of non-violence and understanding. They serve as a means to impart wisdom and strategies for conflict resolution, emphasising the importance of peaceful coexistence and mutual respect. Through the power of storytelling and poetry, the Tuareg community educates its members on the principles of negotiation, patience, and empathy, which are crucial for maintaining social harmony and building a foundation for lasting peace.
Integrating storytelling and poetry into formal education is a delicate process that requires a nuanced approach. It is essential to consider religious, cultural, linguistic, and pedagogical factors to maintain the integrity and effectiveness of these traditions. The challenge lies in finding innovative and culturally respectful methods to incorporate these oral forms into the curriculum without diluting their essence. By doing so, educators can leverage the power of storytelling and poetry to enhance peace education, promoting values that are essential for sustainable peace and reconciliation among communities.

References
Gallagher, K. M. (2011). In search of a theoretical basis for storytelling in education research: story as method. International Journal of Research & Method in Education, 34(1), 49-61. https://doi.org/10.1080/1743727x.2011.552308
Galtung, J. (1969). Violence, Peace, and Peace Research. Journal of Peace Research, 6(3), 167-191.
Galtung, J. (1996). Peace by peaceful means: Peace and conflict, development and civilization. SAGE Publications.
Hagan, H. E., & Myers, L. C. (2006). Tuareg Jewelry: Traditional Patterns and Symbols: Xlibris US.
Hallaq, W. B. (2013). The impossible state: Islam, politics, and modernity's moral predicament. Columbia University Press.
Ibn-Khaldūn, ʿAbd Al-Raḥmān. 2005. Al-Muqaddimah [The Introduction]. Edited by Abdesselam Cheddadi. Casablanca: Beit Al-funun wa Al-ulum wa Al-adab, vol. 3.
Keenan, J. (2004). The lesser gods of the Sahara: Social change and contested terrain amongst the Tuareg of Algeria. Frank Cass.
Lum, B. J. (2018). Peace Education: Past, present and future. Taylor & Francis.
Shoup, J. A. (2012). Ethnic groups of Africa and the Middle East: An encyclopedia. Oxford: ABC-CLIO.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Ecological Approaches to Multilingual Children‘s Language Identity Development.

Hanna Ragnarsdóttir, Kristin Jonsdottir, Anna Katrin Eiriksdottir, Samúel Lefever, Anh-Dao Katrin Tran

University of Iceland, Iceland

Presenting Author: Ragnarsdóttir, Hanna; Jonsdottir, Kristin

While immigration to Iceland has grown in recent years, student populations in schools at different levels have become increasingly diverse in terms of languages and cultures.

This paper derives from the research project Language policies and practices of diverse immigrant families in Iceland and their implications for education. The objectives of the project are to explore language policies and practices of diverse immigrant families (Curdt-Christiansen, 2013; Spolsky, 2004), how these affect their children’s education and the relationships and interactions between these families and the children‘s teachers.

The research questions posed in this paper are:

· How do multilingual children‘s language identities develop within their families?

· How do they negotiate these in a school and societal environment which is mainly Icelandic?

The paper builds on Bronfenbrenner‘s ecological systems theory (1979, 2005) which views child development as being affected by multiple levels of the surrounding environment, from the family settings and school to broader societal and cultural values and a further development of this theory by Schwartz (in press). It explores how different systems affect multilingual children‘s language identities. The theoretical framework also includes writings on familiy language policy (FLP). It brings together research on multilingualism, language acquisition, language policy and cultural studies. Spolsky (2004, p. 5) distinguished three components of family language policy: 1) language practices „the habitual pattern of selecting among the varieties that make up its linguistic repertoire“; 2) language beliefs or ideology „the beliefs about language and language use“; and 3) language management „any specific efforts to modify or influence that practice by any kind of language intervention, planning or management.” These have been extended further by Curdt Christiansen (2013), who notes that FLP also recognizes the relevance and influence of economic, political and social structures and processes in a given society.

While early approaches to FLP according to Curdt-Christiansen (2013), emphasized language input, parental discourse strategy and linguistic environmental conditions, more recently there has been a shift of focus in research towards issues such as why different values are ascribed to different languages, how parents view bilingualism from emotional, sociocultural, and cognitive perspectives, and what kinds of family literacy environment and parental capital are likely to promote bilingualism. These components differ from one family to another and Schwartz (2018) notes that pro-active family language management might interact with and be influenced by the surrounding ethno-linguistic community and schools (policy-makers, teachers, and peers). When children enter a new socio-cultural community, such as a school where a majority language is spoken, they also encounter culturally related challenges. There they have to learn not only the vocabulary and grammar, but they also have to recognize and acquire the cultural norms connected to the language use. Bi- or multilingual children, who are a heterogeneous group, experience the differences on a daily basis and gradually acquire insights into all languages that they are exposed to. Children sometimes use translanguaging, i.e. the effective communication through activating all linguistic resources of the individual, is used to achieve communicative goals (García & Wei, 2014). Wilson (2020) argues that whilst the language management of minority-language parents tends to be geared towards transmitting a linguistic heritage, often associated with their emotional bond to the home country, their children, who may be born in the country of immigration, may not share such a deep connection with the heritage culture. As a result, children‘s language choices may differ from their parents.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
The project is a qualitative research study and involves altogether 16 immigrant families who have diverse languages and educational and socio-economic backgrounds, and their children (age 2-16) of different genders, as well as the children’s teachers and principals at preschool and compulsory school levels and, where relevant, their heritage language teachers.
Data for this paper were collected in semi-structured interviews and language portraits from four children, semi-structured interviews with the children‘s parents, as well as teachers and principals in the children‘s schools.
Semi-structured interviews were chosen to elicit the views of the participants as clearly and accurately as possible (Kvale, 2007).
The families live in four different municipalities in Iceland. Families speaking heritage languages belonging to both small (such as Philippines) and large (Polish) language groups in Iceland were selected. The municipalities are located in four different parts of Iceland and there may be important differences between the municipalities where the children are located when it comes to educational opportunities and support.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
The findings indicate that the children‘s language identities develop in multiple ways and are affected by different systems, including family, school and society, as well as peers. The children make active choices on when and how to use their diverse languages and appear to have hybrid language identities. They negotiate these on a daily basis within their schools, among their peers and within their families. The families‘ language policies are diverse manifested in different practices at home and in their engagement with the school staff. Some families reported that teachers seemed to be unaware of the possibilities to encourage children to use their heritage languages in their studies at school. The findings also reveal that the participating families value their children’s language repertoire and use diverse methods and resources to support the children‘s multilingual development. The findings indicate that the teachers are interested in supporting the children‘s multilingualism but they claim that Icelandic is the language of instruction and emphasize that it is extremely important for the children‘s education that they learn Icelandic in schools. The teachers also noted that they were not well aware of methods related to multilingual education.
References
Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979). The ecology of human development: Experiments by nature and design. Harvard University Press.
Bronfenbrenner, U. (2005). Making human beings human: Bioecological perspectives on human development. Sage.
Curdt-Christiansen, X. L. (2013). Family language policy: sociopolitical reality versuslinguistic continuity. Language policy, 12, 1-6. DOI 10.1007/s10993-012-9269-0
García, O. & Wei, L. (2014).Translanguaging: Language, bilingualism and education. Palgrave MacMillan.
Spolsky, B. (2004). Language policy. Cambridge University Press.
Wilson, S. (2020).Family language policy: Children’s perspectives. Palgrave


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Surviving and Thriving: Syrian and Iraqi Refugee Children in Icelandic Society

Magnus Bernhardsson1, Lara Wilhelmine Hoffmann2

1Williams College, United States of America; 2University of Iceland

Presenting Author: Hoffmann, Lara Wilhelmine

This paper presents preliminary findings from the research project, A Part and Apart? Education and social inclusion of refugee children and youth in Iceland (ESRCI). This inter-disciplinary, multi-year project, that was one of four projects to be awarded by the Icelandic Research Council in 2023 as a "Grant of Excellence" seeks to critically explore the education and social inclusion of Syrian and Iraqi refugee children and youth at pre-, compulsory and upper secondary levels and the structures created for their learning and wellbeing in their social and educational settings.

In collaboration with the UNHCR, in 2015 the Icelandic government invited around forty families fleeing the wars in Syria and Iraq to immigrate to Iceland. These so-called "Quota Refugees" settled in elven different municipalities around the country as part of state agreements with those municipalities.

Findings of previous research in Iceland have revealed multiple challenges that refugee children face in Icelandic schools and society, but also educational and social success (Hama, 2020; Hariri et al., 2020; Ragnarsdóttir & Hama, 2018). Compared to most European countries, Iceland has had a limited experience with immigration. While there has been some research on refugee groups in Iceland, ESRCI is the first extensive inter-disciplinary research . The project is directed by the overarching research question: How do the education system and socio-cultural environments in Iceland contribute to the education and social inclusion of refugee children and youth? I am one of the two principal investigators of this project.

The project is divided into four pillars. I am responsible for he fourth which is Cultural and Historical Backgrounds of Syrian and Iraqi Refugee Children and Youth. Drawing on evidence, material and data related to the theme in this pillar, the paper aims to explore how the specific traumas of war and displacement impact the acclimation of these refugees and how their cultural, linguistic, and religious backgrounds may influence what their overall experience in Iceland.

Research questions include:

1: What is the nature of refugee children’s and youth’s experience with the integration processes in Iceland?

2: How does displacement and the memory of war impact their social and educational development?
3: How do the schools accommodate these children‘s traumatic experiences andwhich linguistically and culturally responsive practices are in place?
4: How are the children’s and youth’s cultural needs addressed, both in school policy and practice?

Utilizing the methodology of comparative global history (Lim, 2022) and Immigration and Migration Studies (Hamlin 2021), this paper will evaluate how the social and historical backgrounds of these refugeee children affect their experiences in and out of school. Given the difficult exposure to war and violence and the physical hardship of flight and migration, it has taken these children a considerable time to adapt to these new surroundings and put their trust in the relevant educational authorities. Though their may be commonalities in all immigrant and refugee experiences, particularly in a small and homogenous country like Iceland, I am particularly interested in what makes this a Syrian or Iraqi story. How does their country of origin impact their experiences? Though they are surviving, are they thriving in Icelandic society? And if not, why not? All to often, Icelanders tend to put the blame on immigrants for not being able to adapt to Icelandic society. But is there something about Icelandic culture that makes it difficult for Syrians and Iraqis to be the best version of themselves? How are the schools building on their social and historical resources to best take advantage of this new situation?


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
The qualitative ESRCI research project involves Syrian and Iraqi refugee children and youth of different genders and their parents who have diverse educational and socio-economic backgrounds, altogether 40 families with children in schools at one or more levels (pre-, compulsory and upper secondary) in eleven municipalities in Iceland, as well as the children’s teachers, principals and where relevant, school counsellors in the children’s schools, municipality persons, social services and NGOs. The eleven municipalities are located in different parts of Iceland: Southwest (Capital area), Northwest, West Fjords, Northeast, East and South Iceland. Purposive sampling was used to select the families and information on the participants obtained from authorities (Stjórnarráð Íslands, n.d.). Multiple case studies are conducted with quota refugee children and youth in altogether 40 families in eleven municipalities in urban and rural contexts in Iceland. Each of the 40 families is considered to be one case. According to Stake (2005), a case study is frequently chosen as it draws attention to what in particular can be learned from a particular case. Semi-structured in-depth and focus group interviews (Morgan, 1997) are used for data collection, using interview guides developed by the research team. Emphasis is put on exploring the children’s voices, including child friendly, emancipatory approaches in addition to semi-structured in-depth interviews with children (age 12-18). To ensure children’s participation and agency, data is also collected through active instruments such as participatory place-based methods, child led tour “walk-along” interviews and short diaries and narratives (Dennis, et al, 2009). The analytical process takes place concurrently throughout the research period. My training as a historian of modern Middle Eastern history who has a joint appointment at the University of Iceland and Williams College in the United States, I will evaluate the data from these interviews to consider how Syrian and Iraqi historical experiences factor into their time in Iceland.
Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
The paper presents preliminary findings and interpretations from data collected in the eleven municipalities in Iceland. The findings reveal various challenges that the children and families experience in acclimating to new surroundings and to process the trauma of war, displacement, and exile. Further, this paper will evaluate how the specifically the cultural, religious, environmental and political backgrounds of these refugees contrasts with other resettlement communities particularly how they deal with their encounters with racism and Islamophobia. These intense cultural negotiations and the development of new forms of identities as as  general well being at school are dependent on many different factors, including teaching practices, level of participation and inclusion, communication with peer groups, as well as cultural issues. The children who experience exclusion or other obstacles at school are often less motivated to learn the new language. However, some of the children have progressed in their studies and are active participants in social activities at school.  
 

References
Baczko, A, Dorronsoro G., Quesnay, A Civil War in Syria: Mobilization and Competing Social Orders. 1st ed. Cambridge University Press, 2017.

Burns, T. (2008). Education and migration background research synthesis. Paris: OECD. Retrieved from http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/37/53/40636545.pdf  

Daoudy, M. The Origins of the Syrian Conflict: Climate Change and Human Security. Cambridge, United Kingdom ; New York, NY: Cambridge University Press, 2020.
 
Gay, G. (2010). Classroom practices for teaching diversity: An example from Washington State (United States). In Educating teachers for diversity: Meeting the challenge (pp. 257–279). París: OECD Publishing. Retrieved from https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/education/educating-teachers-for-diversity_9789264079731-en
Hama, S. R. (2020). Experiences and expectations of successful immigrant and refugee students while in upper secondary schools in Iceland [Doctoral dissertation, University of Iceland]. Opin vísindi. https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.11815/2182  

Hariri, K. E., Gunnþórsdóttir, H. & Meckl, M. (2020). Syrian students at the Arctic circle in Iceland. In N. Yeasmin, W. Hasanat, J. Brzozowski  & S. Kirchner (Eds.), Immigration in the circumpolar north: integration and resilience. London: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429344275   
Keyel, J. Resettled Iraqi Refugees in the United States : War, Refuge, Belonging, Participation, and Protest. Forced Migration, Volume 47. New York: Berghahn Books, 2023.
Kohlbacher, J. & Schiocchet, L. (eds.) From Destination to Integration : Afghan, Syrian and Iraqi Refugees in Vienna. Isr- Forschungsberichte, Heft 45. Wien: Verlag der österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 2017.
Mazur, K Revolution in Syria : Identity, Networks, and Repression: Cambridge University Press, 2021
Ragnarsdóttir, H. & Hama, S. R. (2018). Refugee children in Icelandic schools: Experiences of families and schools. In H. Ragnarsdóttir & S. Lefever (Eds.), Icelandic studies on diversity and social justice in education (pp. 82–104). Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Press.
 
Ragnarsdóttir, H. & Schmidt, C. (2014). Introduction. In H. Ragnarsdóttir & C. Schmidt (Eds.), Learning spaces for social justice: International perspectives on exemplary practices from preschool to secondary school (pp. 1–8). London: A Trentham Book. Institute of Education Press.

Saleh, Z. Return to Ruin : Iraqi Narratives of Exile and Nostalgia. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press, 2021.

Sarkin, J. The Conflict in Syria and the Failure of International Law to Protect People Globally : Mass Atrocities, Enforced Disappearances, and Arbitrary Detentions / Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, 2022.
 
17:15 - 18:4507 SES 03 B: Teacher Education Studies in Social Justice and Intercultural Education I
Location: Room 117 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [Floor 1]
Session Chair: Carola Mantel
Paper Session
 
07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Developing a Dialogic and Intercultural Pedagogy: A Case Study on Community Philosophical Practice in Initial Teacher Education

Isabella Pescarmona, Valerio Ferrero

University of Turin, Italy

Presenting Author: Pescarmona, Isabella; Ferrero, Valerio

Initial teacher education (ITE) is becoming increasingly important to ensure that all students have an equitable, inclusive and high-quality school experience (EC, 2021) and learn to play an active role in today’s complex and multicultural society (Cochran-Smith, 2020; Kaur, 2012). Issues of intercultural education and social justice are central in an increasingly interconnected and globalised world (Aguado-Odina et al., 2017; Bhatti et al., 2007). But it needs to be studied in depth how to promote intercultural education in ITE curricula in such a way that future teachers can acquire an habitus focused on social justice and value the uniqueness of everyone, by avoiding the risk of falling into empty rhetoric about diversity (Leeman & Ledoux, 2003; Tarozzi, 2014) and taking into account teaching and learning methods.

Thus, it might be useful to discuss ITE, starting from university teaching, by proposing a change in traditional teaching methods to achieve this much-needed valorization of diversity and the construction of shared knowledge based on dialogue (Cochran-Smith & Fries, 2008). There is a need to move away from traditional delivery transmissive methods to participatory methods that effectively can engage future teachers in an intercultural dialogue and enable them to build their professionalism by deconstructing their ideals, perspectives and beliefs about diversity and their role in class and developing new interpretive lenses and teaching strategies to be effective in heterogeneous contexts. The process of questioning those implicit beliefs and knowledge and fostering complex professional interpretations must be supported (Stephens et al., 2022). In this way, a disorientation can be brought about that creates imaginative spaces for new scenarios of pedagogical action in the classroom and for professional identity (Ellis et al., 2019). Undertaking this process is precisely the basis for intercultural education, which is not only about acquiring knowledge and theoretical principles, but also about constructing and rethinking one’s own professional identity in dialogical contexts.

Our paper aims to contribute to this discussion by proposing to use collaborative philosophical dialogue following the model developed by Matthew Lipman (2003; 2008) to design courses in ITE on issues of intercultural and social justice in education in academic courses. Lipman’s approach has traditionally been used in schools to promote complex thinking (Kennedy, 2012), but its potential can also be used for ITE, especially to reflect on educational processes in heterogeneous and multicultural contexts. Indeed, it encourages the active participation of future teachers in the form of an inquiry exercise that allows them to give original interpretations and unexplored perspectives on the issues discussed and to develop an ethical stance through the confrontation with different perspectives (Oliverio, 2014; Santi et al, 2019). This process can trigger a virtuous circle between philosophical dialogue and intercultural education (Anderson, 2016), as prospective teachers develop the ability to question their own beliefs about education, move between different systems of meaning, and open up to shared contexts.

Our paper addresses this issue from a theoretical standpoint by discussing a case study conducted within a ITE course at the University of Turin (Italy), in which future teachers were engaged in community philosophical dialogues to develop, discuss and problematize some issues of intercultural education. In particular, we would like to encourage discussion on the following questions:

  • How can Lipmanian philosophical practise be used and developed in ITE?
  • How can it support the future teachers in building a social justice-oriented habitus?
  • Could the application of this approach become a resource for ITE to address intercultural issues in terms of reflectivity?

Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
The experience conducted in an ITE course at the University of Turin (Italy) takes the form of a case study (Hamilton & Corbett-Whittier, 2012). Community philosophical practise will be used implemented in some lectures or lessons according to Lipman’s model (2003). The collaborative reading of stimulus texts proposed encourages the formulation of questions on intercultural education. Then, these questions are analysed and organised according to the thematic strands to which they relate. In this way, a discussion plan is defined and shared by the group; thus, the dialogue begins and engage all the participant in an active way. The dialogue is concluded with a self-evaluation about dialogue mode and depth level.
We will use a qualitative approach: data will be collected through the observation of community philosophical practice activities and the analysis of the dialogues in which the future teachers will be engaged. In particular, these dialogues will be recorded, transcribed and analysed in the manner of low-structured focus groups (Stewart & Shamdasani, 2014) through a thematic analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2006): it will illuminate the intercultural themes on which the dialogues will focus.
An original aspect of this ITE research process is the writing of specific pretexts to initiate philosophical dialogue. The use of this practise in ITE on intercultural issues has made it necessary to construct specific texts based on the indications of Lipman and those studies that deal with philosophical narratives (Oliverio, 2015), as well as on the PEACE curriculum (2015), designed for use with children and adolescents to develop skills in reflexive cosmopolitanism.
Our pedagogical process is thus designed as a journey that aims to
- test the effectiveness of the new materials by understanding whether they meet the requirements identified in the literature (presence of multiple strands of inquiry, presentation of multiple epistemic positions, raising questions on multiple thematic strands), thanks to the analysis of dialogic processes and the questions formulated by future teachers;
- evaluate the effectiveness and impact on the ability to critically address intercultural issues by creating spaces where voices can be heard, problematizing your own relationship to diversity and changing the values and expectations of future teachers.
The self-evaluation will be crucial to listen to the voices of the protagonists and understand their perceptions on the activity and effectiveness of using community philosophical practice in ITE to achieve the objectives related to intercultural education.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
We expect that applying the philosophical practise of Lipman’s community will enable future teachers to challenge themselves in the co-construction of pedagogical ideals, to reflect on their tacit knowledge and beliefs about diversity, and to change their habitual perspectives on education through philosophical dialogue. On the one hand, focusing on intercultural and social justice issues through specifically written pretexts could enable the acquisition of knowledge related to the epistemological domains of the discipline in an active way by future teachers. On the other hand, community philosophical practice could facilitate a decentralisation on its part to better understand the other’s point of view and consequently better define one’s own point of view in light of the possibilities of encounter and exchange. Indeed, dialogue is a central tool of intercultural education: through community philosophical practice and they could internalise a habitus open to the other and to different perspectives.
Therefore, we will present the voice of the participants and their ideas from the data that emerged from the thematic analysis and participant observation, discussing the opportunities and criticalities of this approach for ITE in intercultural education at university level.

References
Aguado-Odina, T., Mata-Benito, P., & Gil-Jaurena, I. (2017). Mobilizing intercultural education for equity and social justice. Time to react against the intolerable: A proposal from Spain. Intercultural Education, 28(4), 408-423.
Anderson, B. (ed.). (2016). Philosophy for Children: Theories and praxis in teacher education. London: Taylor & Francis.
Bhatti, G., Gaine, C., Gobbo, F., & Leeman, Y. (2007). Social justice and intercultural education: An open-ended dialogue. Sterling: Trentham.
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative research in psychology, 3(2), 77-101.
Cochran-Smith, M. (2020). Teacher education for justice and equity: 40 years of advocacy. Action in teacher education, 42(1), 49-59.
Cochran-Smith, M., & Fries, K. (2008). Research on teacher education: Changing times, changing paradigms. In Handbook of research on teacher education (pp. 1050-1093). New York: Routledge.
Ellis, V., Souto-Manning, M., & Turvey, K. (2019). Innovation in teacher education: towards a critical re-examination. Journal of Education for Teaching, 45(1), 2-14.
EC (2021). Teachers in Europe. Careers, Development and Well-being. Bruxelles: Publications Office of the EU.
Hamilton, L., & Corbett-Whittier, C. (2012). Using case study in education research. London: Sage.
Kaur, B. (2012). Equity and social justice in teaching and teacher education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 28(4), 485-492.
Kennedy, D. (2012). Lipman, Dewey, and the community of philosophical inquiry. Education and Culture, 28(2), 36-53.
Leeman, Y., & Ledoux, G. (2003). Preparing teachers for intercultural education. Teaching Education, 14(3), 279-291.
Lipman, M. (2003). Thinking in Education. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lipman, M. (2008). A Life Teaching Thinking: An Autobiography. Montclair: IAPC.
Oliverio, S. (2014). Between the De-traditionalization and “Aurorality” of Knowledge: What (Can) Work(s) in P4C when It Is Set to Work. Thinking: The Journal of Philosophy for Children, 20(3/4), 105-112.
Oliverio, S. (2015). Lipman’s novels or turning philosophy inside-out. Childhood & Philosophy, 11(21), 81-92.
PEACE (2015). Reflexive cosmopolitanism. Educating towards inclusiove communities through philosophical enquiry. Madrid: La Rectoral.
Santi, M., Striano, M., & Oliverio, S. (2019). Philosophical Inquiry and Education “through” Democracy. Promoting Cosmopolitan and Inclusive Societies. Scuola democratica, 10(4), 74-91.
Stephens, J. M., Rubie-Davies, C., & Peterson, E. R. (2022). Do preservice teacher education candidates’ implicit biases of ethnic differences and mindset toward academic ability change over time?. Learning and instruction, 78, 101480.
Stewart, D.W., & Shamdasani, P.N. (2014). Focus group. Theory And Practice. London: Sage.
Tarozzi, M. (2014). Building an ‘intercultural ethos’ in teacher education. Intercultural education, 25(2), 128-142.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Moving Towards an Understanding of the Emotional and Psychological Dangers Threatening UK South Asian Students on Teacher Training Courses

Diane Warner, Zoe Crompton

Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, United Kingdom

Presenting Author: Warner, Diane; Crompton, Zoe

The system of initial teacher training in England is changing and this presents new challenges for Black and Asian students whose lives are already impeded by memories and experiences of racism. This presents an increasingly uncertain future and compounds the backdrop of existing racialised structures that occur recursively to continually suppress them (Marom, 2019). Teacher training in the mid-21st century has consistently standardised and normalised practices that reinforce white spaces and cultural knowledge (Warner, 2022). The new changes to teacher training begins in Autumn of 2024 will intensify and further embed hidden racialised and oppressive expectations and practices in the training curriculum (Department for Education, 2022). This Paper examines the debilitating effect of becoming a teacher, on British South Asian people who are often positioned as deficit and under-performing.

The teacher training curriculum in England does not include teaching about race, culture or ethnicity (Department for Education, 2019) despite the UK’s rich multicultural position. Alongside this, the forthcoming new restructure will increase time on school placements; which is recognised as the main combustion point for Black and Asian student teachers, leading to acute emotional and mental difficulties or leaving the course (Warner, 2022). Being undermined, under-supported and marginalised, are some of the findings of the research of the Paper. The research conducted in an English university, was motivated by the annual recurrence of the same problems experienced by South Asian students. There were 10 female and one male student teachers, identifying as British South Asian. Their narratives of obstacles and problems that obfuscate and impede their progression and understanding are manifold. Racialised practices, embedded within both university and school systems, are found to disproportionately affect them.

Attrition rates and under-achievement of student teachers who identify as British South Asian, in the English system of initial teacher training, are an unfortunately common occurrence (Tereshchenko, Bradbury & Mills, 2021).  The Pakistani heritage of nearly all of the participants in our research, raises specific intersectional cultural issues such as high parental and community expectations, gender roles of marriage and motherhood expectations and lack of knowledge of gaining entry into and navigating higher education systems (Subedi, 2008). There are also fears of losing their cultural and religious values through the university process.  However, possession of self-efficacy means they are able to transform and rework their parents’ cultures and religion to reflect their contemporary world, thus retaining links with the past while being successful in their personal lives.

It is evident that British South Asian student teachers navigate through a social system that fears their presence and devalues them. Subedi (2008) suggests that systems of teacher training mark South Asian teachers as “inauthentic”; signifying them as “marginal, perhaps deviant, both of which are interwoven with tropes of national identity and values” (p.57). The concept of ‘gendered Islamophobia’ stigmatises them and sets them against Eurocentric, white ideals, that essentialises and categorises people according to colour, language and culture (Bibi, 2022).   However while they also engage in self-motivation and agency to navigate these situations, they become enmeshed in power hierarchies, that are evident in teacher education requirements and categorises them as non-legitimate in their teacher identities (Subedi, 2008).


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
This research is undergirded by the epistemic and methodological approaches of the ‘Silences Framework’ (Serrant-Green, 2011) and what we have called ‘Racialised Identifications’ (Gunaratnam, 2003). These approaches support anti-racist and de-colonised analyses and begin to claim the connection between race, identity and knowledge production.  They offer an alternative to ITE policy in England, in which standardised discourses entangle and disregard identities of Black and Asian student teachers and where race, ethnicity and other forms of cultural difference are problematically absent (Warner, 2022).  

 

The ‘Silences Framework’ is cyclical and includes: working in silences, hearing silences, voicing silences working with silences.  It generates affirmative spaces to talk about deeply personal responses, bringing together unspoken and little articulated ideas, with memories and experiences.  ‘Racialised Identifications’ (Gunaratnam, 2003) seeks to draw on individual narratives of identity, honouring how participants express, resist and mediate within themselves and those around them.  Alterity can be mapped onto their narratives, avoiding the diminishing effects of essentialism and othering and instead promoting ideas of narrative elusiveness, contradictions and instability that racialised subjects experience. This approach asserts individuals seeing and projecting themselves as changing in response to the effects of their environments, identifying stigmatisation and erasure within dominant discourses.

Interviews and focus groups are the main methods of gathering narratives and which frame these ethical considerations:

Interviews were conducted online allowing participants to not be videod to further protect anonymity; sensitive questioning was used to facilitate difficult and emotional recounts; and the Findings’ section draft were shared with individuals before publication.

Our researcher position is also called into question because while we our research began with a Pakistani, Muslim colleague, we ended as two non-south Asian researchers.  This necessitated shifting our mind-sets to confront questions of whose cultural territory within which we are we engaging?  Working in negotiated spaces supported dissipation of researcher privilege and epistemic control (Gunaratnam, 2003) and differences in researchers’ and participants’ ethnic heritages can be a positive dynamic if it is premised on the inter-play between sympathy, authenticity and a desire to move forwards in knowledge construction (Gabi, Olsson-Rost, Warner and Asif, 2023).

These methodologies can facilitate knowledge production around race and exclusion and enable the positional ‘other’ to come into the view and speak the unspeakable that White methodologies cannot grasp (Serrant-Green, 2011).

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
This research paper recognises and implicitly challenges systems within UK teacher training that reduces British South Asian students to tropes of vulnerability and inauthenticity.  It understands how racialized challenges and imposed dominations in ITE, renders them voiceless in the system, although measures of resistance and agency enables some to navigate a way (Mirza, 2013).   The conjoined methodologies of the ‘Silences Framework’ (Serrant Green 2011) and the ‘Racialised Identification’ methodologies (Gunaratnam, 2003) redress the silo-ing of their racialised voices to challenge deficit and assimilationist understandings. Our epistemic base is of listening and affirming words, phrases and concepts that speak of deeper issues and systemic repressions and that insist South Asian student teachers bring about their own destinies and are a possible danger in the classrooms and society (Farrell & Lander, 2019).

Through its specific focus on British South Asian student teachers who leave their teacher training course or experience debilitating problems that affect their progress, this paper offers some detailed insights into their experiences in university and school spaces.  Through their narratives, the paper probes how the nature of ITE, university cultures and school placement cultural norms, pose ethnic and social challenges for them and explores how they navigate or even reject these impositions (Mirza, 2012).  We recognise ourselves as non-South Asian researchers, in powerful positions as university tutors and we work to negate this situation through clear communication, using a flexible and listening interview process and sharing writing drafts before publication.

In moving towards an understanding of the emotional and psychological dangers that threaten the stability of British South Asian student teachers, we recognise that gender, social class and religion dictate how exclusionary practices operate around them (Phoenix, 2019).  These pressures conspire to limit them and transform them into sites of inability and non-legitimacy.

References
Bibi, R (2022) Outside belonging: a discursive analysis of British South Asian (BSA) Muslim women’s experiences of being ‘Othered’ in local spaces, Ethnic and Racial Studies, DOI: 10.1080/01419870.2022.2123715

Department for Education (2019).ITT Core Content Framework (publishing.service.gov.uk) Accessed 12.12.23

Department for Education (2022)  Market review of initial teacher training (ITT) - GOV.UK (www.gov.uk)  Accessed 12.12.23

Farrell, F. & Lander, V. (2019) “We’re not British values teachers are we?”: Muslim teachers’ subjectivity and the governmentality of unease’ in Educational Review, 71:4, 466-482, DOI: 10.1080/00131911.2018.1438369

Gabi, J., Olsson-Rost, A., Asif, U. & Warner, D. (2023) 'Decolonial Praxis: Teacher educators' perspectives on tensions, barriers, and possibilities of anti-racist practice-based Initial Teacher Education in England' in Curriculum Journal of British Educational Research Association.  DOI:10.1002/curj.174    

Gunaratnam, Y. (2003) ‘Looking for ‘race’? analysing racialized meanings and identifications’ in Researching Race and Ethnicity, London:Sage

Marom, L. (2019) Under the cloak of professionalism: covert racism in teacher education, Race Ethnicity and Education, 22:3, 319-337, DOI: 10.1080/13613324.2018.1468748

Mirza, H. S. 2012. “Embodying the Veil: Muslim Women and Gendered Islamopobia in ‘New Times’.” In Gender, Religion and Education in a Chaotic Postmodern World, edited by Z. Gross, L. Davies, and A. L. Diab, 303–316. London: Springer. [Google Scholar]

Mirza, H. S. 2013. “‘A Second Skin’: Embodied Intersectionality, Transnationalism and Narratives of Identity and Belonging among Muslim Women in Britain.” Women’s Studies International Forum 36: 5–15. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®], [Google Scholar]

Phoenix, A. (2019) Negotiating British Muslim belonging: a qualitative longitudinal study, Ethnic and Racial Studies, 42:10, 1632-1650, DOI: 10.1080/01419870.2018.1532098

Serrant-Green L. (2011) ‘The sound of ‘silence’:a framework for researching sensitive issues or marginalised perspectives in health’ in Journal of Research in Nursing16(4) 347–360.  DOI: 10.1177/1744987110387741  

Subedi, B. (2008) Contesting racialization: Asian immigrant teachers' critiques and claims of teacher authenticity’ in Race Ethnicity and Education, 11:1, 57-70, DOI: 10.1080/13613320701845814

Tereshchenko, A., Bradbury, A. & Mills, M. (2021). What makes minority ethnic teachers stay in teaching, or leave? London: UCL Institute of Education. What makes minority ethnic teachers stay in teaching or leave.pdf (ucl.ac.uk)

Warner, D. (2022) ‘Black and Minority Ethnic Student Teachers stories as empirical documents of hidden oppressions: using the personal to turn towards the structural’ in British Educational Research Journal https://doi.org/10.1002/berj.3819


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Teacher Educators as Facilitators of or Force Against Ignorance About Indigenous Peoples? Contributions from Finland.

Ella Mattila, Jyri Lindén, Johanna Annala

Tampere University, Finland

Presenting Author: Mattila, Ella

Motivated by the increasing recognition of the anti-colonial potential of teacher education (TE), this study examines how Finnish teacher educators engage with and understand knowledge about and from the Indigenous Sámi people (‘Sámi knowledge’). The research delves into the discourses, meanings, practices, and challenges the interviewed teacher educators express regarding the inclusion of Sámi knowledge to TE programmes. Thus, the paper aims to contribute to ongoing Nordic and international discussions about the wicked problem of ignorance about Indigenous peoples and colonial realities ('settler ignorance'), which is documented perpetuating oppressive structures and hindering Indigenous rights (Cook, 2018).

While the phenomenon of settler ignorance and its presence in education has been globally discussed (e.g., Godlewska et al., 2020; Taylor & Habibis, 2020), the issue remains under-researched in the contexts of the Sámi, the only Indigenous people in the European Union. The Sámi inhabit Northern European regions currently spread across Finland, Sweden, Norway, and Russia. National truth and reconciliation processes in Finland, Sweden and Norway all emphasise the goal of better public knowledge about Sámi matters, underlining its significance in overturning the historical and ongoing mistreatment (e.g., Prime Minister’s Office, 2021). Furthermore, the European Commission Against Racism and Intolerance has repeatedly highlighted the need for education to address the profound lack of knowledge about Sámi people, recognizing mainstream ignorance as a source of hate speech and Sámi discrimination (ECRI, 2019). Acknowledgment of the problematic nature of transnational ignorance has prompted initiatives at both national and EU levels to raise awareness of Indigenous issues (see Saami Council, 2022).

In the Finnish context, the incorporation of Sámi knowledge into education depends largely on teachers, given the minimal support and accountability the curricula and teaching materials assign for Sámi inclusion (e.g., Miettunen, 2020). Sámi scholars Keskitalo and Olsen (2021) reinforce the interconnectedness of stronger Sámi education and Sámi inclusion in mainstream teacher education. Recognizing settler ignorance not as a mere absence of knowledge but as a cognitive, affective and social force (Cook, 2018), it has been highlighted that dismantling such ignorance necessitates proactive and systematic incentives and support at different educational levels, thus deeply affecting TE institutions (e.g., Somby & Olsen, 2022). Together with these conceptualisations, we apply Susan Dion’s (2007) theory of educators’ common ‘perfect stranger’ position toward Indigenous matters as we examine whether future teachers receive both Sámi-related teaching and opportunities for critical reflection, both of which they need to truly access the 'difficult knowledge' related to Indigenous/colonial realities.

In a preceding sub-study linked to this paper, we discovered that Finnish TE programmes' written curricula often privilege liberal/nationalistic narratives over openings for Sámi knowledge or critical reflections on colonial responsibilities (Mattila et al., 2023). Given the influential role educators play in curriculum interpretation and development, as well as in institution-wide anti-colonial efforts (e.g., Parkinson & Jones, 2019), the perceptions of educators become a highly relevant focus of research. The work of teacher educators is complex and influential considering their multiple intertwining roles and the dripple-down effect of being the teachers of teachers (see Boyd & White, 2017). Through interviews with teacher educators from Finnish TE universities, this study seeks to deepen our understanding of the current state of teaching/learning Indigenous and colonial matters and provide insights for future TE development.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
Finnish teacher educators’ perceptions of Sámi knowledge and TE’s role in overcoming settler ignorance are approached through thematic interviews. Thematic interviews are a compatible methodological choice for such a research problem where the subject of study is relatively little known. As the focus is on a structural issue such as settler ignorance, thematic interviews create valuable opportunities to explore not only the questions of whether/how Sámi knowledge is negotiated by Finnish teacher educators, but also go deeper into the why.

The data will consist of 15-20 interviews of teacher educators working in different Finnish TE universities. We practice purposeful sampling, i.e., the potential interviewees are approached depending on their positions and teaching areas, weighting how relevantly their courses can be connected to discussions about the Sámi and/or colonial legacies. The interview data is analysed thematically (Braun & Clarke, 2006), which allows for addressing both implicit and explicit answers as well as keeping interpretations data-driven. Thematic analysis is complemented by a critical discursive reading (applied from Critical Discourse Analysis by Fairclough, e.g., 2001), which helps to delve deeper into the cultural implications, meanings and powers that may underlie the interviewees' responses. We anticipate that combining thematic and discursive analysis will facilitate access to a deeper explanatory level, identifying the effects of national and international discourses and prevailing power relations. This analytical choice can also help avoid drawing individual-level conclusions; it is important to avoid ascribing elements of the widespread structures of colonial ignorance to the values, motivation, or expertise of individual interviewed educators.

As non-Indigenous researchers working to examine questions and contexts relating to Indigenous peoples, we are committed to conducting research ethically, with methods and data that allow us to make our enquiries sustainably. We have sought the informed consent of the Finnish Sámi Parliament to the design and relevance of this research. Considering the collection and preservation of personal interview data, we are set to carefully construe and follow data management plans, in line with EU data protection guidelines and ethical scientific practice.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
The interview data for this study is collected during 2024. Based on the current research phase, the data collection is still ongoing by the time of the ECER 2024 conference, but the research process, design, and 'key questions' for the expected findings will be discussed in the presentation.

While we look forward to encountering 'unexpected' perspectives from the interviewees’ responses, international ignorance research and our preceding sub-studies allow us to outline interesting 'key questions' for the data and, thus, suggest some expected pointers. Interesting questions that guide our analysis and our emerging understandings of the role of teacher educators include; Do teacher educators' responses reflect resistance and/or agency towards Sámi knowledge? Do the answers reflect a saturation with social or (trans)national narratives, such as the 'exceptionality' of Finnish societal and educational equality or colonial 'innocence'? And do teacher educators perceive TE's role in increasing Sámi knowledge important in general?

References
Boyd, P., & White, E. (2017). Teacher educator professional inquiry in an age of accountability. In Boyd, P. & Szplit, A. (eds.) Teacher and Teacher Educator Inquiry: International Perspectives. Kraków: Attyka.

Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77-101.

Cook, A. (2018). Recognizing settler ignorance in the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. Feminist Philosophy Quarterly, 4(4), 1–21.

Dion, S. (2007). Disrupting Molded Images: Identities, responsibilities and relationships – teachers and indigenous subject material. Teaching Education, 18(4), 329–342.

European Council against Racism and Intolerance ECRI (2019). ECRI Report on Finland (fifth monitoring cycle).

Fairclough, N. (2001). Language and power (2nd ed.). London: Longman.

Godlewska, A. M. C., Schaefli, L. M., Forcione, M., Lamb, C., Nelson, E., & Talan, B. (2020). Canadian colonialism, ignorance and education. A study of graduating students at Queen’s University. Journal of Pedagogy, 11(1), 147–176.

Kasa, T., Rautiainen, M., Malama, M., & Kallioniemi, A. (2021). ‘Human rights and democracy are not self-evident’ – Finnish student teachers’ perceptions on democracy and human rights education. Human Rights Education Review, 4(2), 69–84.

Keskitalo, P., & Olsen, T. (2021). Indigenizing Education: Historical Perspectives and Present Challenges in Sámi Education. Arctic Yearbook 2021, 452–478.

Mattila, E., Linden, J., & Annala, J. (2023). On the Shoulders of a Perfect Stranger: Knowledge Gap About the Indigenous Sámi in the Finnish Teacher Education Curriculum. Race Ethnicity and Education [Ahead of Print].

Miettunen, T. (2020). Saamelaistietoa vai puuttuvaa tietoa saamelaisista? Selvitys saamelaistiedosta peruskoulun suomen- ja ruotsinkielisissä oppimateriaaleissa. [Sámi knowledge or missing knowledge about the Sámi? Report on Sámi knowledge in Finnish and Swedish learning materials for primary education]. Ministry of Education and Culture.

Parkinson, C., & Jones, T. (2019). Aboriginal people’s aspirations and the Australian Curriculum: a critical analysis. Educational Research for Policy and Practice, 18(1), 75–97.

Prime Minister’s Office (2021). Decision on establishing a truth and reconciliation commission concerning the Sámi people.

Saami Council (2022). Sápmi-EU Strategy. Production by project Filling the EU-Sápmi Knowledge Gaps.

Somby, H. M., & Olsen, T. A. (2022). Inclusion as indigenisation? Sámi perspectives in teacher education. International Journal of Inclusive Education.

Taylor, P. S., & Habibis, D. (2020). Widening the gap: White ignorance, race relations and the consequences for Aboriginal people in Australia. The Australian Journal of Social Issues, 55(3), 354–371.
 
Date: Wednesday, 28/Aug/2024
9:30 - 11:0007 SES 04 B: Teacher Education Studies in Social Justice and Intercultural Education II
Location: Room 117 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [Floor 1]
Session Chair: Carola Mantel
Paper Session
 
07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

“It’s a Form of Psychological Warfare Against Educators”: Protective Factors for Sustaining Social Justice Education

Elyse Hambacher1, Jalea Turner1, Denise Desrosiers2

1University of Florida, United States of America; 2University of New Hampshire, United States of America

Presenting Author: Hambacher, Elyse

Public schools should be places where students from diverse backgrounds come together to strengthen their knowledge and skills to maximize their human potential and become active citizens in a vibrant democracy. However, U.S. educators are living in increasingly polarizing times where, as of January 2023, 18 states have passed legislation that bans or restricts how concepts, such as race and equity, are taught in schools, prohibiting complex discussions of systemic injustice (Schwartz, 2023). Book banning and rejecting courses that educate students about African American history (Kim, 2023; Limbong, 2022) reflect the pugnacious state of the current American public classroom. While restrictive legislation of this nature and to this degree may not be prominent across the globe, discussions of “woke education” are occurring in parts of Europe (Cammaerts, 2022). When laws prohibit important social, historical, and political discussions in classrooms in any country, democracy is threatened.

In the context of a heightened politically polarizing time in the US, it is imperative to understand how teachers committed to social justice education (SJE) navigate the complexity of their work. The purpose of our study is to examine the experiences of 17 justice-oriented educators within one school district in the state of New Hampshire, where a law banning the teaching of “divisive concepts” was passed in 2021, as they teach and lead in contentious times. The following research questions guide the study: 1) What supports teachers' commitment to socially just teaching when they encounter opposition to their work? 2) In what ways do these supports operate as protective factors for the teachers' personal and professional wellbeing? We deliberately use the term protective factors because there are forces (e.g., the law, hostility from the community) that threaten the integrity of their practice, and their students’ learning and wellbeing. This study addresses ECER’s conference theme in that it helps us to understand how educators enact SJE in a time of uncertainty, igniting hope and empowering other educators to take part in educating for greater justice.

We draw on the literature related to social justice education and social justice leadership (SJL) to inform the study. Chubbock and Zembylas (2008) define SJE as, “a teacher’s effort to transform policies and enact pedagogies that improve the learning and life opportunities of typically underserved students while equipping and empowering them to work for a more socially just society themselves” (p. 284). As Chubbock and Zembylas (2008) note the focus of SJE is to “improve the learning... of underserved students.” However, often overlooked is another vital part of SJE—the significance and necessity of SJE for privileged students to engender change (Swalwell, 2013). Challenging inequality in these communities must also be part of the larger SJE project (Author, 2021; Swalwell 2013). This is especially important to consider in the current study which takes place in a predominantly white and wealthy district. 

An extension of SJE is SJL, which is carried out by leaders who “make issues of race, class, gender, disability, sexual orientation, and other historically and currently marginalizing conditions in the United States central to their advocacy, leadership, practice, and vision” (Theoharis, 2007, p. 223). SJL is a pivotal piece in the educational equity project and goes beyond simply recognizing injustice to interrogating conditions that perpetuate marginalization and supporting justice-oriented change efforts in schools through policy and practice (Flores & Bagwell, 2021; Theoharis & Haddix, 2011).

The findings from this study indicate the kinds of support that bolstered educators’ determination and ability to persist in justice-oriented teaching. The findings offer guidance for educational leaders and educators who face similar challenges to their social justice commitments in communities across the globe.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
South Adams School District (SASD) is located in a progressive leaning town in New Hampshire, a small, politically divided state in the U.S. Two thousand students attend its four schools—two elementary, one middle, and one high school. The district serves mostly white students and a small percentage of students of color. Only 5% of students come from low-income households. We selected this district because Author had been working with them to facilitate professional learning opportunities as one part of their larger anti-racist and justice-oriented goals. 

Critical ethnographic principles informed the methodological decisions of this study. In this tradition, emancipation and transformation of inequality is a core goal (Carspecken, 1996; Grbich, 2012). An underlying assumption in our research is the current political and cultural state of the U.S. silences the voices and practices of educators, especially those with goals to expose privilege and unequal power relations.

Fourteen teachers and three administrators with various years of teaching experience agreed to participate. Of the 17 participants, two were educators of color and the other 15 identified as white. We wanted to gain a broad understanding of the organization and therefore, deliberately selected participants from various backgrounds to gain an emic perspective, exploring this district culture from the inside (Carspecken, 1996; Spradley, 1980; Wolcott, 1990).  

Interviews, field notes, and documents were data collected over a 10-month period. All participants were interviewed twice with semi-structured protocols that asked open-ended questions focused on understanding a birds-eye view of justice-oriented and anti-racist work in the SASD and larger community, as well as their own commitments related to practice and leadership. We observed over 15 justice-oriented events (e.g., school-based professional learning communities).

Three researchers engaged in a thematic analysis using a block and file approach (Grbich, 2012) initially to keep large excerpts intact. First, we read the 34 total interviews, highlighting instances where participants talked about feeling supported in the district. Second, we met as a research team to group and discuss similar kinds of support and wrote descriptive comments about our initial groupings. Analyzing field notes and documents helped us to gain a holistic view of the setting and corroborate our interview data. We refined our themes in an iterative manner until we reached consensus on key findings. Throughout the analysis process, we kept a research log to record ideas, wonderings, and possible themes. 

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
Despite the teachers’ personal lives feeling threatened and experiencing fear of professional repercussions (Authors, under review), they spoke at length about the means and opportunities that support them through justice-oriented teaching in contentious times. We report on five interconnected kinds of support:

Community-oriented supports are efforts to protect educators’ social justice work by engaging community members in learning and solidarity-building events. Connecting with the local community helps educators feel that they are not alone or unsupported in their efforts and strengthens their ability to persist.

Declarative supports are bold, outward-facing statements and actions that assert the significance of SJE. These declarations may place the individual or institution at risk, yet they continue to persist bravely despite being criticized. While our data points to mostly the superintendent engaging in declarative support for the SASD, school board members and teachers outwardly reaffirmed their efforts to work toward greater justice. 

Structural support refers to school or district-wide policies and procedures put in place to provide the organization with a framework for decision-making related to teaching and interactions with families. Educators explained that they use their district’s anti-racism, transgender, and controversial topics policies as they teach and lead in contentious times. 

Legal support refers to counsel provided by an attorney that gives insight into the possibilities and limitations of teachers' instructional practice within the new constraints of divisive concepts legislation (DCL). This legal counsel aims to empower and protect teachers by providing a level of clarity surrounding the law and how it directly impacts their practice.

Instructional support includes professional learning opportunities and experiences within the district and individual schools that strengthens teachers' development and enactment of SJE. These continual opportunities to learn allowed educators to deepen their knowledge and their instructional strategies to sustain their justice-oriented commitments. 

References
Author (2021).

Authors, under review.

Carspecken, P. F. (1996). Critical ethnography in educational research: A theoretical and practical guide. Psychology Press.

Cammaerts, B. (2022). The abnormalisation of social justice: The ‘anti-woke culture war’ discourse in the UK. Discourse & Society, 33(6), 730-743.

Chubbuck, S., & Zembylas, M. (2008). The emotional ambivalence of socially just teaching: A case study of a novice urban schoolteacher. American Educational Research Journal, 45(2), pp. 274-318. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831207311586

Flores, C., & Bagwell, J. (2021). Social justice leadership as inclusion: Promoting inclusive practices to ensure equity for all. Educational Leadership and Administration: Teaching and Program Development, p. 31-43. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1318516.pdf. Accessed September 29, 2023

Grbich, C. (2012). Qualitative data analysis: An introduction. Sage.

Kim, J. (2023, January 22). Florida says AP class teaches critical race theory. Here’s what’s really in the course. NPR. https://www.npr.org/2023/01/22/1150259944/florida-rejects-ap-class-african-american-studies. Accessed September 26, 2023

Limbong, A. (2022, September 19). New report finds a coordinated rise in attempted book bans. MPR News. https://www.mprnews.org/story/2022/09/19/npr-new-report-finds-a-coordinated-rise-in-attempted-book-bans?gclid=CjwKCAjw5MOlBhBTEiwAAJ8e1sdSXuZOnGm-I4oScfWVpkc9xLd1B7Ph0LFA35F5qUbX0rznyx8jqhoCajkQAvD_BwE. Accessed September 26, 2023

Schwartz, S. (2023, June 13). Map: Where critical race theory is under attack. Education Week. https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/map-where-critical-race-theory-is-under-attack/2021/06. Accessed September 26, 2023

Spradley, J. (1980). Participant observation. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.

Swalwell, K. (2013). Educating activist allies: Social justice pedagogy with the suburban and urban elite. Routledge.

Theoharis, G. (2007). Social justice educational leaders and resistance: Toward a theory of social justice leadership. Educational Administration Quarterly, 43(2), 221-258.

Theoharis, G., & Haddix, M. (2011). Undermining racism and a whiteness ideology: White principals living a commitment to equitable and excellent schools. Urban Education, 46(6), 1332-1351.

Wolcott, H. F. (1990). Making a study “more ethnographic.” Journal of Contemporary  
Ethnography, 19(1), 44-72.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

The Role Of Conflict As A Catalyst In The Formation Of Pre-Service Teachers’ Identity

Rakefet Erlich Ron, Shahar Gindi

Beit Berl College, Israel

Presenting Author: Erlich Ron, Rakefet; Gindi, Shahar

In theories of group behavior, the concept of social identity is extremely useful because it describes individuals in terms of multiple hierarchical affiliations. Thanks to an almost unlimited capacity for rationalization, most humans cope well with multiple identities and loyalties in conflict situations. Alongside this, there are often situations in which the conflict is present and requires the person to bridge it and find a balance (Magen-Nagar & Steinberger, 2016).

Developmental psychologist Erik Erikson (1968) conceptualized an individual's identity as a multifaceted structure dynamically evolving and undergoing gradual changes over time. A crucial element within the components of one's identity is one’s professional identity (Popper-Giveon & Shayshon, 2017. Rodgers and Scott (2008) referred to the negotiation processes that take place in relation to professional identity. They posit that the identity structure is in a constant process of construction, development and changes while at the same time having a tendency to show coherence. They referred to identity as contextual, developing in relation to social, cultural, political and historical aspects, and during negotiations with the ‘other’.

Aligned with the process approach, these assumptions correspond to the perspective that characterizes individuals’ current identity state and delineates the state of their identity at a specific moment (Kroger & Marcia, 2011). The process approach posits that individuals actively seek information about themselves and their surroundings to inform decision-making and meaningful choices in life. These simultaneous processes entail a commitment to a sequence of choices and decisions among identity alternatives, all the while acquiring the necessary knowledge to evaluate these alternatives (Alsanafi & Noor, 2019; Steinberger, 2022).

Identity processes are accelerated in times of conflict. Thus, in a state of incompatibility, when individuals are exposed to central identity conflicts (Van der Gaag et al., 2020) they may feel their basic needs and values threatened. As a result, they may be prevented from considering identity alternatives. Frequent and significant conflict serves as a catalyst for change and action. Reinforcement for this exists in the theory of cognitive dissonance (Festinger, 1962; Harmon-Jones & Mills, 2019), according to which individuals naturally strive for balance. When a conflict disturbs the balance, individuals will be motivated to resolve it in order to reduce the discrepancy.

In this research we approach identity formation both from a process approach and a socio-cultural perspective that takes into account the contextual factors influencing identity formation. For example, Côté (2006) highlighted the development of a contextual approach as a central challenge in identity research. Theoretical models addressing identity development grapple with this challenge by acknowledging the psychosocial context in the formation of identity (Côté & Levine, 2014).

This study aimed to explore the process of identity formation among Arab Pre-Service Teachers (PSTs) who aspired to teach in Jewish schools. The sample comprised 14 Arab PSTs undergoing training, engaged in a unique program called “Cross-Teach” that involved the retraining of Jewish academics to teach in Arab schools and vice versa. As part of the program, the PSTs participated in a one-day-a-week practicum in schools from the ‘other’ stream, presenting various identity conflict situations. The primary research questions focused on understanding the identity processes experienced by Arab PSTs during their training. This included examining the encountered identity conflicts, assessing whether these conflicts acted as catalysts for regrouping, and exploring the ways in which the PSTs navigated and integrated this complexity into their identity.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
This study is based on data collected throughout the 2022-2023 school year. The information collected included 10 interviews with PSTs in the Cross-Teach program and three focus groups with between 5-6 PSTs each. The interviews lasted between an hour and an hour and a half and focus groups lasted between an hour and a half to two hours. All the information was transcribed and uploaded to a qualitative analysis software. The qualitative data analysis used NVIVO software (Bazeley, 2022). This method supports the researcher in storing, coding and systematically retrieving qualitative data (Wood & Bloor, 2006), thereby increasing the accuracy, reliability and transparency of qualitative investigations (Liamputtong, 2020). The coders used a qualitative content analysis method to identify the recurrence of themes and patterns through data reduction efforts, the interpretation of the text and the attempt to identify consistency and core meanings within it (Patton, 2014). As part of the classification process, data are extracted into segments, inductively coded into categories, and grouped and compared with similar segments from other observations. Thus, this flexible method typically combines concept-driven and data-driven categories so that the overall coding framework is consistent with the data (Schreier, 2014).
The interviews and focus groups utilized a semi-structured guide constructed in alignment with the research questions. Four Ph.D. holders, each specializing in distinct fields (psychology, sociology, education, and philosophy), served as interviewers. For the focus groups, two of the Ph.D. interviewers led one group, while research assistants supported the other two researchers in conducting the remaining focus groups. Two of the interviewers were native Arabic speakers, and the other two were native Hebrew speakers. Consequently, some interviews and one focus group were conducted in Arabic, with subsequent translation into Hebrew following transcription.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
The study on the role of conflict as a catalyst in identity formation among Arab PSTs aspiring to teach in Jewish schools may provide valuable insights into the complex nature of identity processes in the context of intercultural education. Initial findings support the notion that identity processes are accelerated in times of conflict and underscore the dynamic nature of identity formation. It seems that the participants experienced conflict as a driving force for reevaluation, regrouping, and decision-making in their identity development. The study aligns with the call for a contextual approach in identity research, acknowledging the influence of social, cultural, political, and historical factors on identity formation.
The study's unique context, with Arab and Jewish PSTs studying together, adds a layer of complexity to the examination of identity processes. Coexisting in the same teacher training program, these groups explore how intercultural dynamics and shared educational goals shape identity. Including Arab and Jewish lecturers enriches the study. Diverse lecturer backgrounds, with some having minority backgrounds, provide added dimensions. Dynamics between staff and PSTs may serve as a model, offering nuanced understanding of identity negotiation in diverse environments.
The findings have implications for teacher training programs that involve intercultural experiences. Understanding the role of conflict as a catalyst for identity development among PSTs is crucial for designing effective training programs. Teacher educators and program developers should consider integrating strategies that recognize and address identity conflicts, fostering a supportive environment for PSTs navigating the complexities of identity formation.
In conclusion, this study advances our understanding of the interplay between conflict and identity formation in intercultural teacher training programs. The insights gained have implications for educational practices and underscore the need for improved approaches to identity development in contexts characterized by cultural diversity and conflict.

References
Alsanafi, I. H., & Noor, S. N. F. B. M. (2019). Development of black feminine identity in two Postmodern American plays through appraisal framework: Comparative study. Amazonia Investiga, 8(21), 104-116.‏
Bazeley, P. (2022). Designing for Multimodal Data and Mixed Methods within a Qualitative Framework. The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research Design (pp.604-617). Sage.
Côté, J. (2006). Identity studies: How close are we to developing a social science of identity? - An appraisal of the field. Identity, 6(1), 3-25.‏
Côté, J. E., & Levine, C. G. (2014). Identity, formation, agency, and culture: A social psychological synthesis. Psychology Press.‏
Erikson, E. H. (1968). Identity youth and crisis (No. 7). WW Norton & company.
Festinger, L. (1962). A theory of cognitive dissonance (Vol. 2). Stanford university press.‏
Harmon-Jones, E., & Mills, J. (2019). An introduction to cognitive dissonance theory and an overview of current perspectives on the theory.‏
Kroger, J., & Marcia, J. E. (2011). The identity statuses: Origins, meanings, and interpretations. In Handbook of identity theory and research (pp. 31-53). New York, NY: Springer New York.‏
Magen-Nagar, N. and Steinberger, P. (2016). The essence of the conflicts in the process of forming the professional identity of teachers in a changing reality. Multifaceted: Research and Discourse 2(15), 17-48. (Hebrew)
Patton, M. Q. (2014). Qualitative research & evaluation methods: Integrating theory and practice. Sage publications.
Popper-Giveon, A., & Shayshon, B. (2017). Educator versus subject matter teacher: The conflict between two sub-identities in becoming a teacher. Teachers and Teaching, 23(5), 532-548.‏
Rodgers, C. R., & Scott, K. H. (2008). The development of the personal self and professional identity in learning to teach. In Handbook of research on teacher education (pp. 732-755). Routledge.‏
Schreier, M. (2012). Qualitative content analysis in practice. Sage.
Steinberger, P. (2022). The relationship between experience in conflict management simulation and formation of professional identity of education students. Multifaceted: Research and Discourse, 22, 181-206. (Hebrew)
Van der Gaag, M. A., De Ruiter, N. M., Kunnen, S. E., & Bosma, H. (2020). The landscape of identity model: An integration of qualitative and quantitative aspects of identity development. Identity, 20(4), 272-289.‏
Wood, F., & Bloor, M. (2006). Keywords in qualitative methods: A vocabulary of research concepts. Keywords in Qualitative Methods, 1-208.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Being a Teacher in a Raciolinguistic World: Internalised Language-based Racism as a Subject of Teacher Education and Professionalisation Research

Gizem Evin Dağ, M Knappik

University of Wuppertal, Germany

Presenting Author: Dağ, Gizem Evin; Knappik, M

Linguicism is language-based racism (Dirim 2010). In its direct form, linguicism includes institutional and individual language bans, and in its more subtle forms, it extends to explicit or unspoken expectations on desired language use. Structurally, linguicism is closely interwoven with racial ideologies and often refers to racism-related marginalisation (Rosa 2019). This raciolinguistic connection is particularly evident in the devaluation of the languages of migrant multilingual persons. This is also expressed in the hierarchisation of languages and their speakers in schools (Knappik/Ayten 2020), which is reflected, among other things, in the different prestige of languages and in the contrasting treatment of foreign languages such as English and French in schools compared to so-called heritage languages such as Turkish or Polish. This hierarchy of languages is of great importance in schools, as it habitually frames the linguistic behaviour of all actors (Doğmuş 2022), which is particularly salient as schools are, at all times, linguistic spaces of teaching and learning. Teacher training itself also contributes to the reproduction of linguicism through the language-related "de_thematisation of migration society orders" (Shure 2021), the unequal assessment of linguistic competences and the creation of exclusions along the category of language (Knappik/Dirim/Döll 2013).

While experiences of racism by pupils, university students and teachers have been investigated more in recent years (Akbaba/Bello/Fereidooni 2022), experiences of linguicism of teachers have barely been explored yet. However, this topic is particularly urgent for teacher education:

  • Experiences of racism in the professional environment have a severe impact on health (Madubuko 2020). Initial studies show that experiences of linguicism are particularly powerful in this context due to the importance of language for learning and teaching in schools (Ayten/Hägi-Mead 2023).
  • Migrant multilingual teachers often experience a complex confrontation with expectations of loyalty directed at them, which are seen as achievable through the exclusive use of one national language only (Fereidooni 2016). They also experience “control attempts" (Mai 2020) related to the languages they use, and the often very painful devaluation of their other languages (Ayten/Hägi-Mead 2023).
  • The forms in which internalised linguicism (based on the term "internalised racism", Bivens 2005) affects the professional self-image and professional actions of affected teachers have not yet been investigated. Initial insights into our data show a highly complex network of cross-referencing effects between professionalisation efforts and the risk of deprofessionalisation, which appears to manifest itself in reproductions of linguistic structures that are ultimately directed against the individual teachers themselves. This complex has not yet been investigated, nor are there any corresponding programmes for teacher training.

Our data indicate that pre-service teacher training in particular is an institution in which linguicism plays a decisive role in the development of the linguistic professional self-image.

Our data also show that experiences of linguicism play a major role in teachers' decisions to leave the profession. In view of the shortage of teachers and the educational policy hopes regarding teachers with a so-called migration background (Akbaba/Bräu/Zimmer 2013), this is a particularly great loss.

In order to better understand how teachers experience and internalise linguicism in schools, our guiding research question is:

How do teachers experience linguicism in schools and how do they interpret their experiences? A particular focus will be on exploring the phenomenon of internalised linguicism and its significance for the professionalisation of teachers.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
14 semi-standardised interviews with multilingual migrant teachers were conducted and transcribed. The interviews were conducted by a multilingual migrant researcher in order to create a space of potentially shared experience and understanding during the interviews. Translanguaging practices were used freely during the interview by the interviewer to ensure free language choice during the interviews. The interviewees used translanguaging practices correspondingly. The interviews are analysed using line-by-line sequential analysis (Reichertz 2016) in order to create detailed understandings of the phenomenon of (internalised) linguicism as experienced by teachers. The use of translanguaging by the interviewees is part of the analysis, as it seems that language choices corresponded to the vulnerable nature of the experiences shared.
For selected sections, collaborative interpretation sessions with a team of researchers will be held. These researchers share theoretical expertise in racism and linguicism studies, and for the most part also share biographical experiences with racism and linguicism. Special attention is being paid to reflect the power dynamics within the research team and during the interpretation processes. This will be done by discussing questions of power dynamics and by creating audio recordings of interpretation sessions, analysing the recordings und subsequently reflecting on the insights.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
Teachers' experiences of linguicism are an urgent subject of investigation in order to develop programmes for teacher training, improve the health and well-being of teachers affected by linguicism and prevent them from leaving the profession due to their experiences of linguicism. To do this, however, it is necessary to understand the phenomenon of experiences of linguicism in the institution of school in more detail, which is the goal of our study.
We expect to gain a deeper understanding of the phenomenon, in particularly of the internalisation of linguicism, of its contributing factors, its effects on teachers and their professional self-image, and on their strategies of resilience.

References
Akbaba, Yalız/Bello, Bettina/Fereidooni, Karim (Hrsg.) (2022): Pädagogische Professionalität und Migrationsdiskurse. Pädagogische Professionalität und Migrationsdiskurse. Wiesbaden, Heidelberg: Springer VS.
Akbaba, Yalız/Bräu, Karin/ Zimmer, Meike (2013): Erwartungen und Zuschreibungen. Eine Analyse und kritische Reflexion der bildungspolitischen Debatte zu Lehrer/innen mit Migrationshintergrund. In K. Bräu, V. B. Georgi, Y. Karakaşoğlu, & C. Rotter (Hrsg.): Lehrerinnen und Lehrer mit Migrationshintergrund. Zur Relevanz eines Merkmals in Theorie, Empirie und Praxis. Münster, New York, München, Berlin: Waxmann, S. 37–57.
Ayten, Aslı Can/Hägi-Mead, Sara (2023): „Lass, mach es nicht, denk an deine eigene Gesundheit“. SchulVerwaltung aktuell 11, 3, S. 82-85.
Bivens, Donna K. (2005): What is internalized racism? In: M. Potapchuk, S. Leiderman, D. K. Bivens & B. Major (Hrsg.):  Flipping the Script: White Privilege and Community Building. Silver Spring: MP Associates, S. 43–51.
Dirim, İnci (2010): "Wenn man mit Akzent spricht, denken die Leute, dass man auch mit Akzent denkt oder so.". Zur Frage des (Neo-)Linguizismus in den Diskursen über die Sprache(n) der Migrationsgesellschaft. In P.  Mecheril, i. Dirim, M. Gomolla, S. Hornberg & K. Stojanov (Hrsg.): Spannungsverhältnisse. Assimilationsdiskurse und interkulturell-pädagogische Forschung. Münster, New York, München, Berlin: Waxmann, S. 91–112.
Doğmuş, Aysun (2022): Professionalisierung in Migrationsverhältnissen. Eine rassismuskritische Perspektive auf das Referendariat angehender Lehrer*innen. Pädagogische Professionalität und Migrationsdiskurse. Wiesbaden: Springer VS.
Fereidooni,Karim (2016): Diskriminierungs- und Rassismuserfahrungen im Schulwesen: Eine Studie zu Ungleichheitspraktiken im Berufskontext. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Knappik, M/Ayten, Aslı Can (2020): Was ist die beste Sprache? Zur Rassismusrelevanz der Ungleichmachung von Sprachen. In: K. Fereidooni & N. Simon (Hrsg.): Rassismuskritische Fachdidaktiken. Theoretische Reflexionen und fachdidaktische Entwürfe rassismusskritischer Unterrichtsplanung. Pädagogische Professionalität und Migrationsdiskurse. Wiesbaden: Springer VS, S. 233–265.
Knappik, M/Dirim, İnci/Döll, Marion (2013): Migrationsspezifisches Deutsch und die Wissenschaftssprache Deutsch. Aspekte eines Spannungsverhältnisses in der Lehrerausbildung. In: Eva Vetter (Hg.): Professionalisierung für Vielfalt. Die Ausbildung von Sprachenlehrer/innen. Baltmannsweiler: Schneider Verlag Hohengehren, S. 42–61.
Madubuko, Nkechi (2020): Berufsbiographische Akzeptanzerfahrungen und Stressempfinden. In: P. Genkova & A. Riecken (Hrsg.): Handbuch Migration und Erfolg. Psychologische und sozialwissenschaftliche Aspekte. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden: Wiesbaden, S. 425–444.
Mai, Hanna Hoa Anh (2020): Pädagog*innen of Color. Professionalität im Kontext rassistischer
Normalität. Wiesbaden: Beltz-Juventa.
Reichertz, Jo (2016): Qualitative und interpretative Sozialforschung. Eine Einladung. Lehrbuch. Wiesbaden: Springer VS.
Rosa, Jonathan (2019): Looking like a language, sounding like a race. Raciolinguistic ideologies and the learning of Latinidad. Oxford studies in the anthropology of language. New York, NY, United States of America: Oxford University Press.
Shure, Saphira (2021): De_Thematisierung migrationsgesellschaftlicher Ordnungen. Lehramtsstudium als Ort der Bedeutungsproduktion. Weinheim: Beltz.
 
13:45 - 15:1507 SES 06 B: Teacher Education Studies in Social Justice and Intercultural Education III
Location: Room 117 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [Floor 1]
Session Chair: Barbara Gross
Paper Session
 
07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Teachers’ Perceptions and Experiences with Immigrant and Refugee Students: A National Survey in Portugal

Joana Manarte, Sara Faria, Pedro Ferreira

CIIE/ FPCEUP, Portugal

Presenting Author: Manarte, Joana

The intensification of migratory flows around the world, largely associated with the humanitarian crisis that has been victimizing migrants and refugees more visibly since 2015, has motivated fracturing positions in civil society and in the political sphere, expressed in welcoming movements, on the one hand, and in xenophobic and segregationist movements, on the other hand, a stance that has been conquering territory in contemporary societies (Huber & Reynolds, 2014; Silva et al., 2018).

The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, guided by the commitment to “leave no one behind”, has had the migratory phenomenon as one of the major challenges to be considered, namely regarding SDG 4, devoted to Education. UNESCO underlines the need to protect the right to education of displaced persons, considering the principle of non-discrimination, which comprises the inclusion of migrants and refugees in national education systems. The increase in the migratory flow to Europe leaves many migrant and refugee students helpless in the education systems, and European countries are faced with the growing need to adapt the institutional, social, and educational response to the reception of a considerable number of children and young people with diverse cultural and linguistic backgrounds (de Wal Pastoor, 2016).

The migration crisis added urgency to the demand of an inclusive school (de Wal Pastoor, 2016). Despite the efforts to ensure access to education for all, there are shortcomings in the quality of educational integration that compromise the academic, emotional, and social well-being of young migrants, intensifying the marginalization and stigmatization of these groups in society (Cerna, 2019; de Wal Pastoor, 2016; European Commission/EACEA/Eurydice, 2019; PPMI, 2017; Silva et al., 2018).

According to the holistic model for the educational integration of refugees (Cerna, 2019), teachers’ training to deal with diversity is one of the main factors to improve the response of education systems to meet the learning, social and emotional needs of this population (de Wal Pastoor, 2016; Szelei et al., 2020; European Commission/EACEA/Eurydice, 2019; PPMI, 2017).

From this panorama, the following research questions emerged: What are the teachers' perceptions and beliefs about migrants and refugees, about welcoming other cultures and about cultural diversity in schools? What training needs, opportunities, challenges, and good experiences can be identified in this area?

Professional development of teachers in interculturality is also an insufficiently studied field (Szelei et al., 2020). Research shows that teachers feel unprepared to work with students from different cultural backgrounds (de Wal Pastoor, 2016; PPMI, 2017; Szelei et al., 2020). Indeed, the increase in cultural and social diversity raises challenges and opportunities for education. For teachers to be(come) agents of positive change in this process, it is essential to promote a culture of support for teachers.

Ecologically informed research on education of migrants and refugees, that considers the educational and historical realities of specific countries (in terms of receiving and integrating migrant populations and national cultural minorities) is still scarce and this is especially true for Portugal (de Wal Pastoor, 2016). Professional development of teachers in interculturality is also an insufficiently studied field (Szelei et al, 2020).

This study intends to contribute to improve the quality of the educational integration of migrant, refugee and ethnic minority children and young people, as well as the professional development and well-being of teachers when working with a multicultural public. For this purpose, the research aims to study the perceptions of primary, secondary and vocational school teachers about the welcoming of other cultures in Portugal and in the Portuguese education system, particularly migrants, refugees and ethnic minorities. Furthermore, it also proposes to know teachers’ preparation and training to deal with cultural diversity.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
The sample is composed of teachers from schools throughout the national territory. An online questionnaire was developed and administered to teachers in Portuguese primary, secondary and vocational schools. Considering the approximate number of 150,000 teachers in Portugal (INE, 2024), and to ensure that the sample was representative, it was expected to inquiry approximately 400 teachers. The survey was disseminated nationwide and open for participation from February to May 2023. The number of valid responses was higher than expected, resulting in a total of 643 participants. The questionnaire is divided into four groups, most of which are closed questions, with only two open and optional questions. Group I involves sociodemographic questions and characterizes the professional profile, consisting of a total of 13 items. Group II contains 6 items related to the work context. Group III addresses questions specifically related to the experience of working with immigrants and refugees, totalling 11 items. Group IV consists of 10 questions about perceptions of hosting other cultures in Portugal.
The data collected is subject to statistical analysis (closed questions) and content analysis (open questions). Exploratory, descriptive, and inferential statistical procedures are being undertaken, using IBM SPSS (version 29) software.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
The main aim of the online survey was to gather information about teachers' perceptions on the welcoming of other cultures to Portugal and to explore some aspects of their experience working with immigrant and refugee students. Hopefully, this data will help to identify teachers’ high or low prevalence of positive or negative stereotypes concerning immigrant and refugee population, and also to characterise the preparation and training of teachers to deal with cultural diversity.
So far, the preliminary analysis suggests a low prevalence of conscious prejudice towards welcoming other cultures in Portugal. On the other hand, there is data pointing to the existence of a negative stereotype regarding the perception of certain ethnic groups as less hard-working than others. In the context of initial and ongoing teacher training, teachers report gaps in certain dimensions of intercultural education, such as communicating with a multilingual and multicultural audience or relating to the families of immigrant or refugee students. The data also suggests that the majority of teachers surveyed consider themselves poorly or fairly prepared to deal with these areas in their professional practice. However, a more thoughtful and informed analysis of these issues is needed.
The open questions include the voluntary sharing of teachers’ reflections, recommendations, and experiences of professional practice with students from minority cultures. It is hoped that the content analysis will reveal interesting praxeological aspects that can inform inclusive and integrative educational practice towards cultural diversity.
The information gathered on perceptions and beliefs, on the one hand, and on the positive experiences shared, on the other hand, may inspire important insights on the improvement of teachers’ education and well-being, and on the healthy fostering and integration of students from different cultures in school, thus contributing to fairer, more inclusive, democratic and wealthier societies.

References
Cerna, L. (2019). Refugee Education: Integration Models and Practices in OECD Countries. Em OECD Publishing. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/a3251a00-en
de Wal Pastoor, L. (2016). Rethinking Refugee Education: Principles, Policies and Practice from a European Perspective. Em Annual Review of Comparative and International Education 2016 (Vol. 30, pp. 107–116). Emerald Group Publishing Limited. https://doi.org/10.1108/S1479-367920160000030009
European Commission/EACEA/Eurydice. (2019). Integrating students from migrant backgrounds into schools in Europe: National policies and measures : Eurydice report. Publications Office of the European Union.
Huber, J., & Reynolds, C. (Eds.). (2014). Developing intercultural competence through education. Council of Europe Publishing.
INE, Statistics Portugal (January, 2024). Docentes do ensino não superior (N.º) por Localização geográfica (NUTS - 2013). https://www.ine.pt/xportal/xmain?xpid=INE&xpgid=ine_indicadores&indOcorrCod=0009573&contexto=bd&selTab=tab2&xlang=pt
PPMI. (2017). Preparing teachers for diversity: The role of initial teacher education. Final Report to Directorate-General for Education, Youth, Sport and Culture. Publications Office of the European Union. https://data.europa.eu/doi/10.2766/637002
Silva, R. L., Oliveira, J., Dias, C., Pinto, I. R., & Marques, J. M. (2018). How inclusive policies shape prejudice versus acceptance of refugees: A Portuguese study. Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology, 24(3), 296–305. https://doi.org/10.1037/pac0000314
Szelei, N., Tinoca, L., & Pinho, A. S. (2020). Professional development for cultural diversity: The challenges of teacher learning in context. Professional Development in Education, 46(5), 780–796. https://doi.org/10.1080/19415257.2019.1642233


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Reading Climate: Sustainability and Justice Education in School English

Larissa McLean Davies, Sarah Truman

MGSE, Australia

Presenting Author: McLean Davies, Larissa

The pilot project reported on in this paper is part of a larger aim: to transform English literary education insettler collonial contexts to foreground climate and racial justice as part of its core curriculum. Climate change has been identified as the major crisis facing the world, and a foremost issue for young people. Addressing the climate crisis in education requires new approaches that reflect the urgency and scope and scale of the situation and prepares young people to lead decisions regarding justice-focused, sustainable futures. The Reading Climate Pilot Project explored the way that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander literary narratives provide new perspectives on interactions with Country, climate change, allowing readers engagement with Indigenous knowledges and perspectives for the justice-oriented citizenry of the future. There is an urgent need for this research: while Indigenous writers’ contribution to understandings of climate are well documented and awarded, and the power of story to impact on understandings of significant environmental, social and cultural issues is well established, Aboriginal writing remains significantly underrepresented in Australia’s curricula, particularly in

subject English.

This project prioritizes Indigenous stories and interdisciplinary collaboration in

English, cross-curricular knowledge sharing, developing teaching resources in English secondary

settings, and interdisciplinary and international collaboration. The project was undertaken as a collaboration between the Literary Education Lab (members: Sandra Phillips; Sarah E. Truman, Clare Archer Lean, Melitta Hogarth and Larissa McLean Davies) with the Stella Prize for the literature or women and non-binary writers, and Indigenous authors and scholars.

Research questions were:

1. How do English teachers engage with Indigenous ways of knowing and understanding Country to imagine sustainable climate futures?

2. What new knowledge about climate justice in English education can be developed

through interdisciplinary collaboration between Indigenous writers and texts, and the

environmental humanities and climate science?

3. What real-world applications of new knowledge about the intersections of climate fiction, Indigenous knowledges, racial justice and climate science have for the field of sustainability education?

Theoretical framework: The project’s conceptual approach draws on three key ideas: Indigenous relationality, literary sociability, and literary linking. First, Indigenous relationality enables thought that connects all living things (Graham 2014; Harrison et al 2017). We are not only shaped by biology but also through our story-telling activities: the stories we tell ourselves have material effects on who we become (Heiss 2015; Clarke 2016). A climate justice citizenry requires the capacity to comprehend the complex relations between human and nonhuman species and Country. Indigenous fiction establishes a corpus of narrative ready for critical classroom engagement to develop this capacity. This argument resonates with English curricula accounts of the promise of literature for building good moral character and citizenship (Atherton 2005), but also prioritises feminist concerns over whose stories are prioritised, whose stories are listened to (Hogarth 2019; Truman 2019). By changing the repertoire of stories and reading practices we can change cultural understandings and futures: this is a pressing concern in an era of ongoing resource inequalities, environmental racism, and climate disasters (Yusoff 2018). Second, the study also draws on an understanding that pedagogical literary study is sociable and relational (Phillips & Archer-Lean 2019). Third, this project activates a new transdisciplinary method called literary linking (McLean Davies et al 2021). Literary linking is informed by principles of relationality and co-design, where research participants and researchers work together to develop shared understandings. It is underpinned by a commitment to interdisciplinary collaboration as a necessary component for making sense of pressing social, environmental, and cultural concerns, including climate change.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
In conversation with English’s said aims, the project’s purpose was to advance the decolonisation of English through cross-country book clubs focused on Indigenous climate fiction, a collaborative symposium with Indigenous authors, interdisciplinary experts, and secondary English teachers enabling the development of new disciplinary collaboration, and teaching resources and knowledge mobilisation across English and humanities education.

Participants were selected through the Stella Prize networks, and existing researcher networks.  Cohort diversity in teaching experience and contexts was considered a priority in participant selection. After assessing the expressions of interest, a total of 120 teachers from across Australia were invited to participate. Each email invitation included information about the Reading Climate project and what we were inviting participants to do: read Australian Aboriginal literary texts and participate in a book group online for 2 sessions (one hour each; and complete a survey following the book groups.
Teachers submitted a confirmation of their intention to be involved with the project along with a signed consent form. We received 44 signed consent forms from teachers and established three reading groups that each me twice. Reading group sessions were held in November 2022 (1 hour each session x 6 sessions). All teachers received ebooks and reading information for each session. Reading Groups were audio recorded and transcribed for later thematic analysis.

Data sources, evidence, objects or materials

This is an interdisciplinary project, with the research team spanning English education, literary studies and publishing studies. As such the data is perceived as the literary works themselves; the initial EOI from participants, outlining their motivation for wanting to join the book club; recordings of the sessions, which were audio recorded and transcribed for later thematic analysis, and the post book club questionnaire undertaken by participants.  All data sources will be utilised in the paper presentation

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
Some data analysis from the Reading Climate Pilot Project showed differences in teachers’ motivation for joining the seminars, for some it was to remediate a lack of understanding and engagement with Indigenous texts. Even through Australian writing more broadly, and Indigenous Australian writing have been prioritised in curriculum terms since 2007, several settler teachers expressed their own personal appreciation of Indigenous writing, yet they also articulated a fear of including Indigenous texts in their classrooms and ‘getting it wrong’ or ‘causing offence’. There are many resources for the teaching of Indigenous texts in English in Australia, however some teachers’ concerns could not be addressed by these, as they were more at the levels of ontology and epistemology rather than materials. This finding was in concert with other research (McLean Davies et al, 2023), which showed that English teachers own knowledge and perspectives profoundly shaped students’ experiences of and approach to set texts.
A reluctance and fear of making a cultural mistake, evident in the feedback from some participants, was countered by others, who, working schools with high Aboriginal populations were interested in ‘decentring’ English through Indigenous texts, and had begun this political work. Accordingly the project team discerned to different pedagogical models for understanding the ‘logic of Indigenous texts in English’, one traditionally extractionist, and the other moving toward ‘disciplining and regenerating English in the context of climate justice and sustainability.

References
Atherton, C. (2005). Defining literary criticism. Scholarship, Authority and the possession of literary knowledge 1880-2002. Palgrave Macmillan London
Clarke, M. B. (2016). Interview with Maxine Beneba Clarke. Metaphor, (2) 25-27. Coleman, C. (2017). Terra nullius. Hachette UK
Graham, M. (2014). Aboriginal notions of relationality and positionalism: A reply to Weber. Global Discourse: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Current Affairs and Applied Contemporary Thought, 4(1), 17-22.
Harrison, N., Bodkin, F., Bodkin-Andrews, G., & Mackinlay, E. (2017). Sensational pedagogies: Learning to be affected by Country. Curriculum Inquiry, 47(5) 504– 519.
Heiss, A. (2015) Celebrating the New Australian Literature. In Heiss, A. The Black Words Essays. St Lucia, Qld: AustLit.
Hogarth, M. (2019). Y is standard oostralin english da onlii meens of kommunikashun: Kountaring White man privileg in da kurrikulum. English in Australia, 54(1): 5-11
Janke, T., Cumpston, Z., Hill, R., Woodward, E... (2021). Australian State of the Environment, Australian Government Department of Agriculture, Water and the Environment, Canberra
McLean Davies, L., Doecke, B., Mead, P., Sawyer, W., & Yates, L. (2023). Literary Knowing and the Making of English Teachers: The Role of Literature in Shaping English Teachers’ Professional Knowledge and Identities. Taylor & Francis.
McLean Davies, L., Truman, S. E., & Buzacott, L. (2021). Teacher-researchers: A pilot project for unsettling the secondary Australian literary canon. Gender and Education, 33(7), 814-829
Phillips, S. R., & Archer-Lean, C. (2019). Decolonising the reading of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander writing: reflection as transformative practice. Higher Education Research & Development 38(1): 24-37.
Phillips, S. R., & Archer- Lean, C. (2019). Decolonising the reading of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander writing: reflection as transformative practice. Higher Education Research & Development 38(1): 24-37. Phillips, S., McLean Davies, L., & Truman, S. (2022). Power of country: Indigenous relationality and reading Indigenous climate fiction in Australia. Curriculum Inquiry, 52(2), 171-186.
Truman, S. E. (2022). Feminist speculations and the practice of research-creation: Writing pedagogies and intertextual affects. Routledge.
Truman, S. E. (2019). White deja vu: Troubling the certainty of the English canon in literary education. English in Australia, 54(3), 53-59.
Yusoff, K. (2018). A billion black Anthropocenes or none. University of Minnesota Press.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Early Childhood Education Teachers’ Awareness of Social Classes

Dorota Duda

University of Lower Silesia, Poland

Presenting Author: Duda, Dorota

The objective of this presentation is to show the results of research in which I explored the ECE teachers' awareness of social classes. As a teacher-student, I often observed a lot of reluctance towards some of the pupils from their teachers. Very often those children were from underprivileged families. I also observed and read a lot about inequalities in education, which led me to think about whether teachers, especially those from early childhood education have knowledge and awareness about social division and how this affects the pupils they work with.

According to Bourdieu's theory of socio-cultural reproduction, children start their schooling with different inherited capitals, but the school treats pupils as if they all have the same starting position while assuming that all children are expected to acquire the same skills, knowledge and level of 'cultural familiarity'. This situation allows middle- and upper-class children to benefit from the resources brought from home and early schooling (Grochalska, 2009: 63). Pupils for whom the values of the dominant culture are distant may consequently drop out of further education at a certain stage of their education or consciously choose ‘an educational profile that reproduces the life path of their parents’ (Szkudlarek, 2007: 35). However, the idea is not that students with low-class backgrounds should be deprived of the chance to change their social position, but that those working with the pupils should understand that school is part of a system that reproduces the social structure.

There are divergences in the literature in defining social class. Some authors speak of the 'death of classes' in most developed societies (Pakulski, Waters, 1996, in Lareau, 2008: 4) or the 'obsolescence of the term', including in relation to education, without denying the existence of social inequalities (Harris, 2018: i-ii). Anette Lareau notes that social classes are often written about in a non-explicit way, using terms such as 'inequality’, ‘stratification’, ‘origin’ or analysing specific indicators such as education, wealth, income, and occupation (Lareau, 2008: 3). Also in common parlance, the term appears to be ambiguous (Wright, 2005: 1) or attempts are made to strip it of its political character, as is the case, for example, in Palska's research (Gdula, Sadura, 2012: 18). In Poland, the issue of social classes seems to be perceived rather as a historical relic. The vocabulary used to describe the social structure, i.e. terms like: 'working class’, ‘social classes’, ‘exploitation’, ‘capital’, ‘class conflict’, ‘class struggle’ (Zuk, 2010: 9), is associated with the past social system and tends to be no longer used. On the other hand, some researchers stress that we are intuitively aware of the existence of social classes (Sadura, 2012). Despite the colloquial social perception of social classes, Polish researchers undertake class analyses, including those devoted to Bourdieu's concept, which I also adopted as the basis for my exploration on social classes and educational inequality (Gdula, Sadura, 2012).

Adopting Sadura’s approach to Polish social structure, we can distinguish three main social classes in Poland: higher, middle and lower (Gdula, Sadura, 2012). All three of them have different ways of life as well as different ways of learning which is a part of the way of living and living necessities (Sadura, 2017). Understanding this is crucial to creating inclusive school environments and developing the idea of equal chances.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
The empirical material that this presentation draws on comes from a research project in which I explored whether ECE teachers are aware of the existence of class divisions and whether this (un)awareness is visible in their work with pupils. 14 ECE teachers of varying seniority working in the Polish education system took part in the study. The teachers differed in terms of the geographical location of their schools (eight of them worked in large cities, two – in small towns, and four – in rural areas) and their experience with working in a class-diverse environment. Interviewed teachers worked in a school in a neighbourhood with a bad reputation; perceived to be affluent; in a socially diverse environment; in areas with high economic deprivation, in a place that formed an enclave by being a private institution for parents with high economic capital and in places that were so-called urban bedroom communities.
I used the grounded theory methodology (Charmaz, 2009) and a bricolage of interpretive approaches in the research project (Kvale, 2012).  The narrative and semi-structured interviews were used to collect data. The opening question during the narrative interview was about family relationships, especially from childhood and educational experiences up to the time the interviewee entered university. The semi-structured interview questions focused on four areas: the teacher's workplace, the teacher's vision of the child, the perception of pupils' educational opportunities, and social inequalities. Most of the interviews were conducted in two sessions, one for the narrative part, and the other for semi-structured. They lasted from 45 minutes to 2 hours. All interviews were recorded and transcribed. The responses were coded inductively; the analysis itself was divided into two stages: the identification of teachers' awareness of social class and the analysis of teachers' private pedagogical theories, resulting in a middle-range theory of a preliminary typology of teachers' private pedagogical theories of the possibilities for pupils to change their social trajectories.
To identify the social class awareness of teachers, I analysed their explicit statements about what class they belonged to, whether their position had changed during their lifetime, as well as the non-explicit statements I was able to generate from other parts of the interviews. The research was carried out in line with the principles of ethical research conduct, with consent obtained from all participants.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
The analysis followed three steps: exploring the class self-identification of the teachers participating in the research; analysing the language used by the teachers concerning social class; identifying the areas of the teachers' awareness of social class.
Twelve teachers answered the question about their class affiliation, six of whom explicitly defined their class affiliation using terms such as middle class, intelligence, economically average, so in the middle, borderline average, and lower borderline average. Five teachers answered the question by comparing their current social class with their class of origin. One teacher said that her current social class was higher than that of her childhood, and one identified ‘social class’ with ‘classroom’.
After self-identification of the teacher’s social position, I explored the language teachers were using and was able to distinguish explicit and non-explicit statements related to social class.
In the third step, I explored areas of the teachers’ class awareness determined on the basis of their non-explicit statements concerned issues such as economic, cultural capital, dichotomous perception of reality, the neighbourhood in which the educational institution is located, social position, reproduction of family lifestyles and ‘indirect differentiation’.  
Based on the data collected, I distinguished four groups of teachers' class (un)awareness: a group of teachers who valorise social differentiation (6), those who observe social differentiation (4), those who do not perceive social differentiation (3), and a group of teachers who have no class awareness (1).
The first conclusion after analysing the empirical material leads one to conclude that social class content appears in the narratives of the teachers. It occurs independently of the question of the teacher's class identification. The second conclusion, however, is that, overall, there is little content related to class awareness in their narratives as well as addressing the issue of changing the social order.

References
Charmaz, K. (2009). Teoria ugruntowana. Praktyczny przewodnik po analizie jakościowej. Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN.
Gdula, M., Sadura, P. (2012). Style życia jako rywalizujące uniwersalności. In: M. Gdula, P. Sadura (ed.), Style życia i porządek klasowy w Polsce (p. 15–70). Wydawnictwo Naukowe SCHOLAR
Grochalska, M. (2009). Między pożądaną równością a nieuniknioną różnicą. In: A. Męczkowska-Christiansen, P. Mikiewicz (ed.), Idee—Diagnozy—Nadzieje. Szkoła polska a idee równości (p. 61–80). Wydawnictwo Naukowe Dolnośląskiej Szkoły Wyższej.
Harris, D. (2018). Foreword. In: I. Gilbert (ed.), The working class. Poverty, education and alternatives voices (p. i–ii). Independent Thinking Press.
Kvale, S. (2012). Prowadzenie wywiadów. Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN.
Lareau, A. (2008). Introduction: Taking Stock of Class. In: A. Lareau, D. Conley (ed.), Social Class: How Does It Work? Russell Sage Foundation.
Sadura, P. (2012). Wielość w jedności: Klasa średnia i jej zróżnicowania. In: M. Gdula, P. Sadura (ed.), Style życia i porządek klasowy w Polsce (p. 163–193). Wydawnictwo Naukowe SCHOLAR.
Sadura, P. (2017). Państwo, szkoła, klasy. Wydawnictwo Krytyki Politycznej.
Szkudlarek, T. (2007). Edukacja i konstruowanie społecznych nierówności. In: J. Klebaniuk (ed.), Fenomen nierówności społecznych. Nierówności społeczne w refleksji humanistycznej (p. 31–52). ENETEIA Wydawnictwo Psychologii i Kultury.
Wright, E. O. (2005). Approaches to Class Analysis. Cambridge University Press.
Żuk, P. (2010). Wstęp. Przemilczana rzeczywistość—O problemach z dostrzeganiem nierówności społecznych w czasach realnego kapitalizmu. In: P. Żuk (ed.). Podziały klasowe i nierówności społeczne: Refleksje socjologiczne po dwóch dekadach realnego kapitalizmu w Polsce (p. 9–14). Oficyna Naukowa.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Boundary-crossing teachers in war: Israeli-Palestinian Educators in Jewish Schools Amidst Unprecedented Turmoil

Shahar Gindi1, Michal Hisherik1,3, Nehaya Awida Haj Yehya1,3, Iris Yaniv2, Gahl Silverman4, Taly Ben Yehuda1

1Beit Berl College, Israel; 2Oranim College of Education; 3The Open university; 4Tel Aviv University

Presenting Author: Gindi, Shahar; Yaniv, Iris

We examine how Palestinian teachers in Jewish schools, who are Israeli citizens, coped during the intense conflict that unfolded after the events of October 7, 2023. This period was marked by a series of coordinated attacks initiated by Palestinian militant groups led by Hamas. The attacks included a relentless barrage of some 3,000 rockets targeting Israel and the breach of the Gaza–Israel barrier by around 3,000 militants who launched assaults on Israeli military bases and civilian communities, resulting in approximately 1,200 casualties and the abduction of about 240 civilians (Dostri, 2023).

The onslaught triggered recollections of European pogroms and the Holocaust among many of the Jewish citizens in Israel and elicited a national trauma (Tal, 2023). This shifted their perception from enjoying a comfortable, modern life in a quasi-European nation to an overarching sense of survival. This sentiment manifested as heightened suspicion toward Arab citizens of Israel (Asad, 2023), accompanied by widespread conspiracy theories alleging collusion with Hamas. There was also a notable persecution of Palestinian citizens of Israel expressing support for Palestinians on social media during this period.

Amidst the escalated tension and violence, Palestinian citizens of Israel working as teachers in Jewish schools were placed on the educational frontlines (Gindi et al., 2023). They encountered unprecedented challenges in managing interactions with students, students’ parents, co-teachers, and even their daily commutes to the schools where they taught. Our exploration delves into the experiences, resilience, and strategies employed by Israeli-Palestinian educators as they navigated the complexities of teaching in an environment overshadowed by the Gaza–Israel conflict.

Throughout November 2023, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 12 teachers and five supporting personnel 16 of which are Palestinian citizens of Israel and one Jewish Israeli citizen. The interviewees expressed their astonishment at the events of October 7th, elaborating on their personal concerns regarding safety, security, and the prospect of resuming teaching duties in Jewish schools. They also discussed the transformations they observed both in Israeli society at large and within their immediate school environments. By exploring the role of Palestinian citizens of Israel as teachers in Jewish schools during this tumultuous period, the lecture aims to offer insights into the transformative power of education and the mediating role of teachers’ workplace relationships in fostering resilience, tolerance, and the potential for unity even in the most challenging circumstances of external war which intensify an internal national identity conflict.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
This qualitative study is based on data collected In November 2023. The information collected included 12 interviews with Palestinian citizens of Israel who are teachers in Jewish schools and five interviews with supporting staff from a non-governmental agency that provides support for Palestinian teachers in Jewish schools. Three of the supporting staff were Palestinians working in Jewish schools themselves which allowed them to both report on their own experiences at the school and their experiences in supporting other teachers.
The interviews utilized a semi-structured guide constructed in alignment with the research question. Four Ph.D. holders, each specializing in distinct fields (psychology, sociology, education, and religion), and one Master’s level psychologist served as interviewers. One of the interviewers was a native Arabic speaker, and the others were native Hebrew speakers. Consequently, some interviews were conducted in Arabic, with subsequent translation into Hebrew following transcription.
The interviews, ranging from one to one and a half hours, were transcribed and then uploaded to a software-assisted qualitative data analysis  NVIVO14  program (Bazeley, 2022) that was employed to facilitate the storage, coding, and systematic retrieval of the qualitative data (Wood & Bloor, 2006). This method enhances the accuracy, reliability, and transparency of qualitative investigations (Liamputtong, 2020). The coder, a Ph.D. holder specializing in conflict analysis, experienced in software-assisted qualitative data analysis, utilized a qualitative content analysis approach to identify recurring themes and patterns through data reduction, text interpretation, and an effort to identify consistency and core meanings within the data (Bernard et al., 2016). In the classification process, data were extracted into segments, inductively coded into categories, and grouped and compared with similar segments from other observations. This flexible method typically combines concept-driven and data-driven categories, ensuring that the overall coding framework aligns with the data (Schreier, 2014).

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
Following the October 7th, 2023 events, Israeli-Palestinian teachers in Jewish schools faced complex challenges due to the change in Jewish Israeli society. After the Oct 7th attack, many Jews began suspecting the Palestinian Arabs of allegiance with Hamas, asked them continuously to prove their loyalty and scrutinized their social media involvement. These educators, who had previously aimed for shared living with their Jewish counterparts, found their coexistence efforts seemingly futile amid the war. Initial findings highlight their astonishment and concerns about safety, affecting their personal well-being, including travel to and from school.

In response to the precarious situation, these teachers adopted strategic communication approaches to foster unity and understanding during heightened tensions. Utilizing first-person terms, they emphasized the shared experiences of fear and anger among both Jews and Arabs affected by indiscriminate missiles. Acknowledging the difficulty of empathizing during escalations, Israeli-Palestinian teachers emphasized the paramount importance of maintaining mutual respect. Despite challenges in understanding the other side's perspective, they stressed the need for concerted efforts to ensure the safety and well-being of all teachers and students.
Some teachers took a proactive stance against the war, expressing clear and decisive opposition to violence. They articulated a general stance against harm to both innocent Jews and Palestinians, some even exhibiting opposition to Hamas. Steering clear of complex political debates, they prioritized unity over ideological disagreements, reflecting a commitment to a cohesive educational environment and peace principles during a period of heightened emotions and challenges.
Finally, initial findings point to an interrelation between the concerns of management for the personal condition of Israeli-Palestinian teachers during the chaotic first days of the war, especially principals’ interventions, and teachers sense of belonging and willingness to teach in a Jewish school.

References
Asad, A. (2023). Challenges and threats: Arab society in Israel during the war in Gaza. The Israel Democracy Institute, https://en.idi.org.il/articles/51567
Bazeley, P. (2022). Designing for Multimodal Data and Mixed Methods within a Qualitative Framework. The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research Design (pp.604-617). Sage.
Bernard, H. R., Wutich, A., & Ryan, G. W. (2016). Analyzing qualitative data: Systematic approaches. SAGE Publications.
Dostri, O. (2023). Hamas’s October 2023 attack on Israel: The end of the deterrence strategy in Gaza. Military Review, 1, 1-13 .
Gindi, S., Gilat, Y. & Sagee, R. (2022). Short communication – Students’ attitudes toward boundary-crossing teachers before and after the May 2021 violence between Israelis and Palestinians: A ripple effect? International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 91, 38-43
Liamputtong, P. (2020). Qualitative Research Methods (5th ed.). Oxford University Press.
Schreier, M. (2012). Qualitative content analysis in practice. Sage.
Tal, R, (2023). The October 7 Massacre Brings Back Horrific Memories for This Iraqi-Jewish Author, Haaretz (Dec 13, 2023), https://www.haaretz.com
Wood, F., & Bloor, M. (2006). Keywords in qualitative methods: A vocabulary of research concepts. Keywords in Qualitative Methods, 1-208.
 
17:30 - 19:0007 SES 08 B: Education for Democracy and Citizenship - Intercultural and Inclusive
Location: Room 117 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [Floor 1]
Session Chair: Eunice Macedo
Paper Session
 
07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Teaching Democracy in Greek Schools: Prerequisites and Research Outcomes

Anastasia Kesidou

Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece

Presenting Author: Kesidou, Anastasia

Current imperatives for education systems include key objectives, such as developing young people into citizens who will be equipped to live successfully in open, democratic and pluralistic societies. This issue is of crucial importance, taking into account the strengthening of nationalism, intolerance and racism in recent years and the challenges posed by the arrival of large numbers of immigrants and refugees in Greece and in Europe.

The inclusion of immigrant and refugee children into schooling is a matter of crucial importance for European societies. Equal access to school is an unalienable human right of all children, as it is enshrined in the Declaration of Human Rights, the Convention on the Rights of the Child and in other international legal documents. Through education, knowledge is developed and skills, values and attitudes are cultivated, this way ensuring the unimpeded personality development of all children. At the same time, it is the safest way to their inclusion into societies. In the context of an intercultural approach to education, the aim cannot be the linguistic and cultural assimilation of children or their marginalization and the creation of parallel societies within the dominant society. Equal access to school is a legitimate act of respect for the fundamental human right to education, but at the same time it is also a choice with positive results for both children and the wider society.

At the same time, it is of major importance to provide children with quality education, which on one hand, will fully exploit their potential and on the other, will create a culture of democracy, respect, solidarity and justice in school and society. Fully realizing potential means that children will have equal opportunities for advancement in school and society, while a culture of democracy, which will include all children, native, minority, migrant or refugee, should involve a holistic approach; first and foremost, this is understood at the level of an educational policy inspired by a commitment to democratic principles. At the same time, it is important to teach democratic principles through the curriculum and extra-curricular activities, using participatory methods that empower students to think critically and independently and to be able to resolve conflicts. At the same time, democracy can be taught effectively within a democratic school community, so that students can become catalysts for change in their social environment (Council of Europe, 2016).

Intercultural Education has been an issue of importance in Greek education since the 1990s, when Greece became a receiving country for immigrants. After the emergence of the economic crisis in 2009, as well as the dynamic appearance of a far-right extremist group in the political scene, it became evident that the very idea of intercultural education had to be reconsidered and linked to education for democracy in order to help fight xenophobia, racism, chauvinism and euro-skepticism (Kesidou, 2019). This paper seeks to explore the prerequisites and challenges of effective democratic education in Greek schools, taking into account contemporary research data. The data is based on research, which has been conducted by the author in recent years, mainly within a European setting, seeking evidence on the effectiveness of democratic education in Greek secondary schools. The focus is both on educational policy and practice, in terms of the curriculum, teaching methodology, school culture, teachers and students. The research involved the collection of data on the formal education policy, as well as the performance of an in-depth case study in Greece; it revealed a considerable gap between policy and practice as well as that teaching democracy is challenged by inherent weaknesses of Greek education and schooling (Kesidou, 2017, Kesidou, 2021).


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
In recent years, there has been an increasing research interest, at national and European level, on issues concerning education for democracy and in particular on teaching democracy in schools. The field is also of growing interest at a broader international level. A published research by Sant (2019) on Democratic Education: a Theoretical Review (2006-2017) focuses on 377 scientific papers published during the aforementioned period in international journals, only in English, on the topic of "Democratic Education", highlighting the different versions and discourses, their different philosophical foundations and their views on education, but also the relevant criticisms they have made and received. At the same time, it is important to note the extensive research activity that has taken place at the level of international organizations and bodies which, in the context of 'soft governance', act as 'think tanks', providing information and guidance to member states through comparative studies and evaluation reports that influence national policy formulation.
The research was part of a wider research project, which was initiated by the European Parliament’s Committee on Culture and Education. It was conducted by collecting data on the formal education policy of all European Union member states and by performing in-depth case studies in 12 of the member states, one of which was Greece (Veugelers, W., de Groot I. & Stolk V.J., 2017). In particular, a written questionnaire was implemented addressing the research questions concerning education policy on democratic education, content of democratic education, attention to school culture, etc. The in-depth study was conducted on the basis of interviews of teachers who are involved in education for democracy and extended the focus of the research to the curriculum practiced at the school level. The paper also considers a follow up-study conducted a few years later, which highlighted citizenship education policies and practices in 10 European Union member states (Veugelers, W., Zygierewicz, A., 2021).

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
In the following, some of the basic conclusions are highlighted, which, to a wide extent, also correspond to further relevant research conducted at the national level (Sira, 2020, Strouni & Kesidou, 2023). The secondary school curriculum seems to include the basic goals and aims regarding democracy but often they do not go beyond the level of mere rhetoric. Teaching democracy is challenged by inherent weaknesses of Greek education and schooling. Aims and contents of democracy often remain inactive due to the traditional teaching and learning methodologies implemented in practice. In this way, the presence of democracy in the curriculum does not guarantee its implementation but it depends largely on the initiative and inspiration of specific schools and teachers. A democratic school culture seems difficult to realize due to the lack of adequate participation and cooperation of teachers, students and parents. Schools could be closer linked to the communities and the real needs of local societies. Teaching democracy can be improved, if the relevant teaching goals are explicitly clarified and asked for by policy makers, if it constitutes an everyday aim for the school community as a whole, if relevant achievements are assessed by the school unit- the latter is important to receive adequate outside support. Teachers should have the possibility to teach students how to be active citizens with an ability to value diversity. It should also be highlighted that democratic education seems to have been reduced in more recent years within the Greek secondary curriculum, while there is also the positive aspect of a growing interest on the part of teachers to be more actively involved in relevant initiatives.
References
Council of Europe (2016). Competences for democratic culture – Living together as equals in culturally diverse democratic societies. Strasbourg: Council of Europe https://rm.coe.int/16806ccc07

Ikonomidis, Β.D. & Eleftherakis, Th.G. (2011). Εκπαίδευση, δημοκρατία και ανθρώπινα
δικαιώματα [Education, democracy and human rights]. Athens: Διάδραση.

Katsarou, E. (2020). H δημοκρατία στο σχολείο. Προοπτικές από την αξιοποίηση διαδικασιών έρευνας δράσης και κριτικού γραμματισμού [Democracy at school. Prospects from the use of action research and critical literacy processes]. Athens: Πεδίο

Kesidou, A. (2017). Citizenship and tolerance in the cradle of democracy. In W. Veugelers, I. de Groot & V. Stolk (Eds.), Research for CULT Committee- Teaching Common Values in Europe. Study (pp. 107-114). European Union: Directorate-General for Internal Policies. Policy Department for Structural and Cohesion Policies. Culture and Education.

Kesidou, A. (2019). Preparing educators and researchers for Multicultural/Intercultural Education. In W. Veugelers (Ed.), Education for Democratic Intercultural Citizenship (pp. 148-165). Leiden: Brill/Sense.

Kesidou, A. (2021). Greece. In W. Veugelers, W., A. Zygierewicz (Eds), Implementation of Citizenship Education Action in the EU. European Implementation Assessment (pp. 77-80). Brussels: EPRS | European Parliamentary Research Service.

Sant, E. (2019). Democratic Education: A theoretical review (2006–2017). Review of Educational Research, 89(5), 655-696.

Sira, E. (2020). H ιδιότητα του πολίτη στο ελληνικό γενικό λύκειο: δυνατότητες και όρια ανάπτυξής της σε πλαίσιο εκπαιδευτικών παρεμβάσεων [Citizenship in Greek general Lyceum: possibilities and restraints in a framework of educational interventions]. Phd thesis. Florina: University of Western Macedonia.

Strouni, C., A. Kesidou (2023). Citizenship education in the newly published Greek secondary curricula: A move to individualized citizenship? In N. Palaiologou & E. Samsari (Eds.), Intercultural education on the move: Facing old and new challenges (pp. 271-275).
International Association for Intercultural Education (IAIE).

Tridimas, M.F. (2020). Citizenship education curriculum in Greece beyond ethnocentric or eurocentric approach. Australian and New Zealand Journal of European Studies, 12 (1), 4-24.

Veugelers, W., I. de Groot & V. Stolk (Eds) (2017). Research for CULT Committee- Teaching Common Values in Europe: Study. European Union: Directorate-General for Internal Policies. Policy Department for Structural and Cohesion Policies. Culture and Education.
https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/6f527dc2-3c40-11e7-a08e-01aa75ed71a1/language-en

Veugelers, W., A. Zygierewicz (Eds) (2021). Implementation of Citizenship Education Action in the EU. European Implementation Assessment. Brussels: EPRS | European Parliamentary Research Service.
https://www.europarl.europa.eu/thinktank/en/document/EPRS_STU(2021)694207


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Adolescents with Migrant Background. A Systematic Review and a Metasummary of Qualitative Studies.

Paola Dusi1, Giuseppe Grimaldi2, Maria Mori1, Luca Ghirotto3

1Università degli studi di Verona, Italy; 2Università degli Studi di Trieste, italy; 3AZIENDA USL – IRCCS DI REGGIO EMILIA, Italy

Presenting Author: Dusi, Paola

To be an adolescent with migrant background it is not an easy task. During this phase of life, self-image and self-concept have to be reworked, so one is more fragile and more exposed to one's own evaluation and that, particularly relevant, of peers. Besides, as children of immigrants, they have to cope with many cultural systems of reference, and their identities’ multiple faces to build a coherent sense of identity (Syed, 2010). They face the fundamental key task of exploring and defining their cultural and ethnic identity. Succeeding in this task is considered to be an important resource for accomplishing the generic developmental tasks faced by all young people. This identity challenge (i.e.,) has been studied by many researchers (i.e. Baumert et al., 2024; Benet-Martinez et al., 2002; Behtoui, 2021; Lilgendahl et al., 2018; Portes et al., 2011). Most published research has used a quantitative approach, which leaves very little room for adolescents' lived experiences. In this scenario, qualitative research (QR) for its characteristics, allows us to have access and includes the pre/adolescents’ voices and perspectives (ages 10/11–19/20). Conducting a meta-summary on QR on this topic allows us both to access these subjects’ perspectives and to understand the development in the field (which kind of and how much research has been conducted). The thematic summaries of data resulting from the systematic review can give us insight into little-explored topics and provide suggestions on possible new work paths. To the best of our knowledge a systematic review in this field, with this goal, has not yet been done.

This research by underlining the pre/adolescent point of view, can contribute to enhance the knowledge on this topic.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
Systematic review refers to a family of research approaches that use second-level analysis to answer a specific question. The data used are the results collected from the primary research.  Ann Oakley defines a systematic review as a process characterised by transparency and replicability, the result of which is - potentially - also updateable (2000). They differ from other types of research syntheses in the way they formulate a research question, the overall approach to research, the critical appraisal strategy, and the transparency of the inclusion and exclusion criteria of primary studies for review (Davies, 2004). Such a process makes it possible to synthesize the results of many different research in a given field, thus leading to a gain in knowledge that is not only theoretical but also practical (since it provides insights into what works).  To sum up, reviews of qualitative studies allow for a deeper understanding of concepts and findings beyond the single qualitative studies. They aim to achieve abstraction and transferability at a higher level beyond the included original studies.
To answer this study's aim, we performed a systematic review and a meta-summary following the 4-step procedure outlined by Sandelowski and Barroso (2006).  
This method entails a: i) comprehensive search, ii) appraising reports of qualitative studies, iii) classification of studies, and iv) synthesis of the findings.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
We searched for qualitative articles published from 2011 to 2020 to retrieve the more recent studies. The following electronic databases were searched: ERIC, PsycINFO (Ebsco), PsycARTICLES (Ebsco), BEI (Ebsco), and Scopus and Web of Science, with no language limitations.
The amount of the abstract downloaded was 1804. Following the merge of the duplicates  we analyzed 1452 of them. The screening of the abstracts, based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria defined at the beginning of the research process,  led to the elimination of 90.3% of the abstracts found on the databases . We selected 142 abstracts for further analysis of the entire article in order to check whether they met the inclusion and exclusion criteria. We created a drive folder for an intersubjective comparison of the articles to be included and excluded. At the end of the analysis, we included 38 articles that met all the inclusion criteria. To analyze the adolescents’ voices quoted in the selected 38 articles retrived by our search, we used NVivo, a Computer Assisted Qualitative Data Analysis Software  (CAQDAS). Through Nvivo we got 871 nodes, and we classified 69 labels.  Then, we conducted a further grouping, organizing the 69 labels into 9 main themes.  This research, by emphasizing the viewpoint of preadolescents, can help increase knowledge of this topic to inform future research and to explore topics not addressed by traditional research.

References
Baumert, J., Becker, M., Jansen, M. & Köller, O. (2024). Cultural Identity and the Academic, Social, and Psychological of Adolescents with Immigration Background. Journal of  Youth and Adolescence, 53, 294-315.

Behtoui, A. (2021). Construction of self-identities: children of immigrants in Sweden. Identities, 28:3, 341-360.

Benet-Martinez, V., Leu, J., Lee, F., & Morris, M. (2002). Negotiating biculturalism: Cultural frame switching in biculturals with oppositional versus compatible cultural identities. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 33, 492-516.

Davies, P. (2004) Systematic reviews and the Campbell collaboration. In G. Thomas & R. Pring (Eds.) Evidence-based practice in education (pp. 21–33). Maidenhead:  Open University Press.

Erikson, E. (1968). Identity: Youth and crisis. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.

Ho, M., & Bauder, H. (2010). We are chameleons. Identity capital in a multicultural workplace. Brussels: CERIS, Working Paper 77.

Lilgendahl, J.P., Benet-Martinez V., Bishop, M., Gilson, K., Festa, L., Levenson, C. & Rosenblum, R. (2018). “So now, I Wonder, What Am I?”: A Narrative Approach to Bicultural Identity Integration. Journal of Cross Cultural Psychology, 49(10), 1596-1624.

Long H.A., French D.P., &. Brooks J.M. (2020). Optimising the value of the critical appraisal skills programme (CASP) tool for quality appraisal in qualitative evidence synthesis. Research Methods in Medicine & Health Sciences, 1(1), 31-42. doi:10.1177/2632084320947559

Moher D. (2009). Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: The PRISMA Statement. Annals of Internal Medicine, 151(4), 264.
Oakley, A. (2000). Experiments in knowing: gender and method in the social sciences. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Phinney, J. S. (1992). The multigroup ethnic identity measure: A new scale for use with adolescents and young adults from diverse group.  Journal of Adolescence Research (2), 156-176.

Portes, A., Vickstrom, E., & Aparicio, R. (2011). Coming of age in Spain: The self-identification, beliefs and self-esteem of the second generation. The British Journal of Sociology, 62(3), 387–417.

Sandelowski M, Barroso J. (2006). Handbook for synthesizing qualitative research. New York: Springer.


Syed, M. (2010). Developing an integrated self: Academic and ethnic identities among ethnically-diverse college students. Developmental Psychology, 46, 1590-1604.

Tong A., Flemming K., McInnes E., Oliver S., Craig J. (2012). Enhancing transparency in reporting the synthesis of qualitative research: ENTREQ. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 12(181).

Vertovec, S. (2006). New complexities of cohesion in Britain: Superdiversity, transnationalism, and civil integration. London: Commission on Integration and Cohesion.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

A Look at Dance in Upper-secondary Schools: Democratization and Awareness

Joana Mesquita1,2, Eunice Macedo1,2, Helena Costa Araújo1,2

1University of Porto, Portugal; 2Centre for Research and Intervention in Education of the Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences

Presenting Author: Macedo, Eunice

This paper explores what dance experiences young people can have in upper-secondary school and what happens within. The main concern is the apparent prevalence of inequalities in access to dance in education for young Portuguese.

Dance can introduce strong body awareness, allow people to enjoy a 'totalizing' self-experience (Karkou & Oliver, 2017), linking the capacity for expression, movement, balance, and knowledge of the body with relationships with the social environment (Costa et al., 2004). Enabling dance in education can immeasurably expand students' abilities to master more complex tasks and support social and emotional learning across the curriculum, stimulating self-fulfillment, the sensitive construction of relationships, promoting responsibility and leadership, inspiring to understand and address the most critical challenges of their times as citizens of the world (Brown, 2017).

The European Action Strategy recognizes the transformative potential of cultural practices - such as dance - to strengthen democracy (Council of EU, 2022). Articulate art and education may stimulate cognitive development and make the learning processes more relevant to modern societies (UNESCO, 2006).

Nevertheless, a European political agenda governed by numbers and vehemently market-oriented (Council of EU, 2019; Macedo, 2018) still prevails, focused on providing young people with the skills to successfully enter the world of work. Although this is also important, it may lead schools to become instrumental to the market (Nada et al., 2022). Education can and must go further.

In Portugal, the “Profile of Pupils Leaving Compulsory Schooling”(2017) considers these concerns and European guidelines, establishing a set of principles, areas of competence, and values that should be included in education, while simultaneously recognizing the importance of a more humanist education, based on social justice. The “Curricular Matrices of Upper-secondary Education” in Portugal(2018) show that the human, expressive, and artistic dimensions are growingly neglected as we progress through the education system. The "Guiding Principles of Curricular Revision"(2001) blur the core of secondary education, turning it into a "passageway" between elementary and higher education, devaluing its central role.

The curricular pillars of the Portuguese education system aim to respond to the National and European Qualifications Framework as recommendations that have reaffirmed competitive, economic, and mercantilist principles, leaving small room for exercising citizenship of body, brain, and soul. Appears necessary to unleash new strategies to connect education to humanity to build an increasingly democratic and citizen society (International Commission on the Future of Education, 2022). Dance is a possible way forward.

In this paper we establish a dialogue between the field of education and the one of dance. Experience with the arts is recognized as a right, and access to dance is defended within the education framework for all, to build fairer, more equitable, and sustainable presents and futures (idem). We argue that education with the arts incorporates ethical, aesthetic, and solidarity principles (Macedo, 2021; Monteiro, 2021) and that the arts are a way of life and of building relationships rather than a technical practice.

It seems trivial to assume the importance of arts in education, at least in a theoretical way (Monteiro, 2014). However, we are still being confronted with a duel between science and arts, reason and emotion, as dissociated. Science is seen as the primary source of reliable, cognitive, and valuable knowledge rather than the artistic experience seen as less valid and credible. This segmented view tends to be reproduced in the educational system where the arts become secondary (Eisner, 2002), with dance coming lastly in the curriculum (EURYDICE, 2009). We argue that dance has a strong potential for young people’s personal and social development, intertwining in a more holistic perspective of education that needs further investment and research.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
This paper is part of a larger research funded by FCT that questions whether and how young people's dance experiences relate to their well-being and their view of themselves as citizens.
To debate the importance of greater social justice in access to dance in schools, this paper focuses on i) the apparent prevalence of inequalities in young people's access to dance in schools; ii) the observed implications of their participation in dance.
After mapping upper-secondary educational institutions offering dance in Porto district, Portugal, to address the following objectives: i) Identify upper-secondary education institutions (public, private, artistic and professional) in Porto's district that have dance spaces; ii) Understand the formats of this offer (extracurricular activity, school sports, dance clubs, among others); iii) Understand who is responsible for the initiative of creating these spaces. Through access to the GesEdu digital portal – provided by the Directorate of Education Statistical Services – we could identify 183 upper-secondary educational institutions. The schools with dance spaces were identified through consultation with official institutional websites, public social network pages, email contacts, and telephone calls. It should be noted that only 22 educational institutions did not reply.
Next, 6 public educational institutions were selected for participant observation over 10 weeks to address the question: what social dynamics take place in dance spaces? The choice schools implied a set of criteria: 1) schools that seemed to have a solid commitment to dance (based on mapping); 2) inland and on the coast - geographical diversity; 3) offer of different dance formats. Schools were invited to participate in the research by e-mail. Meetings were scheduled with the directors and responsible teachers, and we met with the young people to ensure that they wanted and agreed to make part of the research in the conditions defined. Then, we stayed in the field during the weeks observing and taking notes of how young people move, occupy, and socialize in dance spaces. After that, we conducted content analysis to analyse the field notes.
The ethical principles of research are considered throughout the journey, from recognizing the copyright of the arguments mobilized through the informed consents and assents systematically reinforced to the return of the data to the research participants.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
This paper presents the results of two stages of research: mapping and participant observation. Through a quantitative approach, the main results of the mapping allowed us to understand that only 39 upper-secondary educational institutions in Porto’s district offer dance (about 24.2%) from the universe of 161 respondents. We also realized that the offer of dance at the upper secondary level is restricted to a tiny universe of educational institutions, which is even less expressive when we look further inland or refer to public educational institutions. So, we conclude that access to dance in education is not sufficiently democratized, the right to its practice is unequal.
Through a qualitative approach, using content analysis on the field notes from participant observation, we defined a set of categories and subcategories that sought to reflect on: What relationships are established in dance spaces? How do young people organize themselves? What space is there for young voices? What power relations are (de)constructed?
Education is a privileged means of promoting social justice and equal opportunities, particularly during compulsory schooling (Despacho no.182/2022, 15 julho). As such, we argue that public educational institutions are fundamental to providing cultural experiences – such as dance – to young people who could not have them in other ways. Although what is referred to in the Work Plan for Culture 2023-2026 (Council of EU, 2022) (on a European level) and in the National Plan for the Arts 2019-2024 (Vale et al., 2019) (on a national level), defending the widening and democratization of access to arts for its importance to people’s life, we conclude that much work needs to be done. We intend to take the dance to a different level through educational research – like this one – providing solid data to introduce it in scientific, political, and social debates.

References
Brown, Ann(2017). Provoking Change: Dance Pedagogy and Curriculum Design. In Vicky Karkou, Sue Oliver, & Sophia Lycouris (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of dance and wellbeing(pp. 399-414). Oxford University Press.
Costa, Anny, Monteiro, Estela, Vieira, Neiva, & Barroso, Maria(2004). A Dança como meio de conhecimento do corpo para a promoção da saúde dos adolescentes[Dance as a means of body-knowledge for the promotion of adolescents' health]. Doenças Sex Transm, 16(3), 43-49.
Council of the European Union(2019). A new strategic agenda 2019-2024.
Council of the European Union(2022). EU Work Plan for Culture 2023-2026.
Decreto-lei no. 7/2001, 18 janeiro. Princípios Orientadores da Revisão Curricular[Guiding Principles of Curricular Revision]. Portugal.
Decreto-lei nº 55/2018, 6 julho. Currículo dos ensinos básico e secundário e os princípios orientadores da avaliação das aprendizagens[Curricular Matrices of Upper-secondary Education]. Portugal.
Despacho 6478/2017, 26 julho. Perfil dos Alunos à Saída da Escolaridade Obrigatória[Profile of Pupils Leaving Compulsory Schooling]. Portugal.
Despacho no. 182/2022, 15 julho. Apoio financeiro do Estado às entidades de ensino artístico especializado[State financial support for specialized arts education entities]. Portugal.
Eisner, Elliot(2002). The Arts and the Creation of Mind. Yale University Press.
EURYDICE(2009). Arts and Cultural Education at School in Europe.
International Commission on the Future of Education(2022). Reimagining our futures together: a new social contract for education. UNESCO.
Macedo, Eunice(2018). Vozes Jovens entre Experiência e desejo: Cidadania educacional e outras construções. Edições Afrontamento.
Macedo, Eunice(2021). Educação como Experiência Ética, Estética e Solidária: Buscando Inspiração em Freire. Mais Leituras Editora.
Monteiro, Ana, Pereira, Ana, Mesquita, Joana, & Costa, Margarida(2021). Arte num livro de histórias para contar ao mundo: Um artefacto humano, espelho das aprendizagens. In Eunice Macedo (Ed.), A Educação como Experiência Ética, Estética e Solidária: Buscando inspiração em Freire(pp. 217-229). Mais Leituras Editora.
Monteiro, Elisabete(2014). Não basta ter dança nas escolas[It's not enough to have dance in schools]. In José Pereira, Manuel Vieites, & Marcelino Lopes (Eds.), As Artes na Educação(pp. 129-140). Intervenção.
Nada, Cosmin, Macedo, Eunice, Guedes Teixeira, Elsa, & Araújo, Helena C.(2022). Growing up in a never-ending crisis. Profesorado, 26(3), 125-149.
UNESCO(2006). Roteiro para a Educação Artística. Desenvolver as Capacidades Criativas para o Século XXI [Roadmap for Art Education. Developing Creative Capacities for the 21st Century]. Lisboa: Comissão Nacional da UNESCO.
Vale, Paulo, Brighenti, Sara, Pólvora, Nuno, Fernandes, Maria, Albergaria, Maria(2019). Estratégia do Plano Nacional das Artes 2019-2024. Lisboa, Portugal.
Vicky Karkou, Sue Oliver, & Sophia Lycouris(2017). The Oxford handbook of dance and wellbeing. Oxford University Press.
 
Date: Thursday, 29/Aug/2024
9:30 - 11:0007 SES 09 B: Biographies, life stories, belongings and person-centred approaches to social justice studies in education
Location: Room 117 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [Floor 1]
Session Chair: Ábel Bereményi
Paper Session
 
07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Exploring Qualitative and Quantitative Differences in Learning Among Low-educated Adults: a Person-oriented Approach

Bea Mertens, Sven De Maeyer, Vincent Donche

Universiteit Antwerpen, Belgium

Presenting Author: Mertens, Bea

As lifelong learning (LLL) is a significant condition for employability, social inclusion and active citizenship, the European Council has been emphasizing the importance of adult learning for the last two decades (European Commission, 2001; 2016; 2019). While good-quality motivation and good-quality learning strategies are important determinants of continued learning in adulthood (European Commission, 2016; Lüftenegger et al., 2012), learning processes in adult education are an understudied terrain, especially among low-educated adults, who we can expect to be insufficiently developed in these learning skills.

Educational psychological research agrees that learning is a complex interplay of motivation, regulation and cognitive processing and, regardless of the age of the studied population, individual differences in learning quality exist (Vermunt & Donche, 2017). It can therefore be expected that also low-educated adults should not be considered a homogeneous group of learners, but learner profiles, differing in the quality of learning motivation and use of learning strategies, may be present. In person-oriented research, motivation and learning strategies have so far mainly been studied separately, rather than as an integrated whole. Yet literature points to the strong reciprocal relation between the two components, in which neither motivation nor learning strategies are the protagonist (e.g., Alexander, 2017). For this reason, the current study seeks to answer the question of which qualitatively different learner profiles exist among low-educated adults, based on learning motivation and learning strategies used, investigating both components, relative to each other.

Learning motivation is conceptualized in this study according to Deci and Ryan's (2000) Self-Determination Theory (SDT), in which quality is understood as the degree to which behaviour is self-determined. Amotivation is situated at the lower end of the SDT-continuum, which is the same as a lack of motivation. Next on the continuum are various forms of extrinsic motivation. The least self-determined form of extrinsic motivation is external regulation. This behaviour is initiated by external pressure, such as rewards or power. Introjected regulation refers to behaviour that is self-imposed, such as behaviour to avoid guilt or boost the ego. The third and most self-determined form of extrinsic motivation, is identified regulation. It refers to behaviour that is posed because the learner finds it valuable. At the very top of the continuum is intrinsic motivation which refers to behaviour that stems from inherent interest or pleasure.

The distinction in quality for the component of learning strategies is conceptualized according to the Learning Patterns Model (LPM)(Vermunt & Donche, 2017). Students tending toward a meaning-oriented learning pattern process learning content in a deep way, combined with a high degree of self-regulation strategies. Students with an application-oriented learning pattern prefer to make connections to concrete situations and prefer both self- and external regulation strategies. Students with a reproduction-oriented learning pattern process in a surface manner and prefer strong external regulation by the learning environment. Students can be identified lacking any regulation strategies and using few to none processing strategies and whom the model labels as the undirected learning pattern. The former two patterns are considered good-quality patterns, while the latter patterns are considered poor-quality learning.

Although both theories have a tradition of variable-oriented research, person-oriented studies have increasingly appeared to distinguish between individual quality. For each component of learning (motivation, regulation and processing strategies), typically, four profiles are found, differentiating between a high- versus low-quantity and a good- versus poor-quality profile (e.g., Cents-Boonstra et al., 2019; Shum et al., 2023). Based on the insights of earlier person-oriented research, we hypothesize learning profiles among low-educated adults to be distinct not only in terms of quality but also in terms of quantity.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
1. Context and participants
The present study was conducted in six institutions for adult education in Flanders (northern part of Belgium). To reach the target population of low-educated adults, we compiled a convenience sample of 512 adults participating in a second-chance education program, allowing every participant to complete the survey during class hours.

2. Instrument and measurement
Motivation, regulation and processing strategies were measured by means of a paper and pencil version of the LEarning and MOtivation questionnaire (LEMO, Donche et al., 2010), a 49-item self-report inventory including 15 items measuring learning motivation based on SDT (Deci, & Ryan, 2000) and 34 items measuring regulation and processing strategies, as conceptualized in the LPM (Vermunt & Donche, 2017). All items were measured on a seven-point Likert scale to reduce ceiling effects and ranged for motivation from one (totally disagree) to seven (totally agree) and for regulation and processing strategies from one (never) to seven (always). Inspection of the psychometric properties showed acceptable construct validity and reliability of the different scales (motivation (CFI = .92, RMSEA = .08, SRMR = .06)(.70<α<.89); regulation strategies (CFI = .87, RMSEA = .08, SRMR = .07)(.69<α<.78); processing strategies (CFI = .91, RMSEA = .06, SRMR = .06)(.66<α<.73).

3. Data analysis
To distinguish learning profiles, a latent profile analysis was conducted. To evaluate how many groups best describe the data, typically, LPA uses several information criteria. As multiple information criteria can point to different conclusions, we mathematically combined different model fit criteria (AIC, AWE, BIC, CLC, and KIC) into a composite relative importance vector (C-RIV), with the highest value representing the model with the most optimal number of profiles (Akogul & Erisoglu, 2017). For LPA, inspection of missing data, outliers and normality of the distributions is recommended (Spurk et al., 2020). This resulted in the use of multiple imputation of missing values, removal of multivariate outliers using the Mahalanobis distance indicator and log-transformation of highly skewed scales. Key variables were standardized by rescaling to z-scores. All analyses were carried out in the statistical software R.  

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
Analyses revealed for the motivational component the four expected profiles. A distinction was made between a high-quantity profile (25.14%), a low-quantity profile (18.08% ), a good-quality profile (40.11%) and a poor-quality profile (16.67%). For the variables measuring regulation strategies, a two-profile solution proved most optimal. Both profiles are particularly distinct in their scores on self-regulation strategies. The profiles were labelled self-regulated profile (62.15%) versus unregulated profile (37.85%). For the processing scales, the five-profile solution yielded the most optimal results. Of the profiles found, 4 of 5 are quantitatively distinct, scoring either relatively high or low on all processing strategies. We labelled these profiles active (21.47%), moderately-active (49.15%), moderately-inactive (19.21%) and inactive profile (4.80%). The fifth, but underrepresented profile was labelled deep profile (5.37%), because of its relatively low levels of surface processing strategies and relatively high levels of deep processing strategies. When integrating the three components of learning, five motivational-learning profiles could be retrieved. For the learning strategies component in these profiles there is little variation in quality: the mean scores are either relatively high, moderate or low. In other words, homogeneous subgroups of learners can only be discerned in the quantity of learning strategies used. A distinction in quality however, was made for the motivational component in these integrated profiles.
Results showed that patterns found in this study are very similar to motivational-learning profiles identified among primary school students (Heirweg et al., 2019). Previous longitudinal person-oriented studies suggested that the high-quantity learning profiles have the potential to further evolve into good-quality profiles by gaining more learning experiences (e.g., Vanthournout et al., 2009). This developmental hypothesis may hold true for low-educated adults who often did not have had a trouble-free prior educational trajectory and where further development in good-quality learning strategies and motivation is possible.

References
Alexander, P.A. (2017). Issues of Constructs, Contexts, and Continuity: Commentary on Learning in Higher Education. Educational Psychology Review, 29(2), 345–351.
Akogul, S., & Erisoglu, M. (2017). An Approach for Determining the Number of clusters in a Model-Based Cluster Analysis. Entropy, 19(9), 452.
Cents-Boonstra, M., Lichtwarck-Aschoff, A., Denessen, E., Haerens, L., & Aelterman, N. (2019). Identifying motivational profiles among VET students: differences in self-efficacy, test anxiety and perceived motivating teaching. Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 71(4), 600–622.
Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (2000). The “what” and “why” of goal pursuits: Human needs and the self-determination of behavior. Psychological Inquiry, 11(4), 227–268.
Donche, V., Van Petegem, P., Van de Mosselaer, H., & Vermunt, J. (2010). LEMO: een instrument voor feedback over leren en motivatie. Plantyn: Mechelen.
European Commission (2001) Making a European Area of Lifelong Learning a Reality. European Commission COM 678 final. Available at: http://aei.pitt.edu/42878/1/com2001_0678.pdf (accessed January 30, 2024).
European Commission (2016) on Upskilling Pathways: New Opportunities for Adults (2016/C 484/01). Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=OJ:JOC_2016_484_R_0001 (accessed January 30, 2024)
European Commission (2019) Directorate-General for Education, Youth, Sport and Culture, Key competences for lifelong learning, Publications Office (2019) https://data.europa.eu/doi/10.2766/569540 (accessed January 30, 2024)
Heirweg, S., De Smul, M., Devos, G., & Van Keer, H. (2019). Profiling upper primary school students’ self-regulated learning through self-report questionnaires and think-aloud protocol analysis. Learning and Individual Differences, 70, 1555-168.
Lüftenegger, M., Schober, B., Van de Schoot, R., Wagner, P., Finsterwald, M., & Spiel, C. (2012). Lifelong Learning as a goal - do autonomy and self-regulation in school result in well prepared pupils? Learning and Instruction, 22, 27-36.
Shum, A., Fryer, L.K., Vermunt, J.D., Ajisuksmo, C., Cano, F., Donche, V., Law, D.C.S., Martínez-Fernández, J.R., Van Petegem, P., & Yu, J. (2023). Variable- and Person-centred meta-re-analyses of university students' learning strategies from a cross-cultural perspective. Higher Education.
Spurk, D., Hirschi, A., Wang, M., Valero, D., & Kauffeld, S. (2020). Latent profile analysis: A review and “how to” guide of its application within vocational behavior research. Journal of Vocational behavior, 120, Article 103445.
Vanthournout, G., Donche, V., Gijbels, D., & Van Petegem, P. (2009). Alternative data-analysis techniques in research on student learning: Illustrations of a person-oriented and developmental perspectives. Reflecting education, 5(2), 35-51.
Vermunt, J. D., & Donche, V. (2017). A Learning Patterns Perspective on Student Learning in Higher Education: State of the Art and Moving Forward. Educational Psychology Review, 29(2), 269–299.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Differentiated Spaces- Negotiations of racialized Belonging and Inclusion in a Danish high school

Iram Khawaja

Aarhus University, Denmark

Presenting Author: Khawaja, Iram

When you enter the Southsea high school, you enter an open area called the “lounge”. The lounge is a place you pass through, but it also serves as a place to hang out, meet other students and to take a break and rest in the comfort of the sofas. Everybody knows and notices that the lounge is primarily populated by the racialized minoritized students. The white students hang out in the canteen. This resonates with Beverly Daniel Tatum’s classic and poignant question ‘Why are all the Black Kids sitting together in the cafeteria?’ (Tatum 1997). In this paper I wish to follow another but related question, investigating the internal logics and negotiations of the majoritized white students and the minoritized racialized students in how they make sense of the ways in which they can take up space in the high school - and in society in general.

I conceptualize racialization as an affective process (Ahmed 2012, Zembylas 2015, Manning 2023) of differentiation (Deleuze 1990, Massumi 2009) to understand the affective, spatial and embodied experience of standing out, blending in or passing as a racialized Other. Educational contexts and inclusion are seen as connected to how spaces are able to embody some bodies and not others as naturally belonging (Puwar 2004, Ahmed 2012).

Based on group interviews utilizing the creative methodology of identity mapping (Futch & Fine 2014, Jaffe-Walter & Khawaja 2022) with students from both the lounge and the canteen, I ask how they negotiate their sense of embodied and spatialized belonging in relation to each other and the spaces they can inhabit.

The analysis shows how the students are actively engaged in creating inclusive spaces for themselves within and beyond the high school in a political and societal backdrop where high schools with high numbers of racialized minoritized students are seen as “ghetto schools” and problematized as less successful schools in terms of achieving integration and social cohesion. This paper sheds light on how the students themselves negotiate a sense of social cohesion and community and how it links to their sense of belonging in school and, more generally, in society.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
Based on group interviews utilizing the creative methodology of identity mapping (Futch & Fine 2014, Jaffe-Walter & Khawaja 2022) with students from both the lounge and the canteen, I ask how they negotiate their sense of embodied and spatialized belonging in relation to each other and the spaces they can inhabit. Identity mapping invites the subject into a space of active, projective and visual imaginary – imagining oneself in different spaces and relations. The students have a blank piece of paper and different coloured markers in front of them and are asked to draw and visualise spaces and relations they relate to and feel they belong in/with.
The paper shows how this method especially is suitable to capture the embodied and affective experiences of (non)belonging, sense of inclusion and racialization.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
The paper sheds light on how both ethnic minoritized and majoritized students reflect on and negotiate their sense of belonging in the high school context - bringing a youth centered perspective on an issue that most often is problematized by school leaders and policy makers in regard to a concern of segregation, lack of integration and inclusion in schools. This paper shows how, what might seem as segregation, in fact is about creating a sense of social cohesion and community amongst the students. This links to the students ways of negotiating a sense of belonging in school and, more generally, in society.
References
Ahmed, S. (2012) On being included- Racism and diversity in institutional life, London, Duke University Press.
Deleuze, G. (1990) Negotiations. New York, Columbia University Press
Futch, V. A., & Fine, M. (2014). Mapping as a method: History and theoretical commitments. Qualitative Research in Psychology 11(1), 42–59. https://doi.org/10.1080/14780887.2012.719070
Jaffe-Walter, R., & Khawaja, I. (2022). “Why Do I Live Here?”: Using Identity Mapping to Explore Embodied Experiences of Racialization . In (Re)Mapping Migration and Education: Centering Methods and Methodologies (pp. 112-133). Brill.
Manning, E. (2023) The being of relation, eFlux journal, Issue #135, April 2023, retrieved May 2023 https://www.e-flux.com/journal/135/529855/the-being-of-relation/
Massumi, B. (2009) Micropolitics : Exploring Ethico-Aesthetics. Inflexions: A Journal for Research-Creation. No. 3. October 2009. www.inflexions.org
Puwar, N. (2004). Space invaders: Race, gender and bodies out of place. Oxford and New York, NY: Berg Publishers.
Tatum, B. D. (1997). "Why are all the black kids sitting together in the cafeteria?" Basic Books/Hachette Book Group.
Zembylas, M. (2015) Rethinking race and racism as technologies of affect: theorizing the implications for anti-racist politics and practice in education, Race Ethnicity and Education, 18:2, 145-162, DOI: 10.1080/13613324.2014.946492


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Exploring the Education of Newly Immigrated Students: A Qualitative Study on Organizational Approaches and Challenges in German Secondary Schools

Hosay Adina-Safi

University of Hamburg, Germany

Presenting Author: Adina-Safi, Hosay

The intersection of education and immigration presents a multifaceted and dynamic landscape that significantly influences both individuals and societies. Schools serve as essential platforms, equipping immigrant students with the necessary linguistic, cultural, and academic skills. They play a crucial role in shaping a sense of belonging and civic engagement among immigrant youth. Despite these benefits, challenges such as language barriers and socio-economic disparities persist. Recognizing these challenges, inclusive educational policies are imperative to address the diverse needs of immigrant populations. Research into the impact of immigration on school systems is crucial for developing effective strategies and ensuring equitable educational opportunities for all. As global migration trends persist, understanding the interplay between schools and immigration is essential for building inclusive and culturally rich societies.

Within the framework of this research project, the school organizational practices related to the establishment of preparatory measures for newly immigrated students and their transition into regular classes in secondary education are examined. Concerning the development of schools and school culture, the study delves into questions regarding the extent to which the establishment of preparatory classes for newly immigrated children and adolescents entails structural changes towards intercultural openness in the school. It also investigates whether a school with already implemented measures for intercultural school development shows different ways of organizing the education of newly immigrated students. Factors such as the criteria underlying past decisions on organizing the education of newly immigrated students are considered, and the possible explanations for differing processes and routines in the school are explored (Herrmann 2017). This includes examining the orientation patterns and positionalities of school management and teachers regarding migration-related heterogeneity and diversity in general.

This research project also aims to investigate how teachers perceive dealing with diversity as a professional task. Secondly, it explores how appropriate conditions for this task can be achieved (Tillmann 2017). Understanding diversity as a pedagogical opportunity and enrichment as advocated by Trautmann and Wischer (2011) is a pedagogical attitude that has not yet been embraced by a majority of teachers (Solzbacher 2008).


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
The research adopts a qualitative exploratory approach, as the literature review revealed a lack of studies connecting the question of schooling models to fundamental issues of (intercultural) school development. Additionally, insights into the developed practices and routines at schools from the perspective of the stakeholders are lacking. Addressing this gap allows for mapping the characteristic features of pedagogical practice in this field and distinguishing specific questions related to the establishment and teaching in preparatory classes from those concerning school development and school culture more generally. Six schools, differing in their experience with classes for newly immigrated students and in terms of school type (Gymnasium and Stadtteilschule in Hamburg), were selected for interviews. Each school was represented by one person at the school leadership level such as the principal, one responsible teacher for the coordination of preparatory classes, and one teacher mainly involved in teaching preparatory classes.


Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
The interviews were analyzed using qualitative content analysis following Kuckartz (2018). Of particular interest was how schools addressed organizational challenges, the significance of school climate/school culture in this context, and in which areas there was room for improvement. Different typologies are expected to emerge, serving as a framework for further work in this area and for practical guidance in schools. The results are embedded within the framework of the trilemmatic inclusion theory (Boger 2017). The findings of this study contribute valuable insights to understanding how the trilemmatic inclusion theory operates in the context of education and immigration. By examining the interplay between these factors, I aim to provide a theoretical foundation for designing inclusive policies and practices that cater to the diverse needs of immigrant students, fostering a more comprehensive and effective approach to their educational journey.
References
Boger Mai-Anh (2017): Theorien der Inklusion – eine Übersicht. Zeitschrift für Inklusion Online 1. https://www.inklusion-online.net/index.php/inklusion-online/article/view/413/317.
Herrmann, Joachim (2017): Discussion failed! Hinweise an die deutschsprachige Schulentwicklungsdiskussion zu „failing schools“ aus einer Hamburger Perspektive. In: Manitius, Veronika/ Dobbelstein, Peter (Hrsg.): Schulentwicklungsarbeit in herausfordernden Lagen. Waxmann, Münster, S. 240-265.
Kuckartz, Udo (2018): Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse. Methoden, Praxis, Cpmputerunterstützung. 4. Auflage, Beltz Juventa, Weinheim.
Solzbacher, Claudia (2008): Positionen von Lehrerinnen und Lehrern zur individuellen Förderung in der Sekundarstufe I – Ergebnisse einer empirischen Untersuchung. In: Kunze, Ingrid/ Solzbacher, Claudia (Hrsg.): Individuelle Förderung in der Sekundarstufe I und II. Schneider Verlag Hohengehren, Baltmannsweiler, S. 27-42.
Tillmann, Klaus-Jürgen (2017): Heterogenität – Ein Grundproblem der Schul- und Unterrichtsentwicklung. In: Paseka, Angelika et al. (Hrsg.): Schulentwicklung zwischen Steuerung und Autonomie. Beiträge aus der Aktions-, Schulentwicklungs- und Governance-Forschung. Waxmann, Münster, S. 71-83.
Trautmann, Matthias/ Wischer, Beate (2011): Heterogenität in der Schule. Eine kritische Einführung. VS Verlag, Wiesbaden.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Behind Bars and Beyond: Milestones and Important Events in Life Stories from Prison Education in Ireland and Greece

Angeliki Lima

University College Dublin, Ireland

Presenting Author: Lima, Angeliki

This presentation delves into the life stories of individuals engaged in education within the context of prison life, focusing on experiences in both Ireland and Greece. Positioned within a broader project on the lived experience of prison education, this research draws theoretical inspiration from key concepts in recognition theory, identity formation, and critical adult education, rooted in the works of Axel Honneth (1996, 2003, 2012) and Paulo Freire (2000, 2005).

By interweaving these foundational theories, the overarching aim was to critically examine the multifaceted aspects of identity formation and the relationships created in the unique environment of prison education. Of particular interest is the lasting impact of these dynamics on individuals post-release. The theories of recognition and identity formation offer valuable insights into the development of self-awareness and the negotiation of identities within the prison education setting. Furthermore, critical adult education theories bring into sharp focus transformative learning, agency, and praxis, by viewing education as a means to address social inequalities and take action for social justice.

The central research question guiding this exploration is:

What are the significant events and milestones identified by individuals participating in prison education as learners in their narratives?

This question is approached through the lenses of recognition and transformation, employing the theories above to deepen our understanding of the complex interplay within the prison education environment.

Considering that all participants in both countries were early school leavers, examining key factors influencing early school leaving within the Irish context is essential. According to Tusla – the Child and Family Agency in Ireland (2007), some of these factors include:

a) Sense of belonging: Students who feel alienated and have reduced participation in school are more likely to drop out,

b) Attitude toward school: Beliefs and attitudes that students hold toward school significantly impact their likelihood of dropping out, more specifically, factors such as locus of control (feeling in control of one's actions and outcomes) and motivation to achieve are crucial predictors of dropout rates.

And c) Stressful life events: Increased levels of stress and the presence of stressors, such as financial difficulty, health problems, or early parenthood, can be associated with higher rates of early school leaving. These challenges can negatively impact a student's ability to cope with school demands, leading to disengagement.

Indeed, all these factors emerged in the participants’ narratives when reflecting on important events and milestones surrounding their re-engagement in education while serving their time.

Overall, this presentation contributes to the growing discourse on social justice and intercultural education by shedding light on the nuanced experiences of individuals in prison education, by presenting their voice and their stories the way they narrated them and providing insights on education for social justice.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
To explore these questions, a narrative inquiry approach was employed, conducting 14 life-story interviews in both Ireland and Greece. The participants were individuals who had spent time in prison and had re-engaged in education while incarcerated. All participants were post-release, with varying durations after release, ranging from a few weeks to more than 10 years. This diversity in post-release periods provided valuable insights into the various ways individuals acted on their educational outcomes.

Thematic analysis and elements of the voice relational approach were employed in the analysis. For the narrative thematic analysis, the basis was formed by the work of narrative analysis scholars, such as Riessman (1993, 2008), Clandinin and Connelly (2000), and for the voice relational approach the framework relied on Clough, Goodley, Lawthom and Moore (2004).

The use of life stories as a research tool will be explored and examined, emphasising its effectiveness in capturing the intricate and nuanced experiences of the participants. Issues that bring into focus positionality and reflexivity are also discussed. This discussion will also address pertinent issues related to positionality and reflexivity, shedding light on the researcher's stance and self-awareness in the process.

It is important to note that the study does not aim to directly compare systems and institutions. Instead, it embraces a culturally sensitive approach. Consequently, insights into differences within the systems and structures of both countries emerged organically, only when necessary and prompted by the participants' narratives. The primary focus of this research is the stories and life trajectories of the individuals who participated in the fieldwork.

By adopting a narrative approach, the study acknowledged the importance of stories in
human thinking, meaning-making, and identity construction. Narrative inquiry was chosen
as the most suitable method to capture and analyse the personal lived experiences of
individuals who had experienced incarceration.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
The analysis revealed key themes, highlighting the significance of moments of recognition within educational encounters, as well as the process of self-transformation by emphasising agency and empowerment, and the influential role of significant others throughout the educational journey.

This presentation focuses on one of the main themes that emerged from the analysis—this is the Milestones and Important Events in the participants' life trajectories. More specifically, within the prison system, the pursuit of education unfolds through narratives that reveal a series of turning points and milestones profoundly influencing participants' educational journeys. These pivotal moments play a critical role in shaping their perspectives on learning and sense of self, representing significant experiences where participants recognise their importance and the changes they bring to their life journeys.

Within this theme of Milestones and Important Events, two subthemes are analysed. More specifically these subthemes include, firstly, the re-engagement in education and the transformative moment when motivation becomes genuine and sustainable. Secondly, there is an exploration of a different way to exist in the world, allowing participants to reclaim their educational potential. In addition to the exploration of this theme and subthemes, the conclusions link the findings to policy recommendations for adult education in prison.

These experiences of the participants align with the principles of critical adult education, emphasising the importance of recognising adult learners as complete beings with valued previous experiences and viewing education as an act of love and empowerment (Freire, 2000). By valuing individuals' identities and perspectives, liberating education nurtures a transformative educational encounter where learners and educators collaborate in shaping the world through knowledge, understanding, and mutual respect.

References
Clandinin, D. J., & Connelly, F. M. (2000). Narrative inquiry: Experience and story in
qualitative research. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Clough, P., Goodley, D., Lawthom, R., & Moore, M. (2004). Researching Life Stories:
Method, Theory and Analyses in a Biographical Age (1st ed.). Routledge

Freire, P. (2000). Pedagogy of the oppressed. (30th Anniversary edition). New York:
Continuum

Freire, P. (2005). Education for critical consciousness. New York: Continuum.

Honneth, A. (1996). The Struggle for Recognition: The Moral Grammar of Social Conflicts. Cambridge: The MIT Press.

Honneth, A. (2003). Redistribution as recognition: A response to Nancy Fraser. In N.
Fraser & A. Honneth, Redistribution or Recognition: A Political-Philosophical Exchange, 110-197. New York: Verso.

Honneth, A. (2012). The I in we studies in theory recognition. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Riessman, C. K. (1993). Narrative Analysis (Qualitative Research Methods) (1st ed.).
SAGE Publications, Inc.

Riessman, C.K. (2008). Narrative methods for the human sciences. Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage.

Tusla - Child and Family Agency (Ireland). (2007). The School Completion Programme: Guidelines on Identifying Young People at Risk of Early School Leaving. Dublin.
 
13:45 - 15:1507 SES 11 B: Multicultural and Socially Equitable Learning Environments: Ethos, trust and social mobility
Location: Room 117 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [Floor 1]
Session Chair: Ghazala Bhatti
Paper Session
 
07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Opportunities for Social Mobility of Pupils in the Private Pedagogical Theories of Early Childhood Education Teachers

Dorota Duda

University of Lower Silesia, Poland

Presenting Author: Duda, Dorota

The objective of this presentation is to discuss the results of a research project on early childhood education teachers’ awareness of social classes and its consequences for their views on education, and in particular on the possibilities for pupils to change their social position.

Although there are attempts to talk about the death of classes (Mikiewicz, 2014: 43), the topic of class inequality is still relevant and debated, and educational inequalities are not decreasing (Blandford, 2017; Eribon, 2019; Kulz, 2017; McGarvey, 2017; Reay, 2017).

Bourdieu and Passeron's theory of socio-cultural reproduction speaks of the reproduction of the social class by the school system. Related to this is the division into inheritors, i.e. children from the upper classes who possess the qualities that the school system values, and les miracules, children from the lower classes who, despite objectively difficult conditions, experience social mobility (Kłoskowska, 2006: 25). This division is related to two modes of cultural acquisition: total learning and methodological learning. Total learning begins with primary socialisation and is followed up within schooling; in other words, it is early and imperceptible to the child. Methodological learning takes place as part of secondary socialisation and schooling. It is characteristic of pupils with a low-class background and is associated with uncertainty and difficulties in acquiring cultural competence, among other things required by teachers. In addition, pupils with a lower-class background have to deculturate, which is, de facto class eradication or liberation from what has been acquired during primary socialisation and is considered inappropriate by the school system (Bourdieu, 1984: 66-68).

Pupils entering school have different inherited capitals, yet the school does not seem to take this into account and treats pupils as if they all had the same starting position. As a result, children's knowledge and experiences other than those desired by the school are excluded (Grochalska, 2009: 63). According to Szkudlarek, pupils who have undergone total learning find it easier to find their way around the school requirements and use what they have already been equipped with at home (Szkudlarek, 2007: 35).

The different class backgrounds of pupils, and the different ways of acquiring culture, while promoting the culture of the privileged classes and excluding what is incompatible with it within the school system, leads to the differentiation of an individual's educational and life chances already at the earliest stages of education. By making the educational establishment culturally unfamiliar and inaccessible to pupils of low-class backgrounds, the school system, of which teachers are a part, contributes to the self-exclusion of pupils from the path leading to a change in life trajectory. At the same time, the neoliberal narrative seems to overlook the objective difficulties faced by pupils from underprivileged classes. Instead, it speaks of poverty of aspiration, laziness, and parental responsibility for the (poor) choices of educational institutions for their children (Hursh, 2014).

My aim was to explore early childhood education teachers’ openness to the pupils’ social mobility, their awareness of class differences and social inequalities, and ideas for overcoming them. Teachers, along with pupils' resistance (Giroux, 2018), academic resilience (Smulczyk, 2019), and happy coincidences (Mikiewicz, Sadownik, 2014), are the factor that has a major impact on potential changes to pupils’ life situations. In my presentation, I will provide a preliminary typology of teachers' pedagogical convictions that contribute to either social reproduction or changes to pupils' social position.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
The empirical material that this presentation draws on comes from a research project in which I explored whether ECE teachers are aware of the existence of class divisions and whether this (un)awareness is visible in their work with pupils. 14 ECE teachers of varying seniority working in the Polish education system took part in the study. The teachers differed in terms of the geographical location of their schools (eight of them worked in large cities, two – in small towns, and four – in rural areas) and their experience with working in a class-diverse environment. Among those in large cities, teachers worked: in a school in a neighbourhood with a bad reputation (1); perceived to be affluent (4); in a socially diverse environment (2); both in a neighbourhood with a so-called bad reputation and also in a private school in a neighbourhood with an affluent location (1). Interviewees from small towns and villages had worked in areas with high economic deprivation (1), in a place that formed an enclave by being a private institution for parents with high economic capital (1) and in places that were so-called urban bedroom communities (2). Two did not define the location of their schools in social terms.
I used the grounded theory methodology (Charmaz, 2009) and a bricolage of interpretive approaches in the research project (Kvale, 2012).  The narrative and semi-structured interviews were used to collect data. The opening question during the narrative interview was about family relationships, especially from childhood and educational experiences up to the time the interviewee entered university. The semi-structured interview questions focused on four areas: the teacher's workplace, the teacher's vision of the child, the perception of pupils' educational opportunities, and social inequalities. Most of the interviews were conducted in two sessions, one for the narrative part, and the other for semi-structured. They lasted from 45 minutes to 2 hours. All interviews were recorded and transcribed. The responses were coded inductively; the analysis itself was divided into two stages: the identification of teachers' awareness of social class and the analysis of teachers' private pedagogical theories, resulting in a middle-range theory of a preliminary typology of teachers' private pedagogical theories of the possibilities for pupils to change their social trajectories.
The research was carried out in line with the principles of ethical research conduct, with consent obtained from all participants.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
I aimed to establish whether ECE teachers identify the social inequalities experienced by pupils, caused by their families’ insufficient economic capital as well as the low level of cultural capital. My second aim was to analyze whether the social (un)awareness of social classes affects teachers’ attitudes towards their pupils. First of all, most of my interviews had an intuitive perception of the social class concept, but the class narrative was very limited.
Based on the data collected, I distinguished two types of private pedagogical theories of the teachers who participated in my research. The first has emancipatory potential, while the second has adaptive character. Within the types of identified theories, I also distinguished a number of subtypes. Only two teachers’ narratives demonstrated the potential to change the social position of students, and among these, one theory was action-oriented, and the other one was reflection-oriented. Twelve teachers’ narratives had adaptive character. Among those, I distinguished six subtypes: of colonising helplessness character (4), soaking into the structure of the institution (2), upholding the social order (2), escaping the system (2), being in the service of the neoliberal narrative (1) and making educational change without social change (1). I distinguish one more private pedagogical theory, one which has critical potential but has not emerged during my research. This theory is present in literature (Blandford, 2017; McLaren, 2015; Reay, 2017).
The results indicate that there might be little or no opportunity for pupils with low-class backgrounds to change their educational and social trajectories. While being one of the factors that can support pupils in making such change, the teachers in my research emerge as the guards of the social order with its social structure.

References
Blandford, S. (2017). Born to fail? Social mobility: A working class view. John Catt Educational Ltd.
Bourdieu, P. (1984). Distinction. A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste. Harvard University Press.
Charmaz, K. (2009). Teoria ugruntowana. Praktyczny przewodnik po analizie jakościowej. Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN.
Eribon, D. (2019). Powrót do Reims. Karakter
Giroux, H. A. (2018). Reprodukcja. Opór i akomodacja. In: H. A. Giroux, L. Witkowski (ed.), Edukacja i sfera publiczna. Idee i doświadczenia pedagogiki radykalnej (p. 111–147). Impuls.
Grochalska, M. (2009). Między pożądaną równością a nieuniknioną różnicą. In: A. Męczkowska-Christiansen, P. Mikiewicz (ed.), Idee—Diagnozy—Nadzieje. Szkoła polska a idee równości (p. 61–80). Wydawnictwo Naukowe Dolnośląskiej Szkoły Wyższej.
Hursh, D. (2014). Market Ideologies and the Undermining of Democracy, Education, and Equality. In: J. Hall (ed.), Underprivileged School Children and the Assault on Dignity (p. 97– 109). Routledge.
Kłoskowska, A. (2006). Teoria socjologiczna Pierre’a Bourdieu. Wstęp do wydania polskiego. In: P. Bourdieu, J.-C. Passeron, Reprodukcja. Elementy teorii systemu nauczania (p. 11–52). Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN.
Kulz, C. (2017). Factories for learning. Making race, class and inequality in the neoliberal academy. Manchester University Press.
Kvale, S. (2012). Prowadzenie wywiadów. Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN.
McGarvey, D. (2017). Poverty safari: Understanding the anger of Britain’s underclass. Luath Press Limited.
McLaren, P. (2015). Życie w szkołach. Wprowadzenie do pedagogiki krytycznej. Wydawnictwo Naukowe Dolnośląskiej Szkoły Wyższej.
Mikiewicz, P. (2014). Kapitał społeczny i edukacja. Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN.
Mikiewicz, P., Sadownik, A. (2014). Szczęśliwy traf. Edukacja w procesie adaptacji migrantów z Polski w Wielkiej Brytanii. Wydawnictwo Naukowe Dolnośląskiej Szkoły Wyższej.
Reay, D. (2017). Miseducation. Inequality, education and the working classes. Policy Press.
Smulczyk, M. (2019). Przezwyciężenie statusowej determinacji karier szkolnych. Wydawnictwa Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego.
Szkudlarek, T. (2007). Edukacja i konstruowanie społecznych nierówności. In: J. Klebaniuk (ed.), Fenomen nierówności społecznych. Nierówności społeczne w refleksji humanistycznej (p. 31–52). ENETEIA Wydawnictwo Psychologii i Kultury.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Let’s Talk About the Elephant in the Room: Good Intentions!

Patricia Briscoe

Niagara University, Canada

Presenting Author: Briscoe, Patricia

Benevolence is driven by an innate human behaviour giving hope to others. People respond to many tragedies with compassion, often stepping up to help others in different ways—assisting others, donating funds, or giving their time. Over the past decade, global charity, and humanitarian efforts to help others have been staggering. According to the Charities Aid Foundation, World Giving Index (2024), in 2022, Americans, the leading global donors, gave $499.3 billion to charity. These statistics, however, exclude unregistered, not-for-profit, or non-profit organizations and the small-scale charitable acts performed by individuals or groups.

Despite the substantial financial resources and good intentions, increasing evidence suggests that advancement for individuals experiencing severe financial instability has yet to show consistent progress. Lupton (2011, 2015) argues that while people are very generous in charitable giving, much of their money is wasted or harms the people it is targeted to help. While the intention behind charitable giving and acts of kindness seems noble, its impact on broader societal improvement still needs to be investigated. Furthermore, there is a risk of perpetuating adverse outcomes, inadvertently turning good intentions into bad. Chang (2008) refers to these well-meaning but potentially harmful groups as "bad Samaritans" (p.19) who unconsciously support neo-liberal colonizer/colonizing dichotomies and are more generally defined as "helping behaviours from developed countries" (Pinazo et at., 2010, p. 393).

This study was grounded in Niehaus's (2020) theory of good intentions, stating that "altruists' effectiveness often falls short of their intentions" (p.1). This research tested this theory based on the above arguments and the researcher's extensive work in a developing country that receives much small-scale charity. This research explored the behaviours, motivations, and initiatives of these good-intentioned, small-scale individuals and groups, assessing the perceived impact of their endeavours.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
A case study research method was chosen because of the qualitative methods of combining extensive personal experience with investigating individuals and groups of people in a localized area. (Yin, 2018). The terms unauthorized non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and charity groups were deliberately chosen to represent smaller-scale altruistic entities, distinct from the more prominent, authorized NGOs like the United Nations or Red Cross.
Participant selection initially targeted a few known individuals and then employed the snowball technique. Criteria for participation included: i) involvement in charitable actions within the area over the past decade (2013-2023) and ii) not being affiliated with an NGO or registered charity group. Ten participants were interviewed, conducted both virtually and face-to-face in three months. The interview questions were designed to target participant demographics, how and why they started their charitable work in the area, the motivations behind their actions, the nature of their charitable acts, and their perceived impact. Following Yin's approach (2018) to data analysis, the data was examined and categorized. The primary focus was identifying recurring themes from participants' reflections and personal insights to offer empirically grounded conclusions.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
The findings of this case study confirmed Niehaus's (2020) theory of good intentions, highlighting the frequent failure to achieve the intended goal of assisting others, often resulting in the giver feeling more fulfilled than the receiver. Additionally, the responses of most participants aligned with similar studies, indicating that well-intentioned individuals and their actions supported neoliberal helping imperatives (O'Sullivan & Smaller, 2023) and perpetuated dominant colonial ideologies. While these acts may offer short-term hope, they have unintended consequences. Reflecting on these findings and my work with marginalized people striving for a better future, I concluded that many well-intentioned efforts require more intentional purpose and direction for positive effectiveness and more sustainable and decolonizing change. Also, they are often driven by individuals unknowingly supporting dominant neoliberal agendas.

Overall, good intentions lack sustainability and the development of the receivers' human skills to advance the betterment of their lives, often causing more harm than good. Rather than fostering economically self-reliant citizens and societies, these actions foster reliance on external aid, perpetuating colonization. The culmination of these findings underscores the urgent need for action: a call for all individuals engaging in well-intentioned behaviours to critically reflect on their beliefs, values, and actions to support shifts of consciousness (Gorski, 2008) and develop the capacity to identify any colonizing implications of their good intentions. This approach aligns with the principles of transformative learning (Mezirow, 2000, 2006) and transformative leadership (Shields, 2013). Extending this approach beyond educational boundaries is critical because of the growing global population of small-scale, well-intentioned charity groups and individuals.

References
Chang, H. J. (2008). Bad Samaritans: The guilty secrets of rich nations and the threat to global prosperity. Random House.

Charities Aid Foundation. (2022). World giving index: A global view of giving trends. https://www.cafonline.org/docs/default-source/about-us-research/caf_world_giving_index_2022_210922-final.pdf

Gorski. P. G.  (2008) Good intentions are not enough: a decolonizing intercultural education, Intercultural Education, 19:6, 515-525, DOI:10.1080/14675980802568319
 
Lupton, R. D. (2011). Toxic charity: How churches and charities hurt those they help (and how to reverse it). HarperOne.

Lupton, R. D. (2015). Charity detox: What charity would look like if we cared about results (First edition.). HarperOne.

Mezirow, J. (2000). Learning as transformation: Critical perspectives on a theory in progress. Jossey Bass.

Mezirow, J. (2006) An overview of transformative learning. In P. Sutherland & J. Crowther (Eds.), Lifelong learning: Concepts and contexts (pp. 24–38). Routledge.

Niehaus, P. (2014). A theory of good intentions. San Diego, CA: University of California and Cambridge, MA: NBER, 111.

Pinazo, D., Peris, R., & Gámez, M.-J. (2010). Lay beliefs about developing countries in relation to helping behaviors. The Journal of Social Psychology, 150(4), 393–415. https://doi.org/10.1080/00224540903366685

Shields, C. M. (2013). Transformative leadership in education: Equitable change in an uncertain and complex world. Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group.

Yin, R. K. (2018). Case study research and applications: design and methods (Sixth edition.). SAGE.
 
17:30 - 19:0007 SES 13 B: Multilingualism in Education
Location: Room 117 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [Floor 1]
Session Chair: Eunice Macedo
Paper Session
 
07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Religious Language, Secular Language?: Tracing Intersections, Exclusions, and Uncertainties in Diverse Language Learning Contexts in Luxembourg

Anastasia Badder

University of Cambridge, United Kingdom

Presenting Author: Badder, Anastasia

It is widely accepted within anthropology, education, sociolinguistics and beyond, that language learning as a process happens across contexts, as students participate in multiple complex learning systems and make connections through and across these. Ignoring these connections has consequences for pedagogy, classroom experience, and learning outcomes. A wide range of powerful research examines language learning across home, school, and other contexts and highlights what is lost when teachers overlook students’ language and literacy learning experiences in different contexts (cf. Bronkhorst & Akkerman 2016).

However, there remains a dearth of research detailing the specific ways secular and religious language and literacy learning processes intersect. Some emerging research examines the learning of a single language (Avni 2014; Rosowsky 2016), while other work illustrates multiple language learning processes within highly observant communities wherein religion frames all language learning (cf. Fader 2009). Yet studies of language learning complexities, challenges, and exclusions experienced by religiously minoritized students attending both secular schools and religious afterschool programs (as the majority do in many traditions, cf. Pomson 2010) remain rare (Meyer 2016; Badder 2022 are some exceptions).

I suggest that uncertainty about the place of religion in our contemporary, conflict-laden moment, narrow understandings of secularism, and misunderstandings of the value, use, and meaning of religious language and literacy have led scholars to silo religious language to religious spaces and to view any appearance of religious language practices outside of those spaces as a problem, if not a direct threat, to secular education (cf. Dallavis 2011; Sarroub 2002). In the process, as Skerrett (2013) powerfully argues, myriad continuities and opportunities for effective and meaningful learning are being missed, to the detriment of students and scholarship. Indeed, in ‘secular’ spaces, religious understandings and viewpoints get articulated, very often in ways that do not align with or directly contradict their manifestations in the lives of religious communities (Badder 2024).

My research aims to investigate the intersections of literacy ideologies and language learning experiences encountered by religious students enrolled in secular schools in Europe across the contexts of their everyday lives. Specifically, I zoom in on a Jewish community in Luxembourg, where French and Biblical Hebrew language and literacy are brought into contact and conversation in complex ways that subvert expectations for religious and secular language use and boundaries.

This cohort presents an interesting case for three reasons. First, the Luxembourgish state has recently been working to secularize, including detaching itself from connections with religious communities and removing religion from the public realm. Second, French holds an awkward space in Luxembourg. Historically a language of prestige, it is tightly interwoven with ideologies of laicité and rationality and echoes of colonial memories. French is also the last official language taught in the state school curriculum and graduates from the Luxembourgish system often report feeling less competent in French. Additionally, existing research shows that teachers cite having French (or another Romance language) as a reason that students are unable to access the university education track (Horner & Weber 2008). Third, the Jewish community at the heart of this research has simultaneously experienced its own rapid internal changes. As members grapple with these changes and their implications, they are experiencing new forms of uncertainty about their community, its history and future. In response, French has emerged as a point around which they seek to cohere as a community.

This paper therefore explores how students in a Luxembourgish Jewish congregational school program make sense of the ways French and Hebrew overlap, zooming in on how such connections shape student understandings and experiences of Hebrew, themselves as Hebrew users, as Jews, and as students in secular schools.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
The questions I am asking and the theoretical frames on which I draw in my research have certain implications for my methods and methodology.   First, I am interested in processes; second, my questions involve the details, actions, and interactions of everyday life; and third, in order to address these issues, I need to have access to these interactions as they unfold and as people work to make sense of those unfoldings.  To this end, my work is primarily ethnographic.  Ethnography and its methods, including participant observation, enable me to get beyond universals and consider the specificity of people’s everyday experiences while calling attention to “the political stakes that make up the ordinary” (Biehl 2013: 574).
The inspiration for my current project emerged in 2017 during a separate course of research.  In 2022, I returned to this project and began new focused fieldwork, which is ongoing.  In that time, I have been attending organized events at or organized by the synagogue community with whom I am working, such as services, lectures, memorials, etc.  Importantly, I have also been sitting in on the classes of this synagogue’s congregational school.  I have also been able to spend time with people in more informal settings, such as dinners at home and social gatherings.  In the coming months, I plan to continue this fieldwork, including conducting a series of interviews with families in the congregational school.

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
Based on my fieldwork to date, I am working through several big questions.  What does it mean that French, an apparently universalistic and ‘secular’ language with its own cultural imperatives and imperial histories is being taken up by and tracked onto this Jewish community in Luxembourg?  What does it mean that not only is French being taken up, but also framed in very similar ways to religious Hebrew?  What does it mean that the ways in which French is valued and the roles and import associated with it very clearly diverge from the ways it is valued and its import in secular spaces, especially schools?  And relatedly, what does it mean that there is a clear language policy operating in the congregational school classroom that creates hierarchies that are the inverse of those outside that classroom?  
By way of conclusion, I can tentatively offer the following: the students in this congregational school are keenly aware of the de facto language policies, hierarchies, and exclusions in their congregational and secular state schools and in many ways reinforce those through their discursive actions.  At the same time, however, they also find ways to undermine those policies and hierarchies through playful language use, translanguaging, making new linguistic connections, and reflecting thoughtfully about whether and how French and Hebrew are related.  Though the future remains uncertain for many of these students – indeed, some have already left Luxembourg for reasons attributed to issues of language and identity – they nonetheless continue to carve out novel and creative means through which to think through and value their linguistic capacities and identities.

References
Avni, Sharon. 2014. Hebrew education in the United States: historical perspectives and future
directions. Journal of Jewish Education 80 (3): 256-286.

Badder, Anastasia. 2024. When a yarmulke stands for all Jews: Navigating shifting signs from synagogue to school in Luxembourg. Contemporary Jewry. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12397-023-09524-8

Badder, Anastasia. 2022. ‘I just want you to get into the flow of reading’: Reframing Hebrew
proficiency as an enactment of liberal Jewishness. Language & Communication 87: 221-230.

Biehl, João. 2013. Ethnography in the way of theory. Cultural Anthropology 28 (4): 573-597.

Bronkhorst, Larike H & Sanne F. Akkerman. 2015. At the boundary of school: Continuity and
discontinuity in learning across contexts. Educational Research Review 19: 18-35.

Dallavis, Christian.  2011. “Because that’s who I am”: Extending theories of culturally responsive pedagogy to consider religious identity, belief, and practice. Multicultural Perspectives 13 ( 3): 138-144 .

Fader, Ayala. 2009. Mitzvah Girls: Bringing up the Next Generation of Hasidic Jews in Brooklyn. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Horner, Kristine & Jean-Jacques Weber. 2008. The language situation in Luxembourg. Current Issues in Language Planning 9 (1): 69-128.

Myers, Jo-Ann. 2016. Hebrew, the Living Breath of Jewish Existence: The Teaching and Learning
of Biblical and Modern Hebrew. DProf Thesis, Middlesex University.

Pomson, Alex. 2010. Context, Context, Context—The Special Challenges and Opportunities in
Congregational Education for Practitioners and Researchers. Journal of Jewish Education 76 (4):
285-288.

Rosowsky, Andrey. 2016. Heavenly Entextualisations: the acquisition and performance of classical religious texts. In Navigating Languages, Literacies and Identities: Religion in Young Lives, edited by V. Lytra, D. Volk, E. Gregory, 110-125. New York: Routledge.

Sarroub, Loukia K. 2002. In-betweenness: Religion and conflicting visions of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly 37: 130-148.

Skerrett, Allison. 2013. Religious Llteracies in a secular literacy classroom. Reading Research Quarterly 49 (2): 233-250.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Educator Perspectives on Openness and Interconnectedness: Orientations for Creating a Positive Climate for Diversity with Multilingual Students and Beyond

Kara Viesca1, Jenni Alisaari2, Svenja Hammer3, Svenja Lemmrich4, Annela Teemant5

1University of Nebraska, United States of America; 2University of Turku, Finland; 3Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Norway; 4Leuphana University, Germany; 5Indiana University Purdue University Indianapolis, USA

Presenting Author: Viesca, Kara

Building off of the work of Viesca et al. (2019), that important teacher knowledge and skills for working with multilingual learners fall into three major categories—context, orientations, and pedagogy—a multinational team of researchers has embarked on further exploring the orientations necessary for quality teaching and learning to occur with multilingual students. In Viesca et al. (forthcoming), this team operationalized five orientations, drawing from the empirical and theoretical research suggesting the orientations necessary for positive school and classroom climates for diversity. Since diversity in every possible aspect (e.g., language, race, class, gender, sexual orientation, religion, etc.) is a major feature of multilingual populations, embracing diversity and elevating it to create community and a sense of belonging is critical for the work of teaching multilingual students.

In 2022, the team conducted an exploratory qualitative study, holding interviews and focus groups with teachers in Finland, Norway, Germany, England, and the US to discuss orientations and how they can create a positive climate for diversity. We also asked for specific feedback on the orientations we had identified and defined (Viesca et al., forthcoming). We sought insights from myriad practitioners working in varied contexts (e.g., grade level, content area, country, etc.) to understand the perspectives different practitioners held to these orientations. In this study, we examine the interview data (n = 22) to reveal the perspectives and ideas shared by our research participants regarding the orientations of interconnectedness and openness.

We conceptualize interconnectedness as humanizing teaching and learning that produces belonging (Viesca et al., forthcoming). We view humanizing connections from one person to another, connecting the individual to the collective, as essential for co-constructing a positive diversity climate and creating great learning opportunities for multilingual learners. For this to be possible, relationships and practices must be purposeful for the community’s inherent diversity to be positively productive and thus capable of generating widespread, authentic belonging. To accomplish this, teaching/learning spaces must be deliberately developed to ensure individual self-actualization occurs in reciprocity and with accountability (Hayes & Kaba, 2023; Simpson, 2017). This way, personal self-actualization (grounded in self-determination and agency) ensures collective self-actualization through reciprocity and shared accountability. With interconnectedness, all forms of diversity can come into a relationship in positive and productive ways while co-creating authentic love and belonging at the individual and collective levels.

We operationalize openness as teaching and learning that embraces multiple knowledges with grace. To counter issues of power that are deeply entrenched in our society and communities, we propose a commitment to epistemic humility, or openness, which is necessary to co-construct a positive diversity climate. Such openness is grounded in an ongoing acknowledgment and investment in what one can and cannot know. This kind of openness also recognizes that there are multiple ways of knowing, and thus, no universal epistemology or ontology should be privileged over all others. Such humility counters various issues of supremacy that impact teaching and learning practices, policies, and spaces. It is also the openness necessary to adopt new ways of thinking upon receiving additional information. Educators practice openness in teaching/learning through critical self-reflection and an ongoing commitment to rethink and disrupt various messages, biases, and social norms we accept without question. Finally, the kind of openness necessary to co-construct a positive diversity climate is the openness that embraces and operates around a clear understanding of humans as flawed (Hayes & Kaba, 2023). This openness in application accepts and expects all human beings to exist and operate in imperfection, thus offering grace, acceptance, and understanding to both others and self in the face of conflicts, mistakes, and problems, as well as successes and celebrations.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
In this study, we ask:
•   How do practitioners discuss and contextualize the orientations of interconnectedness and openness in their practices?
•   What opportunities and challenges do participants identify to putting the orientations of interconnectedness and openness into practice?

We collected qualitative data from five nations (Finland, Norway, Germany, England, and the US) with practicing teachers (n = 22): 3 Finnish, 4 Norwegian, 7 German, 6 English, and 2 American educators. In this study we conducted problem-centered interviews (Witzel & Reiter, 2012) that have been employed to facilitate discursive-dialogic knowledge production between the interviewer and interviewees. The lead author was present at each of the data collection events as was 1-2 additional research team members. We recorded the interviews for later transcription and collected background information using a short questionnaire. The transcriptions were created focused on the words spoken in the interviews and focus group exchanges. Each conversation was held in English except the focus group in Germany, which was held in German. The interviews took in general around 60-90 minutes. We analyzed the data using the Gioia method (Gioia, Corley, & Hamilton, 2013). This approach combines open (first order) coding with theory-centric (second order) coding, based on grounded theory principles. We engaged in these analysis processes collaboratively with the lead author engaged in all conversations and data analysis efforts in collaboration with both team members present for data collection and at least 1-2 members who were not present. Therefore, the coding decisions and data analysis efforts were deeply collaborative and dialogic including all members of the research team as well as a consistent perspective offered by the lead author.
As an exploratory study, participants were largely found through snowball sampling and local relationships. We sought to recruit teachers to the study who could represent a variety of perspectives and life experiences. The teachers we talked to range from being relatively new to teaching (in their first few years) to highly experienced (in their last few years before retirement). We also talked with teachers from racially minoritized backgrounds in their local contexts, teachers who had moved to teach in their local context from another country, teachers who were monolingual in the local language, and those who were multilingual for various reasons.


Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
Preliminary results suggest a relationship between the two orientations of openness and interconnectedness. In our coding, instances of interconnectedness rarely occur without instances of openness and vice versa. Additionally, participants discuss these orientations as essential for creating classroom and school climates where diversity is positive and productive for all students, especially multilingual students.

However, participants also noted myriad barriers to the widespread implementation of the orientations of interconnectedness and openness. Specifically, issues in the larger sociopolitical context were invoked, like the impacts of social media, different policies impacting schools, teachers, and students, as well as the inability of school systems and structures to nimbly adjust to the rapidly changing student populations and world (like the changes experienced during the Covid-19 pandemic). These contextual aspects are particularly interesting since the study was conducted across multiple European countries and the US, thus offering important perspectives across varying national contexts. Participants also discussed challenges within schools like parental involvement and administrative support.

Finally, participants noted the tensions and paradoxes they experience seeking to orient their work around interconnectedness and openness, particularly concerning the extensive standardization of educational outcomes in the context of widespread diversity, inequitable supports, and narratives about 21st-century learning and differentiated instructional approaches. Participants articulated an ongoing tension of not being able to do the work of orienting themselves and their students towards interconnectedness and openness due to restraints created outside and inside of school, leading to frustration and considerations of leaving the profession. A small subgroup of teachers had experience working in spaces where they could orient their practice towards interconnectedness and openness and reported the value of working in such spaces for themselves and for students and their families. In such spaces, participants overwhelmingly noted the use of democratic practices for decision-making at both the classroom and school levels.


References
Gioia, D. A., Corley, K. G., & Hamilton, A. L. (2013). Seeking Qualitative Rigor in Inductive Research: Notes on the Gioia Methodology.
Hayes, K. & Kaba, M. (2023). Let this radicalize you: Organizing and the revolution of
reciprocal care. Haymarket Books.
Simpson, L. B. (2017). As we have always done: Indigenous freedom through radical resistance.
University of Minnesota Press.

Viesca, K. M., Alisaari, J., Flynn, N., Hammer, S., Lemmrich, S., Routarinne, S., & Teemant, A.
(In Press). Orientations for co-constructing a positive climate for diversity in
teaching and learning. In Teacher Education in (Post-) Pandemic Times: International Perspectives on Intercultural Learning, Diversity and Equity. Peter Lang.

Viesca, K.M., Strom, K., Hammer, S., Masterson, J., Linzell C.H., Mitchell-McCollough, J., &
Flynn, N. (2019). Developing a complex portrait of content teaching for multilingual learners via nonlinear theoretical understandings. Review of Research in Education, 43, 304-335. https://doi.org/10.3102/0091732X18820910
Witzel, A., & Reiter, H. (2012). The Problem-Centered Interview. SAGE Publications.


07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Paper

Maintaining the Ukrainian Language amidst Conflict: Evidence from Greek-Ukrainian Families

Christina Maligkoudi1, Aspasia Chatzidaki2

1Democritus University of Thrace, Greece; 2University of Crete, Greece

Presenting Author: Chatzidaki, Aspasia

In the past ten years, there has been a noticeable rise in studies investigating family language policies in immigrant groups and transnational, mixed-marriage families in Greece (e.g. Chatzidaki & Maligkoudi, 2013; Gogonas & Maligkoudi, 2020; Maligkoudi, 2019). This paper reports on a small-scale study focusing on family language policies in Greek-Ukrainian families living in the city of Thessaloniki, in Northern Greece.

The participants in our study are six Ukrainian mothers married to Greek citizens who have been living in Greece for five to 14 years; among them they have eight children between the ages of 5 to 14 which were born in Greece (with one exception). All mothers are highly-educated, multilingual individuals most of whom have occupations which exploit their ethnic and linguistic background. They have raised their children in two or three languages (Greek, Ukrainian and/or Russian), and are strong supporters of the maintenance and transmission of the Ukrainian language. They have also been actively involved in supporting the Ukrainian cause since the beginning of the war with Russia.

Our study is framed within a Family Language Policy (henceforth FLP) framework drawing from earlier (e.g. Curdt-Christiansen, 2009; King, Fogle & Logan-Terry, 2008; Spolsky, 2004; 2012) and more recent conceptualizations of the field which focus on meaning-making, experiences, agency, and identity constructions in transnational families (e.g. Curdt-Christiansen, 2018; Curdt-Christiansen & Lanza 2018; Fogle & King, 2013; King & Lanza, 2019; Smith-Christmas, 2019).

In particular, the aim of the study was to investigate the families’ language policies as revealed through an examination of the parents’ language practices and language ideologies and measures falling under the language management aspect of FLP (Spolsky, 2004; 2012). Following Curdt-Christiansen (2009; 2020), we deemed it important to take into consideration not only the language ideologies and patterns of communication among family members, but also factors such as the mothers’ educational background, personal language learning experiences, migrant profile, and the financial resources of the family.

Moreover, we wished to investigate how broader sociolinguistic issues impact these mothers’ choices, and, in particular, the stance our informants take with regard to the hotly debated issue of abandoning Russian as an everyday language in Ukraine. After Ukraine became an independent nation in 1991, a process of Ukrainisation was established, which entailed measures in favour of the Ukrainian language as a means to construct a new national identity (Seals & Beliaeva, 2023). However, a large segment of the population continued to use Russian instead of Ukrainian irrespective of their allegiance; apparently, for many Russian-speaking Ukrainians the Ukrainian language is not necessarily a token of nationhood and is not intricately linked to the Ukrainian identity (Bilaniuk, 2016; Kulyk 2016; 2018). However, in the aftermath of the political developments of the past ten years (the Euromaidan and the Revolution of Dignity in late 2013–2014, the annexation of Crimea by the Russians, the strife at the eastern border, and finally, the Russian invasion in 2022) there seems to be a rise in the number of people who call for the abandonment of the Russian language and the adoption of Ukrainian instead (Harrison, 2021; Seals & Beliaeva, 2023), a phenomenon some authors refer to as ‘linguistic conversion’ (Bilaniuk, 2020). In this context, we wished to examine how the six participants negotiate the ongoing changes in language ideologies and attitudes in Ukraine and the impact this may have had on their language policies with regard to the two languages.


Methodology, Methods, Research Instruments or Sources Used
The population we intended to study included mothers of Ukrainian origin who at the time of the study had been living in Greece for at least five years. The first author gained access to the community through her acquaintance with a mother to whom she had previously taught Greek. Using a ‘snowball’ approach, five more mothers were approached and agreed to take part in the study, after assurances of anonymity were given (pseudonyms are used and information about their studies or occupation is presented in as general terms as possible). The six participants were among a group of parents who, in the past few years, organized weekly meetings in order for their children to socialize with other Ukrainian speakers and be immersed in the Ukrainian language and culture through art and play. Since September 2022, this informal ‘club’ was transformed into a small community school for Greek-Ukrainian children operating at the weekend. The school is supported by an NGO (which offers their premises for the courses) while the staff offers their services on a voluntary basis. Children have the opportunity to take Ukrainian language courses and to experience the Ukrainian culture through playful and creative activities. The first author, who is also a member of an association promoting bilingualism among transnational families was invited to visit the school in this capacity and observe its functioning.  This also facilitated the participants’ recruitment, as it fostered a certain degree of familiarity with and involvement in their community,
Data collection was based on semi-structured interviews which took place in spring 2023 at the community school’s premises. The interview protocol comprised questions which dealt, first, with the mother’s educational background and current occupation and the family’s length of residence in Greece. Another set of questions referred to patterns of multilingualism in the family: who can speak which languages, which languages are used by whom to whom. There was a question regarding the child’s experiences at the Ukrainian school, and finally, a question which referred to probable changes in the mother’s linguistic behaviour in the aftermath of the recent political strife in Ukraine. The data is being analysed following ‘thematic analysis’ (Braun & Clarke, 2017).

Conclusions, Expected Outcomes or Findings
Some preliminary findings include the following:
With regard to practices aimed at supporting Ukrainian language development in their children, we found that, in most families, the parents followed a strict OPOL policy and provided plenty of meaningful input in Ukrainian, via exposure to print and media, and ensuring frequent contact with Ukrainian speakers. Two cases stand out, though, and prove the complexity of the situation; in one family the Greek father uses Russian with the children instead of Greek, while in another, the child was born in an Asian country and grew up speaking English, Russian and Greek, until the age of seven when the mother decided to switch to Ukrainian and stopped using Russian with her daughter.
With regard to language ideologies, all mothers agree on the importance of their children speaking Ukrainian as an integral part of their identity and heritage. They also seem to agree on viewing the mastery of many languages as an asset, drawing on  their own educational and professional experiences. However, the most interesting findings are those which emerge with regard to the linguistic conversion.  The six participants seem to represent various positions on a continuum which range between the uninhibited, continued use of Russian at home to taking distance from using this language. Some of the mothers link this stance to feelings of patriotism, even expressing feelings of guilt or shame for previously using the Russian language, while others seem to downplay the importance of rejecting the language, despite their feelings of loyalty to the Ukrainian nation.

References
Bilaniuk, L. (2020). Linguistic conversions: Nation-building on the self. Journal of Soviet and Post-Soviet Politics and Society, 6 (1), 59-82.
Braun, V. & Clarke, V. (2017). Thematic analysis. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 12(3), 297–298.
Chatzidaki, A., & Maligkoudi, C. (2013). Family language policies among Albanian immigrants in Greece. Ιnternational Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 16(6), 675-689. https://doi.org/10.1080/13670050.2012.709817 (first published online 2012)
Curdt-Christiansen, X.L. (2009). Invisible and visible language planning: ideological factors in the family language policy of Chinese immigrant families in Quebec. Language Policy, 8, 351–375.
Curdt-Christiansen, X.L. (2018). Family language policy. In J. Tollefson & M. Perez-Millans (Eds.), The Ox-ford handbook of language policy and planning (pp. 420-441). Oxford University Press.
Curdt-Christiansen, X. L. & Lanza, E. (2018). Language management in multilingual families: Efforts, measures and challenges. Multilingua, 37 (2), 123-130.
Curdt-Christiansen, X.L. (2020). Educating migrant children in England: language and educational practices in home and school environments. International Multilingual Research Journal, 14 (2), 163-180.
Fogle, L.W., & King, K. A. (2013). Child Agency and Language Policy in Transnational Families. Issues in Applied Linguistics, 19, 1-25. https://doi.org/10.5070/L4190005288
Gogonas, N. &  Maligkoudi, C. (2020): ‘Mothers have the power!’: Czech mothers’ language ideologies and management practices in the context of a Czech complementary school in Greece, International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, DOI: 10.1080/13670050.2020.1799324
Harrison K. (2021). ‘In Ukrainian, Please!’: Language Ideologies in a Ukrainian Complementary School. Languages, 6(4), 179.
King, K., Fogle, L. & Logan-Terry, A. (2008). Family Language Policy. Language and Linguistics Compass, 2(5), 907-922.
King, K., & Lanza, E. (2019). Ideology, agency, and imagination in multilingual families: An introduction. International Journal of Bilingualism, 23(3), 717-723.
Kulyk, V. (2018). Shedding Russianness, Recasting Ukrainianness: The Post-Euromaidan Dynamics of Ethnonational Identifications in Ukraine. Post-Soviet Affairs, 34, 119–38.
Μaligkoudi, C. (2019). Issues of Language Socialization and Language Acquisition Among Italians in Greece. Εducation Sciences, 2019(2), 149–165. https://doi.org/10.26248/.v2019i2.596 [in Greek]
Seals, C. & Beliaeva, N. (2023). Aspirational family language policy. Language Policy 22, 501–521. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10993-023-09674-3
Smith-Christmas, C. (2019). When X doesn’t mark the spot: the intersection of language shift, identity and family language policy. International Journal of the Sociology of Language, 255, 133-158.
Spolsky, B. (2004). Language Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Spolsky, B. (2012). What Is Language Policy? In B. Spolsky (Ed.), The Cambridge Handbook of Language Policy (pp. 3-15). Cambridge University Press.
 
Date: Friday, 30/Aug/2024
9:30 - 11:0007 SES 14 B: Mapping the Hidden Journey: Hope, Vulnerabilities, and Uncertainties in Participatory (Action) Research
Location: Room 117 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [Floor 1]
Session Chair: Ines Alves
Panel Discussion
 
07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Panel Discussion

Mapping the Hidden Journey: Hope, Vulnerabilities, and Uncertainties in Participatory (Action) Research

Lingyi Chu1, Jacqueline Hackl2, Constanza Cardenas3, Michael Doblmair2

1Vytautas Magnus University; 2University of Vienna; 3University of Glasgow

Presenting Author: Chu, Lingyi; Hackl, Jacqueline; Cardenas, Constanza; Doblmair, Michael

The purpose of methodology in social research is to be able to understand research methods and their reasoning. The word method comes from the Greek: meta ta hodos, “to follow a path”. While in empirical social research the path was usually thought out and planned before the start of a journey, Participatory Action Research (PAR) cannot plan this path in advance, because the purpose of PAR is to find ways collectively in the double hope that the path was feasible in terms of the research, but above all that this path can initiate the desired change through the research.

While after the years of 1968 the focus of the research communities was on changing the world, the focus was on the word ‘Action’. So questions like, how to change the world as social scientists or what role social scientists play in changing the world. The new uprising of the last decade of the then so called action research (Lewin, 1946) placed the focus on the participation of non-academics in academic research (Lenette, 2022). Questions, like whose knowledge is present at the universities, who has a role in picking or producing knowledge in academia, came up front. The panelists came together in last years ECER events around a shared interest in such questions around PAR and social inequalities and continued to exchange afterwards. This panel is hence a collaborative reflection of different dimensions of participatory research as an articulated need for an alternative way to do research on co-creating a process with groups in participatory research while we manoeuvre academic demands- a part of the research journey which is not usually shown in conferences. We hope to display this juggling of priorities that we do as academics, area experts, teachers and/or students while we navigate societal/ institutional hierarchy, power relations, expectations, and unwritten rules.

Through perspectives of different research projects across Europe, all of us are tracing considerations in those processes - not just the conscious decision but also making sense of influences, positionalities, localities, etc. At the same time, we seek that our reflections can resonate with the audience's experience, contributing to unravelling their hidden journey as researchers.

Constanza Cárdenas Alarcón will develop the idea of uncertainty and vulnerability as a researcher in her study about inclusive curriculum made by teachers in Chile. How do we comply with the plan before you have a plan?

As Lingyi Chu's narrative research on cross-cultural youths’ transitional care leans onto the community as co-researchers, she questions how space, context, and identity play together in shaping her intercorporeality over her status of a shifting “in-out-sider” (Zhao, 2017)”. An ongoing concern: How does the researcher being a visible minority influence multicultural encountering when researching identity and belonging matters in a homogeneous context?

As Jacqueline Hackl uses Collective Memory Work (Haug 2000) - a hegemony critical research, education and political method using memory scenes to work on transformatory possibilities in a collective - when researching discrimination experiences in education, she reflects on how her methodological/methodical choices and considerations are linked to her positionality. One question that follows: How can we widen or intervene in what is possible with(in) educational research?

Michael Doblmair seeks opportunities for participation of co-researchers in research collaboration in political struggles. As an activist researcher (Ulrich 2019) he addresses the notion ‘Action’ in his PAR. He will focus on grouping processes in Action Research. As in voluntary political activities groups are seldomly consistent, we constantly have to ask: How can we achieve participation, continuity and consens in constantly changing groups?


References
Haug, F. (2000). Sexualization of the female body. Verso.
Lenette, C. (2022). Participatory Action Research. Oxford University Press.
Lewin, K. (1946). Action Research and Minority Problems. Journal of Social Issues, 2, 34-46.
Ullrich, P. (2019). Protestforschung zwischen allen Stühlen. Ein Versuch über die Sozialfigur des “Protestforschers”. Forschungsjournal Soziale Bewegungen. 32.Jahrgang, Heft 1. 29-40.
Zhao, Y. (2017). Doing fieldwork the Chinese way: A returning researcher's insider/outsider status in her home town. Area, 49(2), 185–191. https://doi.org/10.1111/area.12314.

Chair
Ines Alves, University of Glasgow, Ines.Alves@glasgow.ac.uk
 
11:30 - 13:0007 SES 16 B: *** CANCELLED *** Teachers of Colour, Minority & Indigenous Teachers and Teacher Mobility: Continuities and Futures in Educational Research
Location: Room 117 in ΧΩΔ 02 (Common Teaching Facilities [CTF02]) [Floor 1]
Session Chair: Lisa Rosen
Session Chair: Lisa Rosen
Symposium
 
07. Social Justice and Intercultural Education
Symposium

Teachers of Colour, Minority & Indigenous Teachers and Teacher Mobility: Continuities and Futures in Educational Research

Chair: Mary Gutman (Michlalah-Jerusalem College; Orot-Israel Academic College of Education)

Discussant: Mary Gutman (Michlalah-Jerusalem College; Orot-Israel Academic College of Education)

In the rapidly evolving landscape of education and growing educational inequalities, the need to maintain diversity and inclusive practices has never been more important. "Teachers of Colour, Minority and Indigenous Teachers: Continuities and Futures in Educational Research" is a symposium that aims to explore the diversity of staffrooms in shaping the educational landscape, addressing challenges such as (linguistic) racism, and fostering a more just and resilient future.

Structural inequalities and the perpetuation of systems of power that maintain racial hierarchies in schools across Europe and beyond are a common starting point. Related, overarching questions focus on how institutional practices, policies and cultures within education systems contribute to the marginalisation or empowerment of minority teachers. In addition, counter-narratives that challenge dominant racial ideologies are explored by highlighting the voices of teachers who resist racial inequalities, thereby providing a broader understanding of how individuals navigate and challenge discriminatory practices.

The symposium brings together four contributions to what has now become an important and wide-ranging field of educational research (see Gist & Bristol, 2022; Gutman et al., 2023). Each contribution addresses unique aspects of diversity within the teaching profession and its impact on the educational landscape:

Paper 1 emphasises the importance of a diverse teaching workforce in actively challenging and unlearning stereotypical prejudices in South Africa. It examines how schools can become cultivated sites where diverse teachers and learners can serve as valuable opportunities and encounters for unlearning the epistemic damage of stereotypical biases and myths.

Paper 2 explores the perceptions of minority pre-service teachers on the integration of artificial intelligence (AI) in Israeli teacher education. This aspect of diversity involves the intersection of technology and education, emphasizing the importance of considering the diversity of pre-service teachers when incorporating AI applications in teacher education programs.

Paper 3 focuses on the biographical narratives of minority pre-service teachers who bring multilingualism into the classroom. On the one hand, it sheds light on the ambivalences that arise when they hardly distance themselves from the monoglossic language ideologies of the German school system. On the other hand, it highlights their potential to combat linguistic racism.

Paper 4 investigates the impact of study abroad experiences on the perceptions of diversity and inclusion among in-service teachers in Japan. Findings reveal that while participants recognize alternative practices for inclusion, they struggle with effectively implementing change within the existing school culture, balancing their commitment to diversity with the pressure to conform to prevailing norms.

Together, these four papers contribute to the broader conversation about the importance of teachers of colour, minority and indigenous teachers, and teacher mobility, in shaping a more inclusive and socially just education system in Europe and beyond.


References
Gist, C.D., & Bristol, T.J. (Eds.). (2022). Handbook on Teachers of Color and Indigenous Teachers. American Educational Research Association.
Gutman, M., Jayusi, W., Beck, M., & Bekerman, Z. (Eds). (2023). To Be a Minority Teacher in a Foreign Culture. Empirical Evidence from an International Perspective. Springer.

 

Presentations of the Symposium

 

The Importance of Teacher Diversity for Unlearning Stereotypical Biases and Harm

Nuraan Davids (Stellenbosch University)

The commitment by some historically ‘white’ schools in post-apartheid South Africa to retain their historical identity and privilege is especially evident in two discernible, yet inter-related paradigms. The more prominent one concerns the slow pace of learner diversity, while the other relates to the starkly neglected matter of teacher diversity. While historically excluded ‘black’ learners are kept at bay via the emergence of a new race-class discourse, ‘black’ teachers are excluded through an ambiguous language of ‘qualified, but incompetent’. Incompetency derives from one or several intersectional identity markers, which can include anything from culture, ethnicity, religion, sexuality, class, to qualification and knowledge, ultimately casting diverse teacher identities in images of mistrust. Of interest to this paper, on the one hand, is a seemingly a priori association of competence, as well as unquestioning trust coupled with ‘white’ teachers. While on the other hand, ‘black’ teachers are treated with suspicion and mistrust, not only because of their presumed incompetence, but because of who they are and the kinds of knowledge they stand to bring. What, therefore, is the role of schools in disrupting the binary between ‘white’-competence-trust’ and ‘black’-incompetence-mistrust? And how might schools become cultivated sites where diverse teacher and learner cohorts can serve as valuable opportunities and encounters for unlearning the epistemic harm of stereotypical biases and myths?

References:

Hunter, M. (2016). The Race for Education: Class, White Tone, and Desegregated Schooling in South Africa. Journal of Historical Sociology, 29 (3), 319–358 Ingersoll, R., May, H. & Collins, G. (2019). Recruitment, employment, retention and the minority teacher shortage. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 27(37), 1-37. Kohli, R. & Pizarro, M. (2016) Fighting to educate our own: Teachers of color, relational accountability, and the struggle for racial justice. Equity & Excellence in Education, 49(1), 72–84. Sleeter, C. E. (2001). Preparing teachers for culturally diverse schools research and the overwhelming presence of whiteness. Journal of Teacher Education, 52(2), 94–106. Teeger, C. (2015). Ruptures in the Rainbow Nation: How Desegregated South African Schools Deal with Interpersonal and Structural Racism. Sociology of Education, 88 (3), 226–243.
 

WITHDRAWN Perceptions of Minority Pre-service Teachers in Academic Institution of the Integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) Applications in the Teacher

Orit Avidov-Ungar (Achva Academic College)

During these days there is growing interest in the use of artificial intelligence (AI) applications in the education world (Celik, 2023; Păvăloaia & Necula, 2023). The academic institutions for teacher training carry out procedures for the integration of these applications in the teaching and learning of students. In this framework, the pre-service teachers at the academic institution who come from different sectors: Arab, Jewish, Christian, and ultra-Orthodox were exposed to practical lectures and workshops on the integration of AI applications in education. The research used a mixed method approach using qualitative and quantitative analysis. This paradigm calls for an in-depth examination of investigated phenomena through qualitative analysis but also enables data quantification to examine general trends through quantitative analysis. Two research tools were used: (1) a reflective protocol (2) a questionnaire regarding the dimensions of pre-service teachers' use of AI tools. The analysis of the study reveals six main categories: 1) the contribution of the exposure to AI applications; 2) AI applications and their use in teaching-learning; 3) reducing gaps between the students with the use of AI applications; 5) assessing the use of AI applications; 6) skills acquired with the use of AI applications. This research provides an understanding of the pre-service teachers from a multicultural academic institution's perception regarding the uses of AI in the early stages of their teaching, and its main uniqueness. In light of this, these findings help policymakers in teacher training in academic institutions from two main perspectives: policy aspects – it offers a comprehensive, wide, and multicultural perspective regarding the various ways in which students use AI applications and their perspective, and teacher training process and the scaffolding that students from a different background and culture need for establishing their role as future teachers in AI era.

References:

Celik, I. (2023). Towards Intelligent-TPACK: An empirical study on teachers’ professional knowledge to ethically integrate artificial intelligence (AI)-based tools into education. Computers in Human Behavior, 138, 107468. Păvăloaia, V. D., & Necula, S. C. (2023). Artificial intelligence as a disruptive technology—a systematic literature review. Electronics, 12(5), 1102.
 

“My Multilingualism is Quite Advantageous” – Minority Pre-service Teachers Encounter Monoglossic Language Ideologies in German Schools

Lisa Rosen (University of Kaiserslautern-Landau)

Research on minority (pre-service) teachers in Germany dates back to the first decade after the turn of the millennium (Lengyel & Rosen, 2015, p. 162). However, there is a lack of research in this area, which contrasts with education policy that has long since developed a strategy for recruiting minority teachers. According to education policy, minority teachers posses specific competencies due to their own or their families' migration experiences, and as such are bridge-builders, integration facilitators, etc., who contribute to reducing educational inequalities in the German school system. Migration researchers in educational science in Germany are critical of this ethnicization as it promotes stigmatization and deprofessionalization (see Goltsev et al., 2023, p. 128; Rosen & Jacob, 2023). In a recent literature review on minority teachers in Germany, multilingualism was identified as one of four research foci (Rosen & Lengyel, 2023). This paper focuses on biographical perspectives towards monoglossic language ideologies (Thoma, 2022), building on an exploratory finding from this review that minority (student) teachers exhibit ambivalence towards multilingual language practices in school. This paper uses biographical narrative interviews with plurilingual student teachers (n=10) to investigate the impact of past school experiences on their professional identities in relation to multilingualism. The research question is: What is the impact of past school experiences on student teachers' views of multilingual practices in future schools? The Grounded Theory analysis (according to Charmaz, 2014) shows that the minority student teachers hold 'one-language-at-a-time monolingual ideologies' (Wei, 2018, p. 16): Because they believe that it was acceptable to be asked to act monolingually in their previous schooling and plan to continue to do so as teachers, they do not distance themselves from the monoglossic language ideologies of the German school system. This is theorised in relation to the concept of linguicism (Skutnabb-Kangas, 2015) and a raciolinguistic perspective (Rosa & Flores, 2020), and discussed in relation to findings that consider students' perspectives. Here, studies show that multilingual students who have experienced that 'my teacher had an accent too' see themselves as legitimate members of a linguistically heterogeneous community (Putjata, 2019), pointing to the potential of multilingual minority teachers to combat linguistic racism.

References:

Lengyel, D. & Rosen, L. (2015). Diversity in the staff room – Ethnic minority student teachers’ perspectives on the recruitment of minority teachers. In Tertium Comparationis, 21(2), 161–184. Putjata, G. (2019). Language in transnational education trajectories between the Soviet Union, Israel and Germany. In Diskurs Kindheits- und Jugendforschung 4, 390–404. Rosa, J., & Flores, N. (2020). Reimagining Race and Language: From Raciolinguistic Ideologies to a Raciolinguistic Perspective. In H. Samy Alim et al. (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Language and Race (pp. 90-107). Oxford University Press. Rosen, L. & Lengyel, D. (2023). Research on Minority Teachers in Germany. In M. Gutman et al. (eds.): To be a Minority Teacher in a Foreign Culture (pp. 107–123). Springer. Rosen, Lisa & Jacob, Marita (2022). Diversity in the Teachers’ Lounge in Germany – Casting Doubt on the Statistical Category of “Migration Background”. In European Educational Research Journal, 21(2), 312-329. Skutnabb‐Kangas, T. (2015). Linguicism. In Carol A. Chapelle (ed.), The encyclopedia of applied linguistics (pp. 1–6). Wiley. Thoma, N. (2022). Biographical perspectives on language ideologies in teacher education. In Language and Education, 36(5), 419-436. Wei, Li (2018). Translanguaging as a Practical Theory of Language. Applied Linguistics 39 (1), 9–30.
 

Are Global Perspectives Appreciated? How Teachers with Abroad Experience are Treated at Schools in Japan

Naomi Kagawa (Shimane University)

The purpose of this paper is to examine the influence of the study abroad experience on teachers’ perceptions about diversity and inclusion at schools. It examines how these teachers are minoritized as outsiders who bring in unnecessary challenges to schools. As a theoretical framework, this research adopted Functional Context Theory of Learning (Sticht, 1975). The theory regards learning as information processing, in which the learners actively look for information and use it to construct a meaningful interpretation of the world. These interpretations lead to the knowledge base, with which learners further interpretate new incoming information. In this research, the study abroad program, that are intended to build a global view, is predicted to change teachers’ way of processing information. Consequently, the teachers with study abroad experiences are hypothesized to have unique perspectives on the issues and challenges that schools are facing, including the diversity and inclusion issue. In terms of methodology, in-service teachers in Japan who had participated in a four-week study abroad programme as part of their teacher education training programme between 2015 and 2020 were invited to complete a survey and follow-up interview. The survey and interviews focused on the participants' perceptions of diversity and inclusion issues in schools, as well as how they believed their views on these issues were treated among teachers. As can be seen from the results, the returning teachers who took part in the study reported that they had experienced a unique struggle. Although they can see an alternative way of practicing inclusion at schools, they do not necessarily know an effective way to make changes in the current school culture. While they care about diversity and inclusion of students and teachers, they also feel their need to fit in to the current teachers’ culture by acting as if they care more about uniformity.

References:

Sticht, T. (1975). Reading for working: A functional literacy anthology. Alexandria: Human Resources Research Organization.
 

 
Contact and Legal Notice · Contact Address:
Privacy Statement · Conference: ECER 2024
Conference Software: ConfTool Pro 2.6.153+TC
© 2001–2025 by Dr. H. Weinreich, Hamburg, Germany